On Chinese Part of Speech and Its Characteristics in Western Sinology among 17-19 Century
Huanhai Fang,Fan Qu,Ye Yin,Yumeng Wang
2014-01-01
Abstract:INTRODUCTIONThere have been discussions on content words and function words for the Chinese part of speech in Ancient China, but their definitions were uncertain. Furthermore, Chinese grammar research was not important in traditional Chinese Language Study and most of these was to help to understand Confucian classics. Thereby, local Chinese grammar research, which served people to interpret the meaning of poems and essays in perspective of rhetoric, was affiliated to the extent of Exegetics from the beginning.As the beginning works for local Chinese grammar, Mashi Wentong((ProQuest: ... denotes non-USASCII text omitted.), 1898) classified words into two types: content words and function words. Nouns, pronouns, descriptive words (such as adjectives), verbs and adverbs belonged to content words; prepositions, conjunctions, auxiliary words and interjections belong to function words. In the perspective of the development for Chinese Linguistics, Lv Shuxiang and Wan Haifen thought Ma Jianzhong initialized the process of introducing content words and function words into grammar research2. Actually, Ma Jianzhong totally classified words according to the Latin grammar system. Despite using Chinese as the research material, these analyses were almost irrelevant with Chinese in terms of the essence of theory systerm. No matter how proficient Ma Jianzhong was in Latin grammar research, his grasp for Latin assumedly could not be compared with that of western scholars', given that Latin isn't his mother tongue, let alone Ma Jianzhong's research material was classical Chinese. So it is an interesting academic phenomenon for Chinese academia to neglect the fact that there has been so many western scholars focusing on the research for the classification of modem Chinese words and their materials of Chinese language is real. If we slightly expand our horizons into Western Sinology, we can find that there had been discussions on Chinese nouns, verbs, pronouns, prepositions, adverbs, interjections, conjunctions in Italian Missionary Martino Martini 's book Grammatica Sinica (1653).Existing in unique forms, these Chinese researches of Western Sinology connected Chinese Linguistics with European Sinology, prompted the academic construction of Chinese Linguistics system by the collision and interconnection of Sino-Westem linguistic ideas, and also pushed the subject development of European Sinology. Therefore they are of a special significance in terms of academic history. How to conduct dialogues between Chinese Linguistics researches and western ones? How to locate the study position for characteristics of Chinese part of speech? Though there had been no debates in academia, scholars advocated they should be skeptical about others' views, but also shouldn't confuse others with personal opinions. However, it is worth pondering about how to establish our own academic role in the Sino-Westem linguistic dialogue. As we show, most of the Chinese research results, found by western Missionaries and Sinologists, are kept in European Sinology literatures except for some monographs. Therefore, this paper aims to investigate the evolutionary course about researches done on Chinese part of speech in Western Sinology, analyze how the Sinologists think about the characteristics of Chinese part of speech under their Indo-European background, and then reveal the characteristic awareness in the Chinese research of Western Sinology.OVERVIEWS ON THE CHINESE PART OF SPEECH IN WESTERN SINOLOGYIn the views of early western scholars, Chinese is a special language and their attitudes towards it varied - those resenting it thought no language was more primeval or difficult than Chinese; those loving it regarded it as the template of ideal language and characters, because Chinese was close to the mind and in accordance with the essence of things. For these reasons, whatever aims they held, even with colonialism factors, Westerners continued to investigate the characteristics of Chinese Grammar in the last 300 years with hundreds of works coming into being, as we can see from the main grammar monograph list below:Apart from these listed monographs, there were some textbooks which fell in the category of grammar books as well. …