Abstract:During the 11 th and 12th FiveYear Plan periods (FYP),China's emission reduction indexes,such as per unit GDP energy consumption,sulfur dioxide (SO2) and chemical oxygen demand (COD) emissions,have all reached the expected targets,posing a sharp contrast with the failures of those goals in the 10th FYP.Current studies have the inconformity for the explanation of such phenomenon at both macro and micro levels.Major reason for such difference maybe the fact that current research tends to attribute the improvement on environment governance solely to the impact of formal institutions but ignores the positive effects resulting from informal institutions.This paper conducts an empirical research from frame of principal-agent model which contains both formal and informal incentives,to test our argument.Hinged on the data of 717 questionnaires from government officials at different levels and tested with structural equation model (SEM),this study shows that the 11 incentives created by formal institutions have no significant influence on officials' environmental governance performance.Obedience to the central government's guidance and superior officials' attention,those incentives from informal institutions,are found to have significant impacts on the improvement.There are two approaches for informal institution to exert its impacts on environmental governance.In the first approach,the feeling of pressure among local officials becomes a mediator variable between informal institutions and officials' environmental governance performance.Officials' promotion preference and obedience preference are positive adjustment variables,where the strictness of implementing formal rulesis a negative adjustment variable.The effect of informal institutions increases as officials have stronger promotion preference and the strictness of formal incentives implementation declines.The mediate effect of pressure is positively influenced by officers' obedience preference.In the second pathway,informal institution could also affect environmental performance directly and is adjusted by officers' service preference.Stronger such preference to be,more influential of informal incentives would be.These findings help us to renew our theoretical knowledge of China's policy implementation and government official incentives by explaining the previous theoretical paradox and providing empirical evidence of how China's pressure-driven system operates.

Performance Ranking and Environmental Governance: An Empirical Study of the Mandatory Target System: Performance Ranking and Environmental Governance

Mandatory Targets and Environmental Performance: an Analysis Based on Regression Discontinuity Design

Environmental Performance Rating and Disclosure: China's GreenWatch Program

Bureaucratic Ranking Event and Implementing of Environmental Policy: Empirical Research Based on Performance of Mandatory Environment Index

Performance management and environmental governance in China

Environmental Target and Government Performance in China

Multi-Tasking Policy Coordination and Corporate Environmental Performance: Evidence from China

Assessing the Administrative Practice of Environmental Protection Performance Evaluation in China: the Case of Shenzhen

The drivers of local environmental policy in China: An analysis of Shenzhen’s environmental performance management system, 2007–2015

Information, Incentives, and Environmental Governance: Evidence from China's Ambient Air Quality Standards

Environmental Performance Measurement of Power Sector Based on Data Envelopment Analysis

Heterogeneous performances and consequences of China's industrial environmental governance: clean production vs. end-of-pipe treatment

Tournament incentives and environmental performance: the role of green innovation

Local government competition, environmental regulation, and green development in China: Empirical analysis based on regional heterogeneity and path mechanisms

Heterogeneous performances and consequences of China’s industrial environmental governance: clean production vs. end-of-pipe treatment

Environmental governance, executive incentive, and enterprise performance: Evidence from Chinese mineral enterprises

Environmental Regulation, Factor Marketisation Allocation and Carbon Emissions Performance: Empirical Evidence from Resource-Based Cities in China

Environmental Regulations, Technical Progress and Corporate Performance: Empirical Study Based on Chinese Provincial Panel Data

Invisible economy, performance assessment of local governments, and environmental regulation in China

Career concerns and multitasking local bureaucrats: Evidence of a target-based performance evaluation system in China

Is stronger punishment and reward system the main reason for improving environment performance in China?