Abstract:To tackle serious environmental problems and overcome the negative impact of an almost exclusively Gross Domestic Product (GDP) oriented performance management, a number of local governments in China have started to establish and promote Environmental Protection Performance Evaluation (EPPE) systems for their cadres since the early 2000s. How these systems work in practice within their wider administrative context has not been examined so far. This paper makes a first attempt to assess the efficacy of this EPPE system by looking at its indicator system, the policy process around it, its political implications, and its actual environmental consequences. It does so for the case of Shenzhen, one of China's most forward-looking cities in terms of socio-economic development and political reform. We find that the system can be flexibly used and does push environmental interests higher up the agenda of the local government, but is negatively affected by high levels of uncertainty in its actual use and the strict hierarchy of its application. The main impact of EPPE is on the impression municipal leaders have of the evaluated cadres and on their reputation among their peers, both indirect factors for their political career and thus incentives for the local environmental management. Empirical data show that Shenzhen's environmental quality has not changed significantly in the past five years, although an overall improvement should have been visible if the EPPE systems worked as intended. From this perspective, the efficacy of the EPPE system remains low. At the end a number of policy recommendations are given to enhance the system's effectiveness and fairness.

Mandatory Targets and Environmental Performance: an Analysis Based on Regression Discontinuity Design

Performance Ranking and Environmental Governance: An Empirical Study of the Mandatory Target System: Performance Ranking and Environmental Governance

Environmental Target and Government Performance in China

Minimum Performance Target as a Response to Multitasking Problems: Theory and Evidence from China's Air Quality Controls

Performance management and environmental governance in China

Bureaucratic Ranking Event and Implementing of Environmental Policy: Empirical Research Based on Performance of Mandatory Environment Index

Multi-Tasking Policy Coordination and Corporate Environmental Performance: Evidence from China

Career concerns and multitasking local bureaucrats: Evidence of a target-based performance evaluation system in China

Assessing the Administrative Practice of Environmental Protection Performance Evaluation in China: the Case of Shenzhen

Do environmental target constraints promote corporate pollution reduction?

Research on Implementation Effectiveness of Command-and-Control Environmental Regulations: Evidence from the Basin Ecological Compensation Policy of China

Accountability, Career Incentives, and Pollution: The Case Of Two Control Zones in China

Heterogeneous performances and consequences of China's industrial environmental governance: clean production vs. end-of-pipe treatment

The drivers of local environmental policy in China: An analysis of Shenzhen’s environmental performance management system, 2007–2015

Heterogeneous performances and consequences of China’s industrial environmental governance: clean production vs. end-of-pipe treatment

How Does Target-Based Performance Evaluation Affect the Accuracy of Energy-Saving Data: Evidence From China

Environmental Policies of Local Governments: An Panel Data Analysis of SO2 Abatement

The Impact of Local Government Environmental Target Constraints on the Performance of Heavy Pollution Industries

Can the Target Responsibility System of Air Pollution Control Achieve a Win-Win Situation of Pollution Reduction and Efficiency Enhancement?

The environmental cost of tax administration: evidence from a regression discontinuity design in China

Does strict environmental regulation lead to incentive contradiction? - Evidence from China