Abstract:Introduction: Criminal convictions may be imperfect markers of criminalized behavior, in part because of criminal legal system processes (e.g., plea bargaining). In this retrospective cohort study of individuals convicted of misdemeanors, authors compared the risk of subsequent criminal charges for a violent crime among those initially charged with a felony with that among those initially charged with only misdemeanors, overall and by defendant race and ethnicity. Methods: The study population included individuals aged ≥18 years who were convicted of a misdemeanor in Washington Superior Courts from January 1, 2015 to December 31, 2019. Those with and without initial felony charges were age/gender matched in a 4:1 ratio. The primary outcome was the first subsequent violent crime charge in Washington Superior Courts through December 31, 2020. Data were analyzed with Fine-Gray hazard models from June 2022 to November 2023. Results: There were 3,841 individuals with initial felony charges and 956 with initial misdemeanor charges only. Median follow-up was 2.4 years for both groups. During follow-up, there were 166 new violent crime charges. In multivariable models, White defendants with initial felony charges had a greater risk of subsequent violent crime charges (subdistribution hazard ratio=2.58; 95% CI=1.24, 5.36) than White defendants with initial misdemeanor charges only. Among Black and Hispanic/Latinx defendants, initial felony versus misdemeanor charges were not associated with subsequent violent crime charges (subdistribution hazard ratio=0.93; 95% CI=0.44, 1.97 among Black defendants; subdistribution hazard ratio=0.49; 95% CI=0.15, 1.57 among Hispanic/Latinx defendants). Conclusions: Findings suggest differential associations between downgrading of felony charges to misdemeanor convictions and future violent crime charges by defendant race and ethnicity, with implications for inequitable collateral consequences of criminal convictions.

Citizenship, Legal Status, and Federal Sentencing Outcomes: Examining the Moderating Effects of Age, Gender, and Race/Ethnicity

Sentencing and State-Level Racial and Ethnic Contexts

Evidence-based sentencing: Public openness and opposition to using gender, age, and race as risk factors for recidivism.

Assessing Cumulative Disadvantage Against Minority Female Defendants in State Courts

Assessing the Differential Effects of Race and Ethnicity on Sentence Outcomes under Different Sentencing Systems

A Multilevel Test of Minority Threat Effects on Sentencing

Discrimination in Sentencing: Showing Remorse and the Intersection of Race and Gender

Examining the Impact of Ecological Contexts on Gender Disparity in Federal Sentencing

Revisiting the Minority Threat Perspective: Examining the Main and Interactive Effects of Segregation on Sentencing Severity

Examining the Direct and Interactive Effects of Changes in Racial and Ethnic Threat on Sentencing Decisions

The Effect of Legal Status on Prison Misconduct

The role of perceived defendant criminality on attributions and case outcomes

Attitudes Toward Hispanic Immigrants and Immigration Policies in the United States: Exploring the Roles of Age and Framing Through a Survey Experiment

The judicial superego: Implicit egoism, internalized racism, and prejudice in three million sentencing decisions

Legal and Extra-Legal Factors Related to the Imposition of Blended Sentences

Racial Sentencing Disparities and Differential Progression Through the Criminal Justice System: Evidence From Linked Federal and State Court Data

Juvenile Justice System Outcomes Among Foreign-Born and Native-Born Latinos in the United States

Sex Differences in the Effects of Adverse Childhood Experiences on Institutional Misconduct among Adults in Prison

Cohort Study of Downgraded Misdemeanor Convictions and Subsequent Violent Crime: Differences by Defendant Race and Ethnicity

Impact of risk assessment on judges' fairness in sentencing relatively poor defendants

Crimmigrating Narratives: Examining Third-Party Observations of US Detained Immigration Court