NBER WORKING PAPER SERIES EXPORTING FROM CHINA: THE DETERMINANTS OF TRADE STATUS
Cooper,Ping Yan,Guan Gong,Guanliang Hu
Abstract:This paper studies the exporting decision of Chinese manufacturing firms. The economic framework stresses the dynamic decision by both state controlled and private entities to export in a model with labor adjustment costs. In this complex environment, a simple decision rule whereby export status depends only on current productivity does not hold. Nor does this rule match data patterns. The estimated model is used to understand the factors that influence export status. The analysis highlights the economic significance of labor adjustment costs in shaping both employment and trade dynamics. 1 Motivation China is the largest exporting country in the world. In 2019, its exports of goods reached a record high of almost 2.5 trillion U.S. dollars, accounting for 13% of goods exports in the world and around 20% of China’s GDP.1 At the plant level, China’s exporters do not fit neatly into the standard patterns documented in the literature. First, although China’s exporters are on average relatively larger, they are typically not more productive. Second, ownership plays a prominent role in exporting. Privately controlled firms are more likely to export and those that do sell most of their output in the foreign market. In contrast, state controlled export less frequently and earn a smaller share abroad. This paper asks: what are the determinants of trade status? A simple and forceful answer is productivity: high productivity firms are exporters, others only sell domestically. But, at least for China, this simple prediction is inconsistent with the data. Figure 1 shows the distributions of the average (revenue) productivity of labor across manufacturing plants in China, by ownership.2 The left panel displays the distribution for exporters and non-exporters of state controlled enterprises, hereafter SCE, while the right focuses on privately controlled enterprises, hereafter PCE. ⇤Department of Economics, European University Institute; Department of Economics, Pennsylvania State University; Research Associate, NBER, russellcoop@gmail.com †School of Economics, Shanghai University of Finance and Economics ‡Department of Economics, Pennsylvania State University §CCER, National School of Development, Peking University Data are from China trade statistics released by World Bank: https://wits.worldbank.org/CountryProfile/en/CHN. Details of the data underlying this figure are provided in Section 2. 1
Economics