Abstract:A unanimous finding in the literature on firm heterogeneity and exporting behavior is that exporters are more productive than non-exporters. Subsequent empirical studies reveal that more productive firms self-select their status as exporters in the presence of fixed costs for exporting, thereby explaining the positive correlation between firm productivity and exporting behavior. Using data from China's Annual Survey of Industrial firms from 1998 to 2005, however, we find strikingly different patterns of firm productivity and exporting behavior between China's indigenous firms and foreign multinationals operating in China. Among China's indigenous firms, exporters are indeed more productive than non-exporters, and the more productive firms self-select their status as exporters. But the results for foreign multinationals are just the opposite: exporters are less productive than non-exporters, and the less productive firms self-select their status as exporters. We then propose an explanation to the contrasting findings between China's indigenous firms and foreign multinationals by expanding the scope of firm heterogeneity from mere firm productivity differences to include differences in the fixed costs of exporting relative to local sales across firms of different national origins.

Does Export Improve Productivity? Firm-level Evidence from China's Manufacturing Sector

Does Export Trade Improve Firms' Productivity in China?──Based on the Data of Manufacturing Enterprises in 2007

Do Exports Generate A Continuous Productivity Growth? Evidence from Chinese Industrial Firms

Exporters' Environmental Premium in a Developing Country: Firm‐level Evidence from China

Export,Heterogeneity,and Corporate Productivity:Evidence from Enterprises in China

Review of the Relationship between the Export Behavior and Productivity in Chinese Enterprises:2001—2007

Do Domestic and Foreign Exporters Differ in Learning by Exporting? Evidence from China

Pre-Export R&D, Exporting and Productivity Gains: Evidence from Chinese Firms

Export and Productivity of Enterprises: Based on the Data of Chinese Listed Enterprises in Manufacturing Industry

Exports, ownership and firm productivity: Evidence from China

Trade Liberalization and Productivity:Evidence from Chinese Firms

Firm heterogeneity and exporting behavior: Evidence from China's manufacturing firms

The Productivity Puzzle of Chinese Exporters: Perspectives of Local Protection and Spillover Effects

Internet Penetration and Multi‐product Exporters: Firm‐level Evidence from China

Learning by exporting effect in China revisited: An instrumental Approach

The “productivity Paradox” of Chinese Export Firms: Review and Assessment

Internet Use and Export Upgrading: Firm‐level Evidence from China

Chinese Export Firms' 'productivity Paradox' and Its Explanations

Do Export Demand Shocks Affect the Export Quality of Multi‐product Firms? Evidence from China

Learning from Exporting in China