Abstract:Abstract Background Poor air quality is the one of the biggest causes of early death and illness across the lifespan. In the UK, 28 local authorities with illegal pollution levels have been mandated by the Government to develop plans to rapidly reduce pollution to legal limits. These plans include consideration of implementing one of four of charging 'Clean Air Zone’ (CAZ) classes in areas of high pollution which would charge older polluting vehicles a daily charge to enter. While this offers a potential to improve air quality, the extent to which CAZ might impact (for example, economically) on socio-economically deprived groups and local businesses is unclear. Aims To explore the acceptability and perceived unintended consequences of a CAZ and other initiatives to improve air quality with seldom-heard communities living in deprived, multi-ethnic areas within the city of Bradford, UK. Methods Ten semi-structured focus groups were conducted with people who live in areas of high pollution and deprivation. A total of 87 people participated from a diverse range of ethnic backgrounds with the majority of Pakistani origin. Recorded data were transcribed, coded and analysed using thematic analysis. Findings As poor air quality was not always visible it was seen as a hidden issue by many, and not prioritised over other more visible environmental issues (e.g. fly-tipping, littering). There was resistance to proposals which included charging private vehicles. Many felt that low-income families did not have the resources to purchase compliant vehicles or pay daily charges, placing a disproportionate burden on them. It was also felt that low-income taxi drivers would be disproportionately affected financially by proposals. Public transport infrastructure was felt to be inadequate. Other traffic management or emission reduction activities were also explored. Views towards these initiatives were more positive if they did not directly affect individuals financially. Conclusion Air quality initiatives such as CAZs were felt to be likely to financially disadvantage communities already living in socio-economic and environmental poverty. Policy makers need to carefully consider appropriate mitigation strategies to ensure that health and economic inequalities are not increased by implementation of CAZ. Given air quality is low priority for some groups, careful engagement and communication will be required to increase acceptance interventions such as CAZs.

UK plan to improve air quality is too weak, say campaigners

Cost-benefit Analysis of China’s Action Plan for Air Pollution Prevention and Control

Air Pollution in UK: the Public Health Problem That Won't Go Away.

Lawyers plan class action against UK government on asthma caused by air pollution

UK must act to protect children from risks of air pollution, say paediatricians

Air quality near new schools in England is "alarmingly poor," say researchers

EU tightens air quality standards as part of commitment to improving health

Pollution: London's low emission zone has improved air quality but not children's lungs, study finds.

Clean air in Europe for all! Taking stock of the proposed revision to the ambient air quality directives: a joint ERS, HEI and ISEE workshop report

The updated WHO air quality guidelines are a big step forward but not a complete solution

Cleaner Air Cut Deaths by 8.8% over 40 Years, but More Progress is Needed

Investigating the air quality surrounding new schools in England: polluted playgrounds and school buildings are a source of avoidable harm

Defending Blue Sky in China: Effectiveness of the "air Pollution Prevention and Control Action Plan" on Air Quality Improvements from 2013 to 2017.

Air pollution and public health: emerging hazards and improved understanding of risk

Taking a deep breath: a qualitative study exploring acceptability and perceived unintended consequences of charging clean air zones and air quality improvement initiatives amongst low-income, multi-ethnic communities in Bradford, UK

Government considers outdoor smoking ban in England

Health-oriented Strategies Are Needed to Optimize China’s 2025 Clean Air Action Plan

WHO Air Quality Guidelines 2021-Aiming for Healthier Air for all: A Joint Statement by Medical, Public Health, Scientific Societies and Patient Representative Organisations.

Opinion: Insights into Updating Ambient Air Quality Directive 2008/50/EC

Harnessing science, policy, and law to deliver clean air

The approach to air pollution control and the utilization of marine renewable energy in the UK