Comparison of physical parameters of two internal fixation devices for femoral neck fractures
Ming Yang,Yu-hui Kou,Bao-guo Jiang,Dian-ying Zhang,Zhong-guo Fu,Jian-hai Chen,Hong-bo Zhang,Kai Yu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3321/j.issn:1673-8225.2008.44.004
2008-01-01
Abstract:Background: Percutaneous cannulated cancellous lag screws internal fixation is the most used method for the cases of femoral neck fractures. However, there are some complications. We designed a new internal fixation device, self-locking cannulated compression anti-rotation blade to improve the treatment effect of femoral neck fractures. Objective: To compare the physical parameters of two internal fixation devices, self-locking cannulated compression anti-rotation blade and AO 7.3-mm cannulated screw applied to femoral neck fractures. Design, time and setting: Randomized controlled experiment was performed at the Department of Orthopaedics and Traumatology Laboratory, Peking University People's Hospital from April to July 2008. Materials: Eight pairs of cadaver femurs were from Anatomy Research Institute of Peking University Medical Department, and self-locking cannulated compression anti-rotation blade was made by Mechanology Institute, Beijing Aviation and Aerospace University. Methods: Femoral neck fracture model was made by osteotomy on eight pairs of cadaver femur and randomly divided into two groups. Area of broken end and volume of femoral head were measured. Two groups of specimens were differently fixed by self-locking cannulated compression anti-rotation blade and AO 7.3-mm cannulated screw under fluoroscopic guidance according to designed procedures. Depth of internal fixation device in femoral head was measured on X-ray after fixation, and volume of internal fixation device in femoral head were calculated. Main outcome measures: Ratio of area of cross-section of internal fixation device versus area of broken end, and ratio of volume of internal fixation versus volume of femoral head. Results: Area of broken end, ratio of area of cross-section of internal fixation device versus area of broken end, and volume of femoral head were not significantly different between two groups (P > 0.05), but ratio of volume of self-locking cannulated compression anti-rotation blade versus volume of femoral head was significantly less than AO 7.3 mm cannulated screw (P < 0.05). Conclusion: Compared with AO 7.3-mm cannulated screw, self-locking cannulated compression anti-rotation blade in treating femoral neck fracture has many advantages, such as reduction of space of internal fixation device in femoral head, reduction of quantity of internal fixation device, and reduction of manipulation difficulty, minimal invasion, and may substitute AO 7.3 mm cannulated cancellous lag screw to treat femoral neck fracture.