Abstract:Hydrological models have been developed in response to the need to understand the complex water cycle of the Earth and to assess its interaction with historical and future climate scenarios. In the global water sector of the Inter-Sectoral Impact Model Intercomparison Project phase 2b (ISIMIP2b), six land surface models (LSMs), eight hydrological models (GHMs), and one dynamic vegetation model (DGVM) are contributing with transient simulations spanning from 1660 to 2300. The model simulations follow a common protocol and are driven by common bias adjusted climate model outputs combined with plausible socio-economic scenarios and representative concentration pathways. The main goal of this study is to highlight similarities and differences among these models in simulating the vertical water balance. The main similarity of these models consists in the water cycle simulation, even if the models have been developed for different purposes such as energy cycle (LSMs), water cycle (GHMs), or vegetation cycle (DGVM) simulation. In particular, we address the following research question: 1) what equations are used to compute water storages and water fluxes; 2) how different are the equations among the models; 3) how the equations were adjusted; 4) how many parameters are used by the models; 5) how often the parameters are used; 6) how similar or different are the parameters among the models. To this end, we apply a standard writing style of the water storages and water fluxes included in the models, to easily identify the similarities and differences among them. Most of the models include in their structure the canopy, soil, and snow storages, and almost half of them include the groundwater storage. Furthermore, we find that: 1) a model needs a very good documentation, this would help to easily identify and understand the equations in the code; 2) some modelers teams use common approaches resulting in similar equations of water storages or water fluxes, but different models structures still lead to different models results; 3) collaboration and communication among the modelers are necessary, on the one hand, for the realization of the models standard writing style, and on the other hand, for a better understanding of the models themselves, especially their strengths, limitations and results. Overall, our results (i) help to better explain the different models results and to attribute these to the differences in simulating specific processes; (ii) contribute to the remarkable efforts in creating a common protocol and a common input datasets for well-defined simulations; (iii) foster a better understanding of how the models work and finding new ways of improvement and development.

Unifying Catchment Water Balance Models for Different Time Scales Through the Maximum Entropy Production Principle

Estimation of Watershed Hydrologic Processes in Arid Conditions with a Modified Watershed Model

Coupling Watershed Environmental Model with Optimizing Method to Provide Least Cost Alternatives in Environmental Planning and Management

A Thermodynamic Interpretation of Budyko and L'Vovich Formulations of Annual Water Balance: Proportionality Hypothesis and Maximum Entropy Production

A Proportionality-Based Multi-Scale Catchment Water Balance Model and Its Global Verification

A Physically-Based Integrated Numerical Model for Flow, Upland Erosion, and Contaminant Transport in Surface-Subsurface Systems

A Water-Energy Complementary Model for Monthly Runoff Simulation

A unified framework of water balance models for monthly, annual, and mean annual timescales

Similarities and Differences among Fifteen Global Water Models in Simulating the Vertical Water Balance

Functional Model Of Water Balance Variability At The Catchment Scale: 1. Evidence Of Hydrologic Similarity And Space-Time Symmetry

Evapotranspiration model based on the maximum entropy production principle

Understanding Each Other's Models: an Introduction and a Standard Representation of 16 Global Water Models to Support Intercomparison, Improvement, and Communication

A Parsimonious Daily Water Balance Model Based on the Proportionality Hypothesis

Water Flux Characterization Through Hydraulic Head and Temperature Data Assimilation: Numerical Modeling and Sandbox Experiments

Modeling Water Balance Using the Budyko Framework over Variable Timescales under Diverse Climates

Megascale thermodynamics in the presence of a conservative field: The watershed case

Derivation and Validation of Watershed Coupled Water-Energy Balance Equation at Arbitrary Time Scale

A Two-parameter Monthly Water Balance Model and Its Application in Hanjiang River Basin

Extension Of The Representative Elementary Watershed Approach For Cold Regions Via Explicit Treatment Of Energy Related Processes

Assessment of long-term water stress for ecosystems across China using the maximum entropy production theory-based evapotranspiration product

New Analytical Derivation of the Mean Annual Water‐energy Balance Equation