State of the Art of Small Punch Creep Testing Technique

陈玉新,凌祥,涂善东

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1001-0777.2004.04.007

2004-01-01

Abstract:The development and application of the small punch creep testing technique is reviewed. The details of the small punch creep testing apparatus is also introduced.Furthermore,the existing problems and the prospects of the testing technique are presented.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Research and Application on Small Punch Test Technology

凌祥,周志祥,解巧云

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1671-7627.2009.02.025

2009-01-01

Abstract:Small punch test(SPT) technology has been developed and applied widely in material mechanical properties testing.State-of-the-art of yield strength,ultimate strength,ductile to brittle transition temperature,fracture toughness and creep features obtained by small punch test were reviewed.According to the experimental results and theoretical models developed for small punch test,there is good relevance between the small punch test and traditional test method.With miniature specimen,the small punch test has the advantage of nearly nondestructive to materials;thus,it has extensive application prospects in material mechanical testing and life prediction of high temperature components.
Study on Small Punch Creep Test for SUS304

Chen Yu-Xin,LING Xiang,TU Shan-tong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1001-4888.2005.02.010

2005-01-01

Abstract:Small punch creep test technique (SPC) using miniature specimen is a new technique which is applied to evaluate the creep properties of materials in high temperature nearly non-destructively. SPC has been applied to evaluate the creep property of SUS 304 stainless steel at different temperature and load range of 443N~513N. A series of deflection curves under different conditions were obtained. Then, the deformation of specimens during the test was analyzed through observing the interrupted specimens by scanning electron micrograph. Also, the major factors influencing the test are discussed. The test results showed that the creep curves, determined by means of the small punch creep test, are similar to those obtained from a conventional uniaxial creep test. That is, they exhibited clearly three creep stages. The specimen central initial deflection and the creep rate of secondary stage increased with an increase of test load level, while the rupture time decreased. Load, temperature, thickness of specimen and environment are the major factors influencing the test.
An elastic-plastic-creep finite element analysis for small punch creep test specimens

Xiang Ling,Yangyan Zheng,Zhengmei Qian

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1115/PVP2006-ICPVT-11-93172

2006-01-01

Abstract:An elastic-plastic-creep finite element model, incorporating a Von Mises plastic flow rule and a creep damage equation, was established based on the small punch creep test on Cr5Mo steel specimens at 550°C and three different loads. Finite element analyses were performed to examine the variation of the central creep deflection and the creep strain with time and the evolution of creep damage. The sensitivity of the creep deflection and equivalent stress at the centre on the disc to mesh size is discussed. Numerical results presented in this paper confirm that the creep damage at the central part is high. The stress gradients are highest near the centre area of the specimen (from 0 to 1 mm). Therefore, accurate stress and strain can be obtained using refined meshes near the specimen center and coarse meshes in other places. The test results are in agreement with those of the numerical simulation and three different stages appearing in the curve of creep deflection, which are quite similar to those observed in conventional creep tests. Copyright © 2006 by ASME.
AN ANALYSIS OF ELASTIC-PLASTIC-CREEP DAMAG FOR SMALL PUNCH CREEP TEST

Yang-yan ZHENG,Zhen-mei QIAN,Xiang LING

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1000-4750.2007.09.023

2007-01-01

Abstract:An elastic-plastic-creep finite element model, incorporating the Von Mises plastic flow rule and a creep damage equation, was established based on the small punch creep test on Cr 5Mo steel specimens at 550°C under three different loads. Finite element analysis were performed to examine the variation of the central creep deflection and the creep strain with time and the evolution of creep damage. The sensitivity of the creep deflection and equivalent stress at the centre on the disc to mesh size is discussed. Numerical results presented in this paper confirm that the creep damage at the central part is high. The stress gradients are highest near the central area of the specimen (from 0 to 1 mm). Therefore, accurate stress and strain can be obtained using refined meshes near the specimen center and coarse meshes in other places. The test results are in agreement with those of the numerical simulation and three different stages appearing in the curve of creep deflection, which are quite similar to those observed in conventional creep tests.
Assessment of Toughness in Long Term Service Crmo Low Alloy Steel by Fracture Toughness and Small Punch Test

Kaishu Guan,Li Hua,Qiongqi Wang,Xiaohui Zou,Ming Song

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nucengdes.2011.01.031

IF: 1.7

2011-01-01

Nuclear Engineering and Design

Abstract:Small punch test (SPT) is a miniature sample test technique which can evaluate in-service material properties with an almost non-destructive method. In this paper, the 2.25Cr1Mo steel samples serviced for 10 years in hydrogenation reactor (with temper embrittlement), 1.25Cr0.5Mo supper-pressure vapor pipe serviced for 14 years at 520°C and several other low alloy steels have been studied by JIC fracture toughness and SPT. The linear relationship between the small punch (SP) equivalent fracture strain and the fracture toughness of JIC was created. The correlations applied to the experimental data indicated advantages of using SPT for the determining fracture toughness of in-serviced low alloy steels. Additionally, size affects the fracture pattern. Small punch samples of small size show dimple fractures whereas large fracture toughness samples show quasi-cleavage fractures.
A Study on Influence Factors of Small Punch Creep Test by Experimental Investigation and Finite Element Analysis

Zhixiang Zhou,Yangyan Zheng,Xiang Ling,Ruomei Hu,Jianqiu Zhou

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.msea.2010.01.010

2010-01-01

Abstract:Small punch creep (SPC) tests for SUS304 and Cr5Mo specimens with dimension Ø10mm×0.5mm were performed at different temperatures, load levels and atmospheres. Based on these tests, a finite element model (FEM) combined with modified Kachanov–Rabotnov (K–R) creep damage constitutive equations was established to simulate the ductile and creep damage of the round specimen during the test procedure. The validity of FEM was proved by the comparison of Center deflection–Time data yielded from finite element analysis (FEA) and experiment. Then, effects of sample thickness, load level, ceramic ball diameter, specimen diameter, temperature and protective atmosphere on SPC test were analyzed by experimental investigation and FEA. The results show that five of the six above-mentioned factors (except specimen diameter) influence the rupture time, center deflection, real creep strain and creep damage of SPC specimen strongly.
Evaluation of creep properties considering the friction effect of the small punch test

Sangyeop Kim,Uijeong Ro,Taeksang Lee,Moon Ki Kim

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.engfracmech.2024.109879

IF: 5.4

2024-01-21

Engineering Fracture Mechanics

Abstract:In contrast to the Uniaxial Creep Test (UCT), where each stress produces a corresponding strain, the Small Punch Creep Test (SPCT) generates displacement in response to applied loads. Therefore, for the direct application of SPCT in creep damage assessment, it becomes imperative to convert the displacement and load data into the strain and stress parameters observed in the UCT. Unlike the UCT, which applies the load directly to the specimen, the SPCT indirectly imposes the load on the specimen through a punch ball. This divergence in loading methods introduces friction between the specimen and the punch ball during the SPCT. This study delves into the analysis of the friction coefficient between the specimen and punch ball using the Finite Element Method (FEM). Additionally, we explore the relationship between the specimen's minimum thickness and the friction coefficient. In conclusion, we propose a correlation between the creep properties of the two test methods, with the objective of accurately capturing the influence of friction between the specimen and punch ball in the SPCT.

mechanics
Material damage evaluation and life prediction via small punch test technology

QIAN Yang,YANG Si-sheng,LING Xiang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1007-2012.2014.05.026

2014-01-01

Abstract:SPT (small punch test) technology draws more and more attention in recent years due to its convenience and micro size of specimen compared to the traditional material tests .This paper introduces the applications of SPT technology to evaluate hydro-gen embrittlement ,ductile-brittle transition temperature ,creep damage and life of material .The factors which may influence the results of finite element analysis are also presented .
Creep Characteristics and Deformation Analysis of Service-Exposed Material Using Small Punch Creep Test

Sisheng Yang,Yangyan Zheng,Yejuan Duan,Xiang Ling

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.engfracmech.2018.04.025

IF: 5.4

2018-01-01

Engineering Fracture Mechanics

Abstract:In this study, the creep characteristics and deformation analysis of service-exposed Cr5Mo are performed. Similar creep curves and deformation trends are found in both the uniaxial creep test and small punch creep test; however, the transient and tertiary creep stages are more apparent in the small punch test. The contribution of secondary creep time to the overall creep life is proven to be greater in the small punch creep test, corresponding to the tertiary stage which occupied most of the creep strain in the uniaxial creep test. When the creep deflection continues to increase, the percentages of low-angle grain boundaries and local misorientation increase, and the largest value appears in the necking region. On the basis of the microstructure analysis, a creep cavity model for the small punch creep is proposed for service-exposed Cr5Mo. The results demonstrate that the growth of creep damage has a stage from the constant speed to the accelerated speed creep. Ductile fracture behaviour is characterized. Finally, the Larson-Miller method is introduced and applied to predict the creep life of service-exposed material from shorter rupture time data.
Evaluation of Multiaxial Creep and Damage Evolution for Small Punch Creep Test Considering Critical-Strain Criterion

Sisheng Yang,Yangyan Zheng,Xiang Ling

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.engfailanal.2018.04.023

IF: 4

2018-01-01

Engineering Failure Analysis

Abstract:Experiment and finite element analysis were performed in this study to estimate the deformation characteristics of small punch creep test. Considering the disadvantage of the traditional model owing to numerous unknown parameters, ductility exhaustion model was introduced and used to estimate the damage and multiaxial creep evolution process. The results show that the evolution trends of creep deflection and strain with three stages are similar. During deformation, apparent damage localization is observed. The maximum strain and damage also occurred in the necking region due to the stress concentration. Thus, a critical damage value is proposed for service-exposed Cr5Mo in this study. In the primary creep stage, a tensile deformation is observed at the lower surface and a compression deformation is observed at the upper surface. Subsequently, the stress triaxiality tends to be constant in the second creep stage. Thus, steady creep parameters of small punch test can be used to replace traditional creep results in the creep properties analysis of in-service components. Finally, the multiaxial creep and damage evolution characteristics of the small punch creep specimen are obtained.
Small punch test for investigating circumferential creep in cladding tubes

Yuntao Zhong,Huan Sheng Lai,Jinquan Guo,Peinan Du,Qifei Huang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijmecsci.2024.109001

IF: 7.3

2024-01-05

International Journal of Mechanical Sciences

Abstract:Several methods have been developed to determine the axial creep properties of nuclear fuel cladding tubes. However, the anisotropic creep properties of nuclear fuel cladding tubes requires that their circumferential creep behaviour be evaluated as well. Nonetheless, this task remains extremely challenging owing to need to employ unaltered cylindrical cladding tube specimens directly and the general low accuracy of the methods developed for this purpose. The present work addresses these issues by developing a modified small punch creep test (SPCT). Equations are proposed to calculate the creep stress and strain of the modified SPCT. The accuracy of the equations is analysed using the finite element method. Finally, the methodology is applied to investigate the circumferential creep behaviour of an FeCrAl nuclear fuel cladding tube experimentally. These results clearly demonstrate that the modified SPCT is suitable for investigating the creep behaviour of irregularly shaped material specimens with anisotropic creep properties. Moreover, the semi-cylindrical specimens employed in the modified SPCT also enable the effective fracture strain of the specimen to be easily determined.

engineering, mechanical,mechanics
Creep life prediction of in-service materials by small punch creep test

Yangyan ZHENG,Sishen YANG,Xiang LING

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1671-7627.2017.03.003

2017-01-01

Abstract:Creep properties of in-service Cr5Mo and 12Cr1MoV under different loads were analyzed by small punch creep tests.Compared to the results of conventional creep tests,creep life prediction method based on small punch test was established.Results showed that there existed apparent stages of deceleration,constant speed and acceleration in the small punch creep curves,which had the ability to replace the traditional creep tests.The steady creep rate gradually increased while the rupture life decreased with the increase of load.The relationship between steady creep rate and load could be described by Norton equation.Meanwhile,there was a power function relation between rupture life and load under constant temperature.In order to realize life extrapolation for in-service materials by small punch test,the creep rupture time was analyzed by temperature and load based on the Larson-Miller equation.
Uncertainties in and Recommendations to Small Punch Tensile and Creep Tests for Ductile Materials

Wei Sun,Ming Li,Zhixun Wen,Guoyan Zhou,Zhufeng Yue,Shan-Tung Tu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.engfracmech.2023.109443

IF: 5.4

2023-06-19

Engineering Fracture Mechanics

Abstract:The objective of this paper is to clarify the complex nature which involves the interaction of several non-linear deformation mechanisms experienced in small punch tensile and small punch creep tests, and as a consequence, the associated difficulties in data interpretation. The paper starts with a highlight of some specific features experienced during small punch deformation, e.g., large deformation, high local plasticity, contact, the effect of initial plasticity, possible early cracking etc. and the consequences of them in data interpretation. Although several test standards have been available, uncertainties in data interpretation still exist and a universally accepted conversion method has not been available. On this basis, for the first time, critical comments on the uncertainties and applicability of the test methods in determining the tensile and creep properties and in high-temperature structural integrity assessment are addressed. Finally, recommendations on future developments are provided.

mechanics
Residual Life Assessment of In-Service High Temperature Components by Small Punch Creep Test

Jianhua Shan,Xiang Ling,Zhenmei Qian

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1115/creep2007-26582

2008-01-01

Abstract:The knowledge of mechanical long term behaviour under static loading for high temperature components requires methodologies for residual life assessment in order to employ the full potential of materials, particularly in non-destructive methods. In this paper, in order to apply small punch creep (SPC) test to the residual creep life assessment of in-service high temperature components, a variety of SPC tests for Cr5Mo steel in a protective Argon atmosphere were carried out, which used disc test specimens of 10mm in diameter and 0.5mm in thickness extracted both new material and in-service high temperature components. The relationship of the creep deflection curve, the test load, rupture time and ductility of miniature specimens were investigated. Based on SPC test and finite element numerical analysis methods, a novel residual life assessment method was proposed to substitute conventional uniaxial creep life analysis method by introducing an initial creep damage parameter. Moreover, the fractographic observation and the structural damage detection analysis were examined. Finally, the results using conventional uniaxial creep life analysis method were studied to validate the reliability of SPC life assessment method.
Creep Life Analysis by an Energy Model of Small Punch Creep Test

Sisheng Yang,Xiang Ling,Yangyan Zheng,Rongbiao Ma

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2015.11.079

IF: 9.417

2015-01-01

Materials & Design

Abstract:Currently most creep life prediction methods by small punch test are focused on the steady creep deformation phase which is similar to conventional uniaxial creep tests. This paper presents a novel creep life extrapolation approach by small punch creep test. An energy model believed to have advantages in modeling creep deformation process of small punch tests is introduced. Linear expression between general strain and creep deflection was recommended as the deformation criterion in the analytical prediction. Meanwhile, the combination of ball radius and hole size of the lower die was analyzed to accommodate the difference of experimental devices. Based on the small punch creep data with different materials and creep environments, the creep life in the multiaxial form of large deformation was analyzed. Finally, by selecting different creep displacements from initial creep phase, the results were in agreement with the expected trend. The creep life extrapolation method was verified.
Creep Property Assessment Of Type 304 By Small Punch Creep Test

Yangyan Zheng,Jianxin Zhou,Xiang Ling,Zheng Yang,Sishen Yang,Yining Wang

2012-01-01

Abstract:A series of uniaxial and small punch creep tests were performed at 650 degrees C in order to study the creep properties of SUS304. A finite element model, with modified Kachanov-Rabotnov creep damage constitutive equations, was used Based on tests and numerical simulations, the relationship between the creep strain from uniaxial creep tests versus creep deflection from SPC tests and the stress applied in uniaxial creep tests versus the loads applied in SPC tests were established in this paper. Creep lives were evaluated using Larson-Miller parameter (LMP) for uniaxial creep tests and SPC tests. Very good agreement between the LPM of uniaxial creep tests and SPC tests was found.
An overview on recent development of impression creep test

Zhufeng Yue,Ming Li,Guo-yan Zhou,Zhixun Wen,Wei Sun,Shan-Tung Tu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijpvp.2024.105160

IF: 2.56

2024-02-24

International Journal of Pressure Vessels and Piping

Abstract:This paper aims to present recent advancements and insights into the impression creep test, elucidating the nature of associated data conversion relationships. The clarification of the benefits of adopting a rectangular indenter is discussed initially, followed by the introduction of a mechanics-based data conversion approach utilizing the reference stress method. The paper then provides updates on constant load and stepped load impression creep tests and highlights ongoing efforts in correcting conversion parameters due to changes in geometry and loading misalignments during the test. Additionally, comments and recommendations are offered regarding the theoretical foundation, applicability, and limitations of the test method for material status ranking, material properties derivation, hardness correlation, and life assessment. Finally, the latest developments in the standardization of the test method are also addressed.

engineering, mechanical, multidisciplinary
Membrane stretching based creep damage analytical solutions for thin disc small punch problem

Raheeg Ragab,Tao Liu,Ming Li,Wei Sun

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmps.2022.104928

IF: 5.582

2022-08-01

Journal of the Mechanics and Physics of Solids

Abstract:The small punch creep test (SPCT) presents a novel miniaturized testing technique popularly used to characterise creep and damage properties of high-temperature materials. Due to the complex non-linear deformation behaviour in the SPCT, a mechanistic based analytical solution describing creep deformation and damage in the SPCT remains unsolved so far. Instead, simplified empirical relations for the analysis of the SPCTs and data interpretation are often employed. However, such approaches lack theoretical underpinnings and thereby limiting the potential of the SPCT as a standardised material characterisation method. In this study, for the first time, creep damage analytical solutions were proposed to represent the complex deformation mechanism of the thin-disk small punch creep problem. The theoretical framework was established based on the membrane stretching theory and continuum damage mechanics-based constitutive model. The accuracy of the proposed analytical model was verified using finite element analysis. The analytical solutions demonstrated excellent capabilities and advantages over the existing models. Further, the potential applications of the new solutions were addressed. The proposed solutions represent a first key step towards improved theoretical modelling of the SPCT for ductile materials.

mechanics,materials science, multidisciplinary,physics, condensed matter
Influence of Oxidation to Small Punch Creep Test

Jianhua Shan,Zhenmei Qian,Xiang Ling

DOI: https://doi.org/10.4028/www.scientific.net/kem.353-358.461

2007-01-01

Key Engineering Materials

Abstract:In order to validate a procedure for creep rupture tests using small punch specimens, the influences of oxidation on the creep deflection curve, rupture time and ductility of miniature specimens were investigated. Using disc test specimens of 10mm in diameter and 0.5mm in thickness, a variety of small punch creep (SPC) tests for Cr5Mo steel at the condition of 550°C-404N and 650°C-189N under the protection of different Argon flow and in air atmosphere were firstly carried out. Metallographic observations, micro-hardness testing and measurement for these specimens of SPC test were performed. It indicates that the oxidized layer of specimens integrates and the residual thickness of specimens increases, while the hardness of specimens increases with the increment of the Argon flow. Moreover, the different oxidation degrees of specimens with the surface morphology were compared in this paper. The test results show the rupture time of specimens can be effectively prolonged by the protection of different Argon flow.
Creep Behaviors Evaluation of Incoloy800H by Small Punch Creep Test

Sisheng Yang,Xiang Ling,Yangyan Zheng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.msea.2016.12.092

IF: 6.044

2016-01-01

Materials Science and Engineering A

Abstract:In this paper, creep properties estimation of Incoloy800H under various loads and temperatures were performed experimentally and analytically. Compared to standard creep test, a similar creep character could be obtained by small punch creep test. On the basis of geometrical shape of deformed specimen, we proposed a modified geometrical model. The relatively simple yet accurate correlation between strain and small punch deflection was established. The reference stress under multi-axial deformation state was discussed and proved to be as constant at the identical condition. Additionally, to analyze the tertiary deformation and fracture mechanism of small punch creep test, creep damage tolerance factor was introduced and modified. The results indicated that necking and precipitate coarsening was the domain model in this phase. Meanwhile, the physical significance of three stages of deflection-time (D-T) curve was proved to be different with that of uniaxial creep curve.

State of the Art of Small Punch Creep Testing Technique

Research and Application on Small Punch Test Technology

Study on Small Punch Creep Test for SUS304

An elastic-plastic-creep finite element analysis for small punch creep test specimens

AN ANALYSIS OF ELASTIC-PLASTIC-CREEP DAMAG FOR SMALL PUNCH CREEP TEST

Assessment of Toughness in Long Term Service Crmo Low Alloy Steel by Fracture Toughness and Small Punch Test

A Study on Influence Factors of Small Punch Creep Test by Experimental Investigation and Finite Element Analysis

Evaluation of creep properties considering the friction effect of the small punch test

Material damage evaluation and life prediction via small punch test technology

Creep Characteristics and Deformation Analysis of Service-Exposed Material Using Small Punch Creep Test

Evaluation of Multiaxial Creep and Damage Evolution for Small Punch Creep Test Considering Critical-Strain Criterion

Small punch test for investigating circumferential creep in cladding tubes

Creep life prediction of in-service materials by small punch creep test

Uncertainties in and Recommendations to Small Punch Tensile and Creep Tests for Ductile Materials

Residual Life Assessment of In-Service High Temperature Components by Small Punch Creep Test

Creep Life Analysis by an Energy Model of Small Punch Creep Test

Creep Property Assessment Of Type 304 By Small Punch Creep Test

An overview on recent development of impression creep test

Membrane stretching based creep damage analytical solutions for thin disc small punch problem

Influence of Oxidation to Small Punch Creep Test

Creep Behaviors Evaluation of Incoloy800H by Small Punch Creep Test