Abstract:[Purpose] The purpose of this study was to analyze foreign private tutoring demand markets and demand management policy trends. The aim was to present implications necessary for managing the domestic private tutoring market. [Methods] In this study, using 103 domestic and foreign research materials, domestic and foreign private tutoring demand markets were analyzed in terms of participation rates of private tutoring, gaps in private tutoring expenses between classes, participation backgrounds and its purposes, and response measures and policies trends for private tutoring demand management were further analyzed as well. [Results] First, the participation rate results of private tutoring over all showed increasing trends across East and West countries regardless of rich or poor, capitalist or socialist, and its more increase due to the COVID-19 pandemic. The participation rates of private tutoring was higher among students with parents in socioeconomic status, who lived in cities, and had top grades, and the gaps in private tutoring expenses between classes were a factor causing social imbalance. Second, the backgrounds and purposes of participating in private tutoring were being formed by being linked to current or changing education, social culture, economy and policy. Although they were somewhat different depending on the education systems and overall conditions of each country, there was the common ground arisen from parents' human nature and desire who wanted their children to live a stable life in the future. While the backgrounds and purposes of private tutoring participation were driven from expectations for usefulness of private tutoring, it partially led to the factor causing the harmful effects of private tutoring. Third, each government's measures and policies for private tutoring demand management were somewhat different depending on the government's perspective on private tutoring and its level of the economy, but those most representative ones included strengthening public education, expanding after-school and care services, supporting the vulnerable social group, improving tests in schools and entrance examination systems, and reforming curricula in schools. These policies lowered students' burden of learning and parents' burden of educating and raising their children, but did not produce clear results in reducing the demand for and dependence on private tutoring. [Conclusion] In order to manage the private tutoring demand market, the multifaceted and complex aspects surrounding private tutoring must be understood deeply, and realistic policies suitable for interests of individuals and their society must be established through evaluations of the harmfulness and usefulness of private tutoring.

The Internal Dynamics of Privatised Public Education: Fee-charging Supplementary Tutoring Provided by Teachers in Cambodia

Understanding the nexus between mainstream schooling and private supplementary tutoring: patterns and voices of Hong Kong secondary students

Marketized private tutoring as a supplement to regular schooling: Liberal Studies and the shadow sector in Hong Kong secondary education

The Marketization of Educational Resources and Individual Choice: Examining the Heterogeneous Treatment Effect of Private Tutoring in Middle Schools

For-Profit Provision of Education As a Quasi-Public Good

The Shadow Education System: Students’ Responses to Private Tutorial Learning

Responsibilised parents and shadow education: managing the precarious environment in China

Teaching under opportunism: The predicament of academic tutors in China

Insights into life of academics at private higher education institutions in Cambodia in light of neoliberalism

Urban-Rural Disparities in Private Tutoring of Lower-Secondary Students

Public School Resources and Private Substitution in Urban China

Parents, quality, and school choice: why parents in Nairobi choose low-cost private schools over public schools in Kenya’s free primary education era

Teaching English in the shadow: identity construction of private English language tutors in China

The Tutoring Industry in Hong Kong: From the Past Four Decades to the Future

Mark Bray et Anas Hajar, Shadow education in the Middle East: Private supplementary tutoring and its policy implications

Shadow Education in Denmark: In the Light of the Danish History of Pedagogy and the Skepticism Toward Competition

Shadow Education And Social Class Inequalities In Secondary Education In Greece: The Case Of Teaching English As A Foreign Language

Public education spending and private substitution in urban China

An Analysis of Foreign Private Tutoring Demand Markets and Demand Management Policy Trends

Private Higher Education in China: Access to Quality Higher Education and the Acquisition of Labour Market Qualifications by Low-Income Students1

Inequality in the shadow: The role of private tutoring in SES achievement gaps