THE LESSONS OF CHINA'S TRANSITION TO A MARKET ECONOMY
Justin Y,Fang Cai,Zhou Li
1996-01-01
Cato Journal
Abstract:China's transition from a plannedeconomy to a market economy beganatthe endof 1978.When Chinastartedtheprocess,thegovern- ment did nothaveawell-designedblueprint. Theapproach to reform can be characterized as piecemeal, partial, incremental, and often experimental. Someeconomists regard thisapproach as self-defeating (Murphy, Schleifer, and Vishny 1992). China's average annualrate of GDP growthhasbeen miraculoussincethe beginningofthe transition (Liiietal. 1996) andis the most successfulofthetransition economies. Nevertheless, the Chinese economyhas beentroubledby an increas- ingly serious "boom and bust" cycle (see Figure 1). WhetherChina's experienceprovides usefullessonsforothertransi- tion economies is hotly debated.Some economists argue that China's successdemonstratesthe superiorityofanevolutionary, experimental, and bottom-up approach over the comprehensive and top-down "shock therapy"approach that characterizes the transitionin Eastern Europe and the former Soviet Union (Jefferson and Rawski 1995; McKinnon 1994; McMillan and Naughton 1992; Smgh 1991; Chen et al. 1992; Harrold 1992; Perkins 1992)~Other economists argue that itis neithergradualismnorexperimentation butrather China's unique initial conditions—namely,a largeagriculturallabor force,low subsid- ies to the population, and a rather decentralized economic system— that have contributed to China's success(Woo 1993; Sachs and Woo 1993; Qian and Xu 1993). According to these economists, China's