Abstract:The common pool resource (CPR) theory has made invaluable contributions to the governance of natural resources in the past decades, but few literatures have specifically paid attention to the different property right arrangements of resource system and resource units, and their relationship. In this paper, we take two types of grassland property right system on the Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau (QTP) in China, one is grassland contract system under that the previous grassland common use was given up and the other is grazing quota system under that the common use is still kept in the community level, as cases to present the different consequences on the ecological conditions, herders' livelihoods and livestock husbandry. Furthermore, from the perspective of property rights of resource system-units, we explore why the two systems resulted in the different consequences. We find that the grazing quota system indicated by the number of livestock each household allowed to raise has more advantages in improving the herders' livelihoods and reducing the livestock production costs, and both systems could alleviate the grazing pressure though the long-term effects of the contract system might be negative on ecological conditions. The main reason why the grazing quota system works better is that this type of individual use rights were clarified based on the resource units so the grassland could be kept common use as an integrated resource system, while the contract system was claimed by physically dividing the resource system by fencing, thus the resource system was fragmented which led to mismatch with the large scope movement needs of livestock grazing. We argue that, theoretically, the grazing quota system is a private property rights embedded in the grassland common property right system, which forms a nested property right regime. Our findings have important implications for both of the CPR theory and practical rangeland management worldwide.

Characters of the property right structure of common property resources and use behavior

The Social Construction Logic of Property Rights:A review on the property rights studies of Chinese sociologists from the perspective of game theory

The Research on Structural Model of Community Property Management based on the Supply Chain Theory

Urban community property management research

PUBLIC DOMAIN OF RESOURCE AND PROPERTY RIGHTS SELECTION

Economic Analysis on the Mechanism of the Special Labor Property Rights of the Township Enterprises

Discussion, Refution and Analysis on "separation of Three Rights" in Rural Collective Land Property Rights - Taking the Opinion to Reserve the Operation Rights of Land and to Trans Fer the Management Rights of Land During the Transferring of Operation And

Objective Regulation of Collective Land Ownership's Character

The Summary of Studies on Juristic Character of Main Types of Transference of Rural Land Contract and Operation Rights

On Clause Design for Land Contracting Management Right in Real Right Law

Complex Operation Paradigm of Data Element Property Rights

Utilization of Environmental Capacity: Legal Attributes and Structure

The Structure of Farmland Property Rights and Agricultural Performance: A Theoretical Framework

Freedom and Harmony:Restrictions on the Exertion of Real Property Rights within the Framework of Private Law

The Metamorphosis of Ownership?

Probing into the Relations Between the Term of Land Use Right and the Integrity of Housing Ownership

A Nested Property Right System of the Commons: Perspective of Resource System-Units

An Analysis on the Nature of Chinese Land Property Rights and Its Trajectory of Reform

Construct modern Chinese Property Law under the Balance of Public Power and Private Right

Between Commons and Anticommons: a Nested Common-Private Interface Framework

COMPARISON OF EXPLOITATION OF PUBLIC RESOURCES IN THE LONG RUN UNDER TWO DIFFERENT INSTITUTIONS