Abstract:Psychologists are paying increasing attention to a distinction between two ways of thinking. Cognitive psychologists discern between non-reflective “intuitive” and critical reflective “analytic” thinking. Cultural psychologists discern between context-focused “holistic” and object-focused “analytic” thinking. Both find the former strongly correlated with religious beliefs and Asian cultures, the latter with secular beliefs and Euro-American cultures. Yet, recent studies convincingly suggest: first, that analytic thinking does not just relate to secular beliefs but also to alternative beliefs that straddle the boundaries between secular and religious worldviews; second, that critical reflective thinking includes both the holistic context-focus of Asian religions and the analytic object-focus of European philosophies and sciences. This article supports these recent studies in the psychology of religion based on recent studies from the history and sociology of religion and a discourse analysis of interviews with members of a small-scale twenty-first-century spiritual group, as an example. We show that people who identify as spiritual in a metamodern context use both holistic and analytic thinking in creating alternative worldviews, which dialectically reconcile beliefs that many within modern western cultures would consider contradictory. We conclude that this both/and logic challenges theories and stereotypes about “secular versus religious” and “eastern versus western” thinking.

On the Thinking Modes of Christianity and Secular Humanism

The Reflection of Humanistic Value Between Chinese Classics and Western Classics

The Development and the Gradual Changes of Enlightenment Thoughts in the West

Dialectical thinking in contemporary spirituality: Reconciling contradictory beliefs through metamodern oscillations between two ways of thinking

Introspection and Re-construction: the Study Pattern about the Modern Chinese Enlightening Principle

Several Questions Concerning Comparative Study Between Marxist Philosophy and Contemporary Western Philosophy--To Clarify Some Questions in Marxism and the Modern and Contemporary Trend of Western Philosophy

On the Blasphemy of Reason and Path of Criticism

From "the Opposition Between a Lower and a Higher Will "to" Control of Yu(Desire) over Li(Reason)"--A Case Study of the Misinterpretation of Babbitt's "new Humanism" in Contemporary China

"Humanist Criticism": the contemporary transformation attempt of the Christian humanistic tradition

Self-Ontology versus Counter-Ontology: The Hermeneutic Basis of Chinese and Western Philosophy

Rethinking the Modernity and Post-modernity of Enlightenment

On the Frontier Questions of Contemporary Chinese Philosophy Study

On Functionalism in Understanding of Chinese: The Modem Inspiration of Humboldt's Thinking of Chinese

On the Three Boundaries to Divide the Sphere of Religious Activity

On the Secularization of Religion and Its Problems

Reflections on the Present World of Chinese Traditional Culture from the Perspective of Comparison between Chinese and Western Philosophy

The Concept of Theosis in Orthodox Christianity and the Concept of Sanctification in Chinese Philosophy

On Evolvement of the Essentialist Mode of Thinking in Western Classical Philosophy

On Mid-View Thinking in Chinese Philosophy

The Buddhist Thoughts in the Human World from Platform Sutra and Theoretical Features

On Modern Anthropocentrism and Human Centralism