Abstract:Developing students' critical thinking skills in writing is essential in different educational contexts. However, the analysis of the argument structure in non-English-major undergraduate students' writing remains largely unexplored. This study aimed to analyze the structure of argumentative English papers written by Chinese university students, based on the adapted Toulmin model of argument structure constituting six elements (claim, data, counterargument claim, counterargument data, rebuttal claim, and rebuttal data). The participants in this study were a class of 47 sophomores enrolled in the course "Modern Education Technology" at Zhejiang University, China. They were required to identify the components of the argument structure in a pre-assigned short text with two opposing views, and to write an argumentative essay. Content analysis was used to assess the students' CT and argument structures. In both tasks, the results found that the majority of the students could identify author's claim with at least a piece of data. They also stated their own claims and provided at least one piece of data to back these up. However, a majority failed to identify the author's counter argument and even though many stated the counter argument claims in their essays, most were unjustified. The majority did not state a conclusion in both tasks. This study may be beneficial in understanding non-English major-undergraduate students' critical thinking skills in English writing and the results suggest that L2 essay writing instructors should use active and explicit methods such as computer-assisted argument mapping tools like RationaleTM to help learners master the argument structure. Some pedagogic guidelines are listed for the implementation of the RationaleTM software in the L2 classroom.

An Investigation into L1 Use in the L2 Writing Process of Tertiary-level English Learners in China

Analyzing Critical Thinking Elements in the Argument Structure of Non-English-Major Chinese Undergraduate Students' Writing

Processes Involved in Chinese and English Writing: A Study of Chinese University Students

An Investigation into the Use of Socio-Cultural Strategies in L2 Writing among Chinese English Majors

Writing in a second language based on cross-linguistic sources: The language use among undergraduates in Hong Kong

A Study into the Chinese English Learners’ Psychological Process in L2 Discursive Writing

Discourses of writing and learning to write in L2 writing curriculum in Chinese universities

The Effects of L2 Chinese Learners’ Perceived Writing Anxiety on Their L1 Use within L2 Writing Performance among English Major Students in a Chinese University

Positive Effects of L1 Thinking on L2 Writing

Exploring and modeling the reading-writing connection in EFL integrated writing

Languaging in Story Rewriting Tasks by Chinese EFL Students

Investigating the Relationship Between Linguistic Competence, Ideal Self, Learning Engagement, and Integrated Writing Performance: A Structural Equation Modeling Approach

How Chinese Thinking Works in English Reading: an Investigation through TAP and RI

Modeling the process of summary writing of Chinese learners of English as a foreign language

Transfer of Ideal L1 and L2 Writing Selves and Their Impacts on L2 Writing Enjoyment and Integrated Writing Performance

A study of the development of Chinese EFL learners’ written English

Investigating What Feedback Practices Contribute to Students’ Writing Motivation and Engagement in Chinese EFL Context: A Large Scale Study

Activity Theory for Examining the Effects of the Story Continuation Writing Task on English Writing Quality

A Comparative Study of the Effects of L1 and L2 Prewriting Discussions on L2 Writing Performance

A Probe into the Integrated Learning Model of Academic English “Writing + Critical Thinking” in Sino-Foreign Joint Education

Facilitating L2 writers’ metacognitive strategy use in argumentative writing using a process-genre approach