Abstract:Background: The double-opposing Z-plasty is a fundamental approach for cleft palate repair. Recently, some surgeons have begun implementing a single Z-Plasty, igniting discussions on the most effective technique for enhancing postoperative outcomes. Consequently, this study sought to evaluate the outcomes of employing single and double Z-plasties within the modified Sommerlad-Furlow technique. Methods: 116 cleft palate patients undergoing primary surgical repair were divided into two groups: those treated with the Sommerlad-Furlow method using a double-opposing Z-plasty (S.F.2.Z.P. group, n = 58) and those receiving a single nasal Z-plasty (S.F.1.Z.P. group, n = 58). Data on cleft type and width, soft palate length, palatal fistula, and velopharyngeal function were collected. Mann-Whitney test compared the mean values between groups. Results: The S.F.2ZP group demonstrated a statistically significant increase in soft palate length compared to those in the S.F.1ZP group (p = 0.008). However, the S.F.1ZP group demonstrated adequate soft palate length (7.9 ± 2.8 mm) compared to the S.F.2ZP group (9.3 ± 2.8 mm). The velopharyngeal function was good in both groups, with no significant differences (P = 0.52). While the proper velopharyngeal closure was 81% in the S.F.1ZP group and 87.9% in the S.F.2ZP group, velopharyngeal insufficiency was 10.3% and 5.2%, respectively. The rates of persistent palatal fistula were 5.2% in the S.F.1ZP group and 3.4% in the S.F.2ZP group, with no significant differences found between both groups (P = 0.64). Conclusions: There were no significant differences in crucial outcomes such as velopharyngeal function and the incidence of persistent palatal fistulas, indicating the effectiveness of both techniques. While the double-opposing Z-plasty demonstrated a statistically significant increase in soft palate length, the a nasal Z-plasty demonstrated adequate soft palate length which sufficiently enables effective velopharyngeal closure. These outcomes suggest that a single Z-plasty is both effective and easy to perform, making it a valuable surgical approach for achieving the desired outcomes.. Clinical relevance: The current study suggests that although the soft palate may not be as elongated with nasal Z-plasty alone compared to the double Z-plasty, it sufficiently enables effective velopharyngeal closure.

Clinical comparative study of two kinds of methods in surgical repair of isolated clefts

STUDY ON WOUND HEALING AFTER Sommerlad TECHNIQUE REPAIR OF ISOLATED CLEFT PALATE

[A Primary Clinical Analysis of Artificial Bone Implantation of Cleft Palate].

The single Z-plasty for cleft palate repair: a preliminary report.

The Square Flap Method for Cleft Palate Repair

Evaluation of fistula rates in three cleft palate techniques without relaxing incisions

Analysis of velopharyngeal morphology in operated cleft palate patients with levator veli palatini retropositioning according to Sommerlad]

Comparison of Velopharyngeal Morphology of Two Palatoplasty Techniques in Patients with Hard and Soft Cleft Palate

Surgical Repair of Hard Palate Cleft with Absorbable Membrane: the New Surgical Technique and Its Clinical Application.

Transverse Maxillary Development in Complete Cleft Patients: Comparison of 2 Treatment Strategies by Longitudinal and Cross-Sectional Model Analysis

Surgical Correction of Velopharyngeal Insufficiency in Cleft Palate Patients with Two Procedures of Reconstruction of Radical Intravelar Veloplasties (Ivvs)

Incidence Of Palatal Fistula After Palatoplasty With Levator Veli Palatini Retropositioning According To Sommerlad

Single vs. Double-Opposing Z-Plasty: Evaluating Their Impact on Palatoplasty Postoperative Outcomes

Clinical study on secondary alveolar bone grafting by lip side combined with palate side approach

The relationship between cleft palate repair technique and audiological outcomes: A retrospective cohort study

Evaluation of postoperative outcomes in palatoplasty with three soft palate cleft repairs

The impact of surgical technique and cleft width on the rate of secondary surgery and velopharyngeal function in children with UCLP at 5 years of age

An Analysis of Velopharyngeal Function about Repairing the Hard Palate Cleft with the Composited Artificial Bone after Five Years

Comparative study on cleft palate morphology after passive presurgical plate therapy in unilateral cleft lip and palate

Comparison of two surgical protocols for the treatment of unilateral cleft lip and palate: a multidisciplinary systematic review and meta-analysis

Evaluation of Postoperative Outcomes Following Early and Late Palate Repair: A Preclinical Study