Comparison of treatment plans between proton and X-ray therapy in pediatric craniopharyngioma

陈佳艺,Régis FERRAND,Léontine RABARIJAONA,Jean-Louis HABRAND

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1007-3639.2003.04.017

2003-01-01

Abstract:Purpose: Comparative treatment planning with megavoltage X - rays and protons has been done tor three pediatric craniopharyngioma patients in an attempt to determine if there are any advantages of using protons instead of X -rays. Methods: Prescribed dose was 55 Gy for each of the three cases. Three different treatment plans were compared, one X - rays, one protons and one mixed beams. Both of the systems were in 3 - D conformal conditions. A conformal index study has been done in order to quantify the target volume coverage and undesired irradiation in normal tissue. Results: All of the three treatment plans gave satisfactory target volume coverage. Ninety-two to 100% of the PTV were within the 95% isodose area. The introduction of the protons beams has shown a therapeutic benefit by a general reduction of the dose to the contingent intracranial organs including normal cerebral tissue, brain stem, temporal lobes and internal ears. Protontherapy reduces also the mean and minimun dose delivered to the optic chiasma when there is a limited space between the tumor and the optic chiasma. The exclusive protontherapy has shown a benefit more important than the combined beams. The conformal factor was 0. 631, 0. 784 and 0. 848 for X-rays, mixed beams and protons respectively, indicating that the high dose area delivered by the protons beams confined better the shape of the PTV. Conclusions: Protons beams allow a better sparing of the normal intracranial organs without compromising the target coverage in the treatment of pediatric craniopharyngioma and is estimated to give the possibility of dose escalation in certains cases so as to improve the local control.