Abstract:In this research, a hybrid game theory and mathematical programming model (HGT-MPM) is proposed for solving trans-boundary water conflicts in Guanting reservoir basin (GRB) between two cities (Le., Zhangjiakou and Beijing) in north China. A water allocation model, which considers both water quality and quantity, is developed for optimizing water use and pollutant discharge in the two cities, maximizing the net aggregate benefits from these activities and reducing the costs for water supply and pollution removal. The initial rights of water use and pollutant discharge are allocated to the cities of Beijing and Zhangjiakou, as two players based on the incorporation of a negotiation method for ill-defined water rights within the watershed. At this stage, equal treatment of every player's benefit claim can be addressed. The strategy spaces of the two players are delineated through solving the proposed HGT-MPM with mutual benefit claim constraints. The Rubinstein bargaining solution method is employed to identify the equilibrium of bargaining. To achieve maximal benefits for the two players, starting from allocating the results of the second step, the concepts of Core and Nash solutions of cooperative games are used to generate stable basin-wide cooperative solutions. Both players find it beneficial to cooperate with side payment from the downstream to upstream. At this stage, the principle of maximum economic benefits is mainly considered. The results indicate that unclear initial water rights and pollutant discharge rights can be fairly defined through bilateral negotiations between upstream and downstream. Without side payment, the initial water rights and pollutant discharge allocation will be the final outcome, which is sub-optimal, although it is better than the status quo in term of both total and individual benefits. Full cooperation with side payment leads to the greatest total net benefits and the greatest benefits to each individual city. The results not only provide a basis to allocate trans-jurisdictional water rights and pollutant discharge rights in an equal and efficient way but also provide certain inspirations for management policy improvement, such as establishing a water right trading system.

Game Analysis for Conflicts in Water Resource Allocation

Pollution Control Costs of A Transboundary River Basin: Empirical Tests of the Fairness and Stability of Cost Allocation Mechanisms Using Game Theory

Analysis of Game Theory Application in the Land Acquisition of Major Projects in China's Urban Area

Generalized Uncooperative Planar Game Theory Model for Water Distribution in Transboundary Rivers

A Cooperative Game Model with Bankruptcy Theory for Water Allocation: A Case Study in China Tarim River Basin

A Hybrid Game Theory and Mathematical Programming Model for Solving Trans-Boundary Water Conflicts

Analysis on competition strategy and regulatory strategy of international river water resources system – with the participation of co-operational agencies

Unpacking Water Conflicts: a Reinterpretation of Coordination Problems in China’s Water-Governance System

Game Analysis of Government-controlled Water Right System

Economic Analysis and Countermeasures on the Yellow River's Cut- off

Study on the Investment-Benefit Coordination Mechanism of Cross-Regional Water Project

Study on Balanced Allocation of Water Resources in the Yellow River Basin Based on Water Benefit Sharing

Evolution of stakeholder behavior strategies in the water quantity eco-compensation mechanism of water use coordination inside and outside the river

Compensation For Agricultural Water Saving And Construction Of Stakeholders' Interest: Evidence From Zhejiang Province

Application of Game Model for Stakeholder Management in Construction of Ecological Corridors: A Case Study on Yangtze River Basin in China

Evolution of water resource allocation in the river basin between administrators and managers

Evolutionary game analysis of water-saving behavior of energy enterprises and food producers from the perspective of water-energy-food nexus

Analysis on Environmental Policies of Trans-boundary Water Pollution Conflicts in China

Allocation Model for Water Right

Analysis of regional water resources spatial pattern and allocation equity

Cost-Sharing Mechanism of Water Pollution Control in Main and Subbasins Based on Stackelberg Game Model