Abstract:Team incentives are important in many compensation systems that pay workers according to the output of their team as well as to their own output, with team bonuses often depending on whether the team meets or exceeds specified thresholds. Yet little is known about how team members with different abilities respond to compensation rules and thresholds. We contrast the performance of lower ability participants and higher ability participants in an experiment with three distribution schemes – equal sharing, piece rate sharing, and tournament style winner-takes-all – in settings with and without a team threshold. Workers randomly assigned to equal sharing had higher productivity than those assigned to winner-takes-all and had similar productivity to workers in piece-rate scheme. Output under equal sharing was boosted by the higher productivity of less able workers, possibly motivated by a desire to avoid guilt feelings about letting down their partners, per models of guilt aversion. Given a choice of distribution schemes, participants selected piece rate over equal sharing and favored both of these over winner-takes-all; in addition, a team threshold induced more concern about cooperation and thus greater preference for equal sharing. The findings suggest that organizations with teams of workers with varying abilities are likely to do better if the organization can consider lower ability workers’ responsiveness to sharing in rewards, e.g., to have an equal sharing component in its compensation system when they are strongly guilt averse.Institutional subscribers to the NBER working paper series, and residents of developing countries may download this paper without additional charge at www.nber.org.

Efficiency Comparison of Team Incentives Based on Different Game Timing under Reciprocity

A Game Analysis of the Incentive Mechanism for Team Cooperation——From Reciprocity Perspective

Triggering Reciprocity in a Principal-Agent Game

Research on Cooperation Behavior in Multi-team System Based on Reciprocity Preference

Reciprocal motivations based on interest conflict

Historical Payoff Promotes Cooperation in the Prisoner's Dilemma Game

Dynamic reciprocal effect research based on different information conditions

Multigames with Voluntary Participation on Interdependent Networks and the Evolution of Cooperation

The Design of Team Incentive Model and the Explanation of Free-Riding Problem Based on Inequity Aversion

Investment Projects Decision Model and Numerical Simulation Analysis Based on Sequential Reciprocity Equilibrium

A Game Analysis of the Incentive Meachanism for Cooperation

Cooperation and Distributed Optimization for the Unreliable Wireless Game with Indirect Reciprocity.

A Study on the Cournot Model with Altruism

A Study on the Cooperation Behavioral of Multi-Participates Project Team

Optimal Distribution of Incentives for Public Cooperation in Heterogeneous Interaction Environments.

An Experimental Comparison between Winner-up and Loser-out Tournaments

Optimal Design of Team Incentive Mechanism Based on Principal-Agent Theory

Analyzing reciprocity dynamics in supply chains of public goods: a stochastic evolutionary game approach

Team Incentives and Lower Ability Workers: an Experimental Study on Real-Effort Tasks

Competition for talent: heterogenous abilities in team production

Study On The Relation Between Team Cooperation And Incentive Structure And The Game Model