Comment on "Magma-dynamic Evidence for Indosinian Emplacement and Tectonic Implication of the Early Yanshanian Granite Batholiths, South China: Based on Estimates of Emplacement Age for the 8 Granite Batholiths in Nanling Range"

Wang Xiang
2014-01-01
Abstract:On the basis of tectonic, petrological and metallogenic observations, this paper suggests that the generation, emplacementand consolidification of the early Yanshanian granitic magmas in the Nanling Range took place nearly in the identical time, representedby their zircon U-Pb ages. In consequence, the conclusion of Zhang et al.(2014) should be unrealistic.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?