Observation of pseudoscalar and tensor resonances in $J/\psi\rightarrow \gamma \phi \phi$

M. Ablikim,M. N. Achasov,X. C. Ai,O. Albayrak,M. Albrecht,D. J. Ambrose,A. Amoroso,F. F. An,Q. An,J. Z. Bai,R. Baldini Ferroli,Y. Ban,D. W. Bennett,J. V. Bennett,M. Bertani,D. Bettoni,J. M. Bian,F. Bianchi,E. Boger,I. Boyko,R. A. Briere,H. Cai,X. Cai,O. Cakir,A. Calcaterra,G. F. Cao,S. A. Cetin,J. F. Chang,G. Chelkov,G. Chen,H. S. Chen,H. Y. Chen,J. C. Chen,M. L. Chen,S. J. Chen,X. Chen,X. R. Chen,Y. B. Chen,H. P. Cheng,X. K. Chu,G. Cibinetto,H. L. Dai,J. P. Dai,A. Dbeyssi,D. Dedovich,Z. Y. Deng,A. Denig,I. Denysenko,M. Destefanis,F. De Mori,Y. Ding,C. Dong,J. Dong,L. Y. Dong,M. Y. Dong,Z. L. Dou,S. X. Du,P. F. Duan,J. Z. Fan,J. Fang,S. S. Fang,X. Fang,Y. Fang,R. Farinelli,L. Fava,O. Fedorov,F. Feldbauer,G. Felici,C. Q. Feng,E. Fioravanti,M. Fritsch,C. D. Fu,Q. Gao,X. L. Gao,X. Y. Gao,Y. Gao,Z. Gao,I. Garzia,K. Goetzen,L. Gong,W. X. Gong,W. Gradl,M. Greco,M. H. Gu,Y. T. Gu,Y. H. Guan,A. Q. Guo,L. B. Guo,Y. Guo,Y. P. Guo,Z. Haddadi,A. Hafner,S. Han,X. Q. Hao,F. A. Harris,K. L. He,T. Held,Y. K. Heng,Z. L. Hou,C. Hu,H. M. Hu,J. F. Hu,T. Hu,Y. Hu,G. S. Huang,J. S. Huang,X. T. Huang,Y. Huang,T. Hussain,Q. Ji,Q. P. Ji,X. B. Ji,X. L. Ji,L. W. Jiang,X. S. Jiang,X. Y. Jiang,J. B. Jiao,Z. Jiao,D. P. Jin,S. Jin,T. Johansson,A. Julin,N. Kalantar-Nayestanaki,X. L. Kang,X. S. Kang,M. Kavatsyuk,B. C. Ke,P. Kiese,R. Kliemt,B. Kloss,O. B. Kolcu,B. Kopf,M. Kornicer,A. Kupsc,W. Kühn,J. S. Lange,M. Lara,P. Larin,C. Leng,C. Li,Cheng Li,D. M. Li,F. Li,F. Y. Li,G. Li,H. B. Li,J. C. Li,Jin Li,K. Li,Lei Li,P. R. Li,Q. Y. Li,T. Li,W. D. Li,W. G. Li,X. L. Li,X. N. Li,X. Q. Li,Z. B. Li,H. Liang,Y. F. Liang,Y. T. Liang,G. R. Liao,D. X. Lin,B. J. Liu,C. X. Liu,D. Liu,F. H. Liu,Fang Liu,Feng Liu,H. B. Liu,H. H. Liu,H. M. Liu,J. Liu,J. B. Liu,J. P. Liu,J. Y. Liu,K. Liu,K. Y. Liu,L. D. Liu,P. L. Liu,Q. Liu,S. B. Liu,X. Liu,Y. B. Liu,Z. A. Liu,Zhiqing Liu,H. Loehner,X. C. Lou,H. J. Lu,J. G. Lu,Y. Lu,Y. P. Lu,C. L. Luo,M. X. Luo,T. Luo,X. L. Luo,X. R. Lyu,F. C. Ma,H. L. Ma,L. L. Ma,Q. M. Ma,T. Ma,X. N. Ma,X. Y. Ma,Y. M. Ma,F. E. Maas,M. Maggiora,Y. J. Mao,Z. P. Mao,S. Marcello,J. G. Messchendorp,J. Min,R. E. Mitchell,X. H. Mo,Y. J. Mo,C. Morales Morales,N. Yu. Muchnoi,H. Muramatsu,Y. Nefedov,F. Nerling,I. B. Nikolaev,Z. Ning,S. Nisar,S. L. Niu,X. Y. Niu,S. L. Olsen,Q. Ouyang,S. Pacetti,Y. Pan,P. Patteri,M. Pelizaeus,H. P. Peng,K. Peters,J. Pettersson,J. L. Ping,R. G. Ping,R. Poling,V. Prasad,H. R. Qi,M. Qi,S. Qian,C. F. Qiao,L. Q. Qin,N. Qin,X. S. Qin,Z. H. Qin,J. F. Qiu,K. H. Rashid,C. F. Redmer,M. Ripka,G. Rong,Ch. Rosner,X. D. Ruan,V. Santoro,A. Sarantsev,M. Savrié,K. Schoenning,S. Schumann,W. Shan,M. Shao,C. P. Shen,P. X. Shen,X. Y. Shen,H. Y. Sheng,W. M. Song,X. Y. Song,S. Sosio,S. Spataro,G. X. Sun,J. F. Sun,S. S. Sun,Y. J. Sun,Y. Z. Sun,Z. J. Sun,Z. T. Sun,C. J. Tang,X. Tang,I. Tapan,E. H. Thorndike,M. Tiemens,M. Ullrich,I. Uman,G. S. Varner,B. Wang,B. L. Wang,D. Wang,D. Y. Wang,K. Wang,L. L. Wang,L. S. Wang,M. Wang,P. Wang,P. L. Wang,S. G. Wang,W. Wang,W. P. Wang,X. F. Wang,Y. D. Wang,Y. F. Wang,Y. Q. Wang,Z. Wang,Z. G. Wang,Z. H. Wang,Z. Y. Wang,T. Weber,D. H. Wei,J. B. Wei,P. Weidenkaff,S. P. Wen,U. Wiedner,M. Wolke,L. H. Wu,Z. Wu,L. Xia,L. G. Xia,Y. Xia,D. Xiao,H. Xiao,Z. J. Xiao,Y. G. Xie,Q. L. Xiu,G. F. Xu,L. Xu,Q. J. Xu,Q. N. Xu,X. P. Xu,L. Yan,W. B. Yan,W. C. Yan,Y. H. Yan,H. J. Yang,H. X. Yang,L. Yang,Y. X. Yang,M. Ye,M. H. Ye,J. H. Yin,B. X. Yu,C. X. Yu,J. S. Yu,C. Z. Yuan,W. L. Yuan,Y. Yuan,A. Yuncu,A. A. Zafar,A. Zallo,Y. Zeng,Z. Zeng,B. X. Zhang,B. Y. Zhang,C. Zhang,C. C. Zhang,D. H. Zhang,H. H. Zhang,H. Y. Zhang,J. J. Zhang,J. L. Zhang,J. Q. Zhang,J. W. Zhang,J. Y. Zhang,J. Z. Zhang,K. Zhang,L. Zhang,X. Y. Zhang,Y. Zhang,Y. H. Zhang,Y. N. Zhang,Y. T. Zhang,Yu Zhang,Z. H. Zhang,Z. P. Zhang,Z. Y. Zhang,G. Zhao,J. W. Zhao,J. Y. Zhao,J. Z. Zhao,Lei Zhao,Ling Zhao,M. G. Zhao,Q. Zhao,Q. W. Zhao,S. J. Zhao,T. C. Zhao,Y. B. Zhao,Z. G. Zhao,A. Zhemchugov,B. Zheng,J. P. Zheng,W. J. Zheng,Y. H. Zheng,B. Zhong,L. Zhou,X. Zhou,X. K. Zhou,X. R. Zhou,X. Y. Zhou,K. Zhu,K. J. Zhu,S. Zhu,S. H. Zhu,X. L. Zhu,Y. C. Zhu,Y. S. Zhu,Z. A. Zhu,J. Zhuang,L. Zotti,B. S. Zou,J. H. Zou

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.93.032011

2016-01-01

Abstract: Based on a sample of $(1310.6 \pm 10.5) \times 10^{6}$ $J/\psi$ events collected with the BESIII detector operating at the BEPCII storage ring, a partial wave analysis of the decay $J/\psi\rightarrow \gamma \phi \phi$ is performed in order to study the intermediate states. Results of the partial wave analysis show that the structures are predominantly $0^{-+}$ states. The existence of the $\eta(2225)$ is confirmed, and its resonance parameters are measured. Two additional pseudoscalar states, the $\eta(2100)$ with a mass of $2050_{-24}^{+30}{}_{-26}^{+75}$~MeV/$c^{2}$ and a width of $250_{-30}^{+36}{}_{-164}^{+181}$~MeV/$c^{2}$ and the $X(2500)$ with a mass of $2470_{-19}^{+15}{}_{-23}^{+101}$~MeV/$c^{2}$ and a width of $230_{-35}^{+64}{}_{-33}^{+56}$~MeV/$c^{2}$, are observed. In addition to these three pseudoscalar states, the scalar state $f_0(2100)$, and three tensor states, the $f_2(2010)$, $f_2(2300)$ and $f_2(2340)$, are observed in the process $J/\psi\rightarrow \gamma \phi\phi$. The product branching fractions ${\cal B}$($J/\psi\rightarrow \gamma X)\times{\cal B}(X\rightarrow \phi \phi)$ are reported.