Abstract:Increase of concentrations of greenhouse gases (GHGs) in atmosphere have garnered lots of attention due to the associated risk of global warming. Carbon footprint (CF) is a measure that is extensively used to assess the contribution of an individual, event, organization, or product to global climate change. In the current study, the CF of five agricultural systems with different crop systems in different regions in China was evaluated in terms of CO2 eq per hectare, per kg crop yield, and per unit economic output, association with soil GHGs, agrochemical production and soil organic carbon (SOC) change. The results showed that direct nitrous oxide accounted for 61.9–97.8% of total soil GHG emissions in upland fields (agroforestry system, summer maize-winter wheat rotation tillage system, maize-soybean intercropping system, and continuous maize tillage system), while soil methane accounted for 89.9–95.1% of total soil GHG emissions in the paddy field (double rice-winter crop rotation system). GHGs produced from agricultural inputs varied from 2698.7 to 9781.5 kg CO2 eq ha−1 yr−1 among different agricultural systems. Nitrogen fertilizer was the dominant source of GHGs, which accounted for 47.4–92.4% of the total emission. Annual SOC increase ranged from −639.9–13823.9 kg CO2 eq ha−1 yr−1 in the five agricultural systems. Increases of SOC in the treatment of “reduced tillage with straw return” offset all of the total GHG emissions while “conventional tillage without straw return” decreased SOC storage in the continuous maize tillage system. An increase of SOC in crop systems of the other four agricultural systems could offset 23.2–66.7% of the total GHG emissions. Carbon emissions per hectare in the double rice-winter crop rotation system (7339.93–22994.17 kg CO2 eq ha−1 yr−1) were higher than the other four agricultural systems (−744.96–6523.12 kg CO2 eq ha−1 yr−1). In terms of crop yield, CFs of the summer maize-winter wheat rotation tillage system (0.28–0.34 kg CO2 eq kg−1 yr−1) were lower than those from the other four agricultural systems (0.39–2.83 kg CO2 eq kg−1 yr−1), except for the treatment with reduced tillage and residue return in the continuous maize tillage system. Similarly, CFs, as quantified via per unit economic output of the agroforestry system (0.12–0.19 kg CO2 eq ¥−1 yr−1), were lower than those in other the four systems (0.26–0.89 kg CO2 eq ¥−1 yr−1).Different evaluation methodology greatly affected the CF of different crop systems and mostly likely contributed to the contrary evaluation results, especially in the complex system of various crop systems (agroforestry and double rice-winter crop rotation system) in current study. Evaluation results of the CF of an agricultural system depends highly on the methodology used and may suggest different management decisions for lowering CF to promote the development of cleaner production.

Carbon Footprints of Grain-, Forage-, and Energy-Based Cropping Systems in the North China Plain

Reducing agricultural carbon footprint through diversified crop rotation systems in the North China Plain

The Carbon Footprint and Influencing Factors of the Main Grain Crops in the North China Plain

Carbon footprint of farming practices in farmland ecosystems on the North and Northeast China plains

Comparison of Carbon Footprint Between Spring Maize-Late Rice and Early Rice-Late Rice Cropping System

Reducing carbon footprint without compromising grain security through relaxing cropping rotation system in the North China Plain

Farm-scale practical strategies to reduce carbon footprint and emergy while increasing economic benefits in crop production in the North China plain

Drivers and Reduction Potential of Carbon Emissions from Cultivated Land Use

Carbon footprint for wheat and maize production modulated by farm size: a study in the North China plain

Trends, distribution, and impact factors of carbon footprints of main grains production in China

Reduce carbon footprint without compromising system productivity: Optimizing crop rotation in the North China plain

Carbon footprint of main crop production in China: Magnitude, spatial-temporal pattern and attribution

Carbon footprint of different agricultural systems in China estimated by different evaluation metrics

Effects of tillage and cropping sequences on crop production and environmental benefits in the North China Plain

Greenhouse Gas Emissions, Carbon Footprint, and Grain Yields of Rice-Based Cropping Systems in Eastern China

Livestock-cropland re-coupling and intensive farming: Strategies for enhancing greenhouse gas mitigation and eco-efficiency in wheat-maize production in north China plain

Patterns of carbon footprints of main grains production in China: a comparison between main and non-main producing areas

Evaluation of Water–Carbon–Ecological Footprint and Its Spatial–Temporal Changes in the North China Plain

Effect of straw retention on carbon footprint under different cropping sequences in Northeast China

Farm-scale practical strategies to increase nitrogen use efficiency and reduce nitrogen footprint in crop production across the North China Plain

Comprehensive analysis of resource utilization efficiency under different tillage systems in North China Plain