The Role of Mediain Replacing Politically Connected CEOs： Evidence from China
吴超鹏,叶小杰,吴世农
DOI: https://doi.org/10.19616/j.cnki.bmj.2012.02.009
2012-01-01
Abstract:One unique feature of Chinese listed companies is that many of their CEOs are politically connected. According to Fan, Wong and Zhang （2007）, 27% of the CEOs in Chinese listed companies serve as current or former government bureaucrat, i. e. , they have political connection. Although politically connected CEOs are detrimental to shareholders＇ interests （Leuz and Oberholzer-Gee, 2006; Fan, et. al. , 2007 ）, the political power increases their ability to be insulated from involuntary replacement by internal governance （Pi and Lowe, 2010）. Recent studies document that media act positively in improving corporate governance （Dyck and Zingales, 2008; Li and Shen, 2010, etc. ）. However, none of them indicate the role of media in disciplining politically connected CEOs. This paper fills the gap by examining whether media shaming could increase the likelihood that politically connected CEOs will be replaced after they made ＂bad＂ acquisitions. We propose that there are two main mechanisms through which media have an effect. First, the criticisms of ＂bad＂ acquisitions in the press could shame the CEOs to resign, or exert pressure on board of directors to replace the CEOs. Second, media pressure forces regulators into action and even trigger some legal punishment of CEOs＇ misbehavior. To test our hypothesis, we study the ease of China over the 1998 to 2008 period. The cultural and institutional setting of China offers us a useful laboratory setting for such a study ： First, shaming, or put other people to shame, is part of the Confucian cultural heritage. When other people pointed out the misbehavior of a righteous person, he will feel shameful, remorse, and will try to remedy it. Therefore, under such a cultural environment, media shaming is more likely to play a role in reducing corporate governance violation. Second, China is characterized by a vast diversity across provinces. China was split into small and independent countries in 65% of the time in China＇s history, from 841 BC to 1911 AD. Different provinces in this most populous country have different levels of marketization, legal environment and government interference. As a result, the development of media supervision system also varies greatly across the provinces （Yu, 2010 ）. China, therefore, is a good candidate for studying the effects of media supervision at the provincial level on disciplining politically connected CEOs. In an alyzing the effect of media supervision, we utilize two measures of media supervision on acquisition transactions. The first measure is the number of articles in newspapers gives negative comments on the acquisition in a period from 3 months prior to the first bid to 3 years after the deal completes. The second measure is Yu＇s （2010） China Media Development Index（CMDI） which measures the development of media supervision system at the provincial level. Based on a sample of 209 large acquisitions made by Chinese listed companies during 1998 to 2008, we find that a significant inverse relation exists between acquisition performance and the likelihood of CEO turnover. However, this inverse relation is weaker for politically connected CEOs. We further show that although the political connection could protect CEOs from being fired after conducting bad bids, this effect is reduced as the increase of negative media coverage and if the companies are located in the provinces with stronger media supervision. Our paper contributes to a growing number of studies on the real effects of media coverage. Previous literatures show that media pressure could curb private benefits （Dyck and Zingales, 2004） , acts as ＂watchdog＂ for accounting fraud （Miller, 2006）, improve the board quality（Joe etal. , 2009）, and reduce corporate governance violation （Dyck and Zingales, 2008）. Our paper expands the existing work by illuminating the cultural foundation of the mechanism through which media could discipline politically connected CEO. Our results also provide plenty of policy suggestions on how to make better use of governance role of media in China and other Confucianism-dominated Asian countries.