Environmental effects on animal production: the nutritional demands of nematode parasite exposure in sheep.
A. Sykes,G. M. Stone
Abstract:The complex interplay between nutrition and response to nematode parasites in sheep is described. The effect of infection on host metabolism and nutrient requirements are considered as well as the evidence that host resilience and immunity can be moderated by improved protein and trace element nutrition. The conclusion is drawn that host immunity may be dependent on a much greater protein supply than current estimates of requirement or can be supplied by pasture. It is speculated that ewe nutrition in the peri-partum period may have important epidemiological consequences. Prof. McClymont is recognised for his contribution to education in animal production and health and applied nutritional problems of ewe nutrition, particularly adapting the animal to environmental demands, in his specific case drought feeding. At the time of Dr McClymont’s work government funded research emphasised basic nutritional studies of animals in controlled environments to provide information about the utilisation of energy in growth and how it varies with the rate of growth, type of ration, development pattern and ultimate mature size. It lead to the metabolisable energy (ME) system, a scheme which....“avoids the errors of the previous ones by not muddling the efficiency of the animal with the nutritive value ascribed to food, and at every stage in the calculations one is cognisant of the limitations of existing knowledge” ...(Blaxter, 1962). The limitations were considerable when these estimates were applied to animals in pastoral environments. Geenty and Rattray (1987) argued that “relative to pen feeding, maintenance requirements of grazing sheep can increase by 30-80% depending on feed supply, climatic conditions and topography. The National Research Councils of several countries used so-called fudge factors which adjusted precise penbased estimates by 20-50% on arbitrary grounds to account for these “environmental” demands. At the time of these nutritional studies the epidemiology of the major nematode parasites was being worked out (Brunsdon, 1970; Donald and Waller, 1982; Michel, 1963). Pathophysiological studies of the effect of parasitism in sheep were designed to throw light on the extreme clinical disease – emaciation and death, so typical of the era before effective anthelmintics became available. Very large larval doses were used to establish infections which resulted in extreme clinical disease at the time of patency of the worm. During the 1970’s and 1980’s, however, nutritionists began to take an interest in quantifying the pathophysiological effects of parasitism. In order to produce ‘relatively stable’ levels of infection – always difficult because of the dynamic interplay between the incoming larvae and the hosts’ immune system – they began to use trickle (daily) infection of small numbers of larvae. What these demonstrated was that even in subclinical infections major reductions – up to 50% in energy utilisation could occur (Reveron et al, 1974; Steel, 1974; Sykes and Coop, 1976; 1977). It is now reasonable to suggest that those socalled fudge factors used to convert estimates of nutrient requirement from calorimeter to paddock also included the additional cost to the host of combating pathogenic components of the natural environment including nematode parasites. This cost has now been identified as having at least two componentsthe cost of repair of the gastrointestinal tissue damage caused by the parasite and the cost of mounting an immune response and so limiting or preventing further tissue damage. Moreover, studies are increasingly suggesting that nematode infection of the gastrointestinal tract, rather than reducing ability of the host to digest and absorb nutrients as assumed in the past – actually increases nutrient requirement. Moreover, there is increasing evidence that in some circumstances it may be possible to meet this requirement and therefore influence the disease outcome. PATHOPHYSIOLOGY OF INFECTION The pathophysiological/nutritional impact of gastro-intestinal nematode parasitism has been the subject of numerous recent comprehensive reviews (Sykes, 1982; MacRae, 1993; Coop and Holmes, 1996; van Houtert and Sykes, 1996; Coop and Kyriazakis, 1999). A major component of the effect of parasitism in reducing overall efficiency of nutrient use is a reduction in feed intake which can reach 50%, even in subclinical cases. The extent of its contribution to reduced energetic efficiency appears to be greater in infections of the abomasum than in infections in the small intestine (Sykes, 1994; Coop and Kyriazakis, 1999). Increased N flow in the digestive tract occurs and has been attributed to increased leakage of plasma proteins, increased mucous secretion and sloughing of epithelial cells. While these secretions are substantially resorbed in distal sections of the gastrointestinal tract (GIT) they do lead to increased protein synthesis and energy demand in the GIT. In effect energy and protein appear to be preferentially sequestered to the Asian-Aus. J. Anim. Sci. 13 Supplement July 2000 A: 343-350 alimentary tract (MacRae,1993), thus increasing maintenance energy requirement. When efficiency of nutrient utilisation is calculated as the ratio of NE deposited to ME available, reduction in feed intake and the diversion of ME to maintenance of the alimentary tract contribute to reductions of efficiency of up to 50% even in subclinical infections (Sykes, 1982). Very recently sophisticated experimental approaches involving catheterisation of the alimentary tract and its vascular bed, coupled with mass isotope tracer kinetics (Yu, 1998; 1999) have shown that sequestration of leucine leaving the alimentary tract before entering the mesenteric and hepatic circulation was increased by 24% and its oxidation by 39%. Although whole body leucine flux was not affected the availability of amino acid for metabolism in peripheral tissues – skeleton and muscle – was markedly reduced. These findings confirm earlier studies (Symons and Jones, 1975; 1981) in sheep and guinea pigs which showed increased protein synthesis in the gastrointestinal tract. They also explain the change in apparent efficiency of use of energy (Sykes, 1982) especially given that splanchnic tissue normally accounts for 30-45% of whole body protein synthesis despite contributing only 5% of body protein mass (McRae, 1993). Some of the early studies (Sykes and Coop, 1976) were specifically designed to provide an understanding as to whether parasitism could be implicated in the osteoporosis typically seen in growing sheep in parts of Scotland (Nisbet et al., 1962). Infection in the small intestine – typically with T. colubriformis (Sykes et al., 1975) or Trichostrongylus vitrinus (Sykes et al., 1977) did indeed show reduced bone growth and, specifically, reduced bone matrix deposition, undoubtedly a result of the change in priority of protein metabolism described above. However, a very reliable finding of numerous studies of intestinal parasitism has been a hypophosphataemia with resultant impaired calcium and phosphorus deposition in the skeleton. Subsequent studies have shown this to be the result of impaired P absorption (Wilson and Field, 1983). There is no conclusive evidence in these studies for change in Ca absorption, nor for any effect of infection in other sites on Ca or P metabolism. There is some evidence for the disturbance of the metabolism of some other minerals though not necessarily with effect on productivity. Very significant losses of Na into the gastrointestinal tract occur in abomasal and intestinal infections though these can be very effectively reabsorbed (Wilson and Field, 1983). However, though Suttle et al., (1996) observed a direct association between apparent Na status, as judged by Na:K ratio of less than 5 in saliva, and abomasal damage, as judged by plasma pepsinogen, Na supplementation did not improve productivity. Interactions between parasites and trace element nutrition have long been suspected, possibly because of their undoubted independent roles along with feed supply and quality in the clinical disease ‘ill-thrift’ July disease in the northern hemisphere (Suttle, 1994). To date there have been few convincing quantitative nutritional studies to show either impairment of absorption or increase in requirement. The pH environment in the abomasum can be changed from the normal pH 2.5 to 6.5 by infection in this organ, and changes in solubility or ability to bind with transporters may be expected. Evidence for impaired absorption is available for Cu, but not, to my knowledge for any other trace element. Bang et al (1990), showed a direct negative relationship between abomasal pH, modified by abomasal infection, and both ‘soluble’ copper concentration in abomasal liquid and the increase in liver Cu after administration of Cu-oxide wire particles. Reductions in liver Cu concentration correlated with increase in abomasal pH have been induced by infection with Haemonchus contortus (Ortolani et al,1993). WHAT IS THE VALUE OF THIS INFORMATION? The difficulty for nutritionists in incorporating this information into estimates of nutrient requirement is that this host-parasite relationship is an unstable and evolving one, governed on the one hand by variation in incoming larvae and on the other by the state of readiness or competence of the host’s immune system though it has been estimated that full immunity itself may cost the equivalent of a 15% loss of productivity (Sykes, 1994). The dependence of the free-living stages of nematodes on climate and the availability of susceptible hosts – the immunologically naïve lamb and the immunologically compromised ewe in the peripaturient period -combine to provide typical patterns of larval availability for particular environments. In addition local climate determines the availability of particular nematode genera. For example, the greater ability of Teladorsagia spp. to develop and survi