Is There a Pure Quantum Spin Liquid?
Gaoting Lin,Jie Ma
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.xinn.2023.100484
2023-01-01
Abstract:Spin liquids are exotic materials where the magnetic order is absent due to fluctuations at any finite temperature less than the spin interaction. Their occurrence is attributed to a high degree of ground state degeneracy. Wannier showed in 1950 that such a large degeneracy of ground state can theoretically take place in a two-dimensional (2D) triangular lattice with Ising spins, a classically geometrical frustrated lattice mode. So far, the geometrically frustrated lattice has a large family of systems: edge-shared triangles as a triangular lattice and corner-shared triangles as a kagomé lattice in a 2D system and corner-sharing tetrahedra as a pyrochlore lattice in a three-dimensional system, etc.1Broholm C. Cava R.J. Kivelson S.A. et al.Quantum spin liquids.Science. 2020; 367eaay0668Crossref PubMed Scopus (380) Google Scholar,2Balents L. Spin liquids in frustrated magnets.Nature. 2010; 464: 199-208Crossref PubMed Scopus (2915) Google Scholar,3Ma J. Spins don’t align here.Nat. Phys. 2023; 19: 922-923Crossref Scopus (1) Google Scholar The realization of a real spin-liquid material has been one of the great challenges in condensed matter physics. Spin fluctuations can be both classical and quantum in the spin liquids.1Broholm C. Cava R.J. Kivelson S.A. et al.Quantum spin liquids.Science. 2020; 367eaay0668Crossref PubMed Scopus (380) Google Scholar Due to the magnetically geometrical frustration, spin order is prevented by thermal fluctuations. If the quantum fluctuation is not included, a classical spin liquid ground state should be obtained theoretically. When the spin liquids are beyond the conventional Landau paradigm for phase transitions and spontaneous symmetry breaking, the topological condensed matter physics becomes an important theoretical basis of describing the spin liquid ground state with long-range entangled phases and topological orders. Such a prototype may be implemented by a frustrated lattice with smaller magnetism comparable to 1/2 that is more likely to occur with the high degree of ground state degeneracy and strong quantum fluctuations. Long-range entanglement can appear and give rise to a quantum spin liquid (QSL) ground state. Half a century ago, in 1973, Philip Anderson introduced the definition of resonating valence bond in the spin-1/2 triangular lattice antiferromagnetic nearest-neighbor Heisenberg model, Figure 1A, which is considered the earliest prototype of the term “QSL.” Although such a state ultimately proved to be questionable, the frustration effect in achieving QSL phases has attracted tremendous attention.1Broholm C. Cava R.J. Kivelson S.A. et al.Quantum spin liquids.Science. 2020; 367eaay0668Crossref PubMed Scopus (380) Google Scholar In 1987, the discovery of high-temperature superconductivity led to a revival of QSLs that continues today. Thus far, topological phases remain the most in-depth and best examples of understanding the QSL ground state, and the subject is steadily evolving. However, a clear experimental observation of QSLs still faces significant challenges owing to the limitations from material preparation, intrinsic-behavior testing, and theoretical methods. The theoretical prediction suggests that “weak” Mott insulators, approaching the metal-insulator transition, have great potential to achieve QSL phases.1Broholm C. Cava R.J. Kivelson S.A. et al.Quantum spin liquids.Science. 2020; 367eaay0668Crossref PubMed Scopus (380) Google Scholar,2Balents L. Spin liquids in frustrated magnets.Nature. 2010; 464: 199-208Crossref PubMed Scopus (2915) Google Scholar,3Ma J. Spins don’t align here.Nat. Phys. 2023; 19: 922-923Crossref Scopus (1) Google Scholar Hence, the geometrically frustrated spin-1/2 Mott insulators with strong quantum fluctuations have always been a key focus for achieving QSLs. Although a great many interesting candidate compounds with geometrically frustrated lattices have emerged that can assist in the generation of a QSL, the evidence is circumstantial. Triangular compounds are one of the simplest frustrated systems, and strong quantum fluctuations have been demonstrated with the spin-1/2 magnetic ions occupying the edge-shared-triangle sites, where a series of exotic physical phenomena have been exhibited, such as the magnetic plateau and QSL behaviors. A representative candidate, YbMgGaO4, was proposed as a structurally perfect rare-earth triangular antiferromagnet with a 6-fold symmetry component, R-3m, and the similar quantum behaviors were obtained from the triangular antiferromagnets, such as the organic systems of EtMe3Sb[Pd(dmit)2]2 and κ-(BEDT-TTF)2Cu2(CN)3 and the inorganic systems of Cs2Cu(Cl, Br)4 and Ba3CoSb2O9.3Ma J. Spins don’t align here.Nat. Phys. 2023; 19: 922-923Crossref Scopus (1) Google Scholar Meanwhile, the large-size single crystals of YbMgGaO4 synthesized by the image furnace meet the requirements of various experimental technologies. Strictly, to identify a QSL, a magnetically disordered state without spin freezing should be observed at 0 K, which is unpractical. Actually, the zero-temperature physical approximation could be expected at any finite temperature less than the spin interaction scale, when there is a magnetically disordered state down to the lowest temperature. The macroscopic measurements of magnetic susceptibility, thermal conductivity, and specific heat are traditional techniques for distinguishing whether a QSL phase exists. Furthermore, the microscopic probes that are sensitive to the local magnetism, for example, muon spin relaxation (μSR) and nuclear magnetic resonance, are also often helped to exclude the spin ordering or freezing. These experiments provide quite reliable proof but are usually not satisfactory. Although the long-range magnetic order may not exist, such a ground state with a magnetically disordered state may originate from site disorder, which prohibits a long-range order. Therefore, the spin-liquid-like state can be considered as a classical spin liquid and fundamentally different from a QSL. This phenomenon has been hinted in the promising gapless QSL candidate material YbMgGaO4 by different experimental techniques, and a different explanation for the observed continuum spin excitations was demonstrated as the spin glass state rather than the spinons of a QSL in YbMgGaO4, which may originate from the nonmagnetic Mg/Ga site disorder of intrinsic issues. Recently, the effective S = 1/2 rare-earth-based 2D triangular lattice materials with magnetically geometrical frustration have received great attention. Compared with YbMgGaO4, the family of ytterbium dichalcogenide delafossites NaYbCh2 (Ch = O, S, Se) with effective spin-1/2 local moments have a simpler structure and avoid the issue of Mg/Ga site disorders. As a representative member of the ABC-stacking family with the possibility of chirality as shown in Figure 1B, NaYbSe2 has received increasing interest of both experimentalists and theorists. The crystalline electric field has confirmed the environment of the Yb3+ ions.4Zhang Z. Ma X. Li J. et al.Crystalline Electric-Field Excitations in Quantum Spin Liquids Candidate NaYbSe2.Phys. Rev. B. 2021; 103035144Google Scholar NaYbSe2 single crystals are absent of long-range magnetic order and spin freezing down to 50 mK by magnetic susceptibility, zero-field specific heat, thermal conductivity, neutron scattering, and μSR measurements. The spin-excitations spectra measured with inelastic neutron scattering and the theoretical expectation from the spinon continuum suggest that the ground state of NaYbSe2 is a QSL with a spinon Fermi surface as a ground state. Frustratingly, such a perfect QSL candidate material still inevitably introduces disorder of Na ions, which makes the system more complex. In recent report, Zhu et al. proposed that the fluctuating droplet-like ferrimagnetic clusters could exist in a sea of QSL, as shown in Figure 1C, which might be applied in searching for an ideal QSL and may serve as a reference to extract the intrinsic attributes of QSL.5Zhu Z.H. Pan B.L. Nie L.P. et al.Fluctuating magnetic droplets immersed in a sea of quantum spin liquid.The Innovation. 2023; 4: 100459Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF Scopus (1) Google Scholar It is worth mentioning that such a proposal in Figure 1C may be also attributed to the intrinsic ABC stacking with the possibility of chirality that results in the stacking-induced magnetic frustration.3Ma J. Spins don’t align here.Nat. Phys. 2023; 19: 922-923Crossref Scopus (1) Google Scholar Although it is difficult to confirm such a proposal through the current experimental technologies, this novel pattern will well arouse theorists to introduce uncontrollable factors into theoretical simulation. Indeed, the structural disorder is inevitable for a real QSL material, and the uncertainties due to the lattice defect make the extraction of the intrinsic ground state complicated and unpredictable. At present, although our vision of finding an ideal QSL candidate through such intensive and unremitting theoretical and experimental efforts has not yet been realized, this field has been substantially advanced. In material searching, the small spins, little structure disorder and defect, strong geometrical frustration, and so on are still necessary reference criteria for finding promising QSL candidate materials. Experimentally, the realization of QSLs still faces enormous challenges. If a real QSL compound is identified, it will greatly promote the development of quantum computer and high-temperature superconductors. G.T.L and J.M. thank the financial support from the National Key Research and Development Program of China (No. 2022YFA1402702), the National Science Foundation of China (Nos. U2032213, 12004243). J.M. thanks the interdisciplinary program Wuhan National High Magnetic Field Center (No. WHMFC 202122), Huazhong University of Science and Technology. G.T.L thanks the project funded by China Postdoctoral Science Foundation (No. 2022T150414). The authors declare no competing interests.