Comparison on the Difference of Growth and Nutritional Quality for Lettuce (lactuca Sativa L.) Between Aeroponic and Hydroponic Cultivation Systems under Different Nitrogen Levels
DING Wenya,LIN Ruoyun,ZHOU Weiwei,ZHOU Kai,LIN Xianyong
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3785/j.issn.1008-9209.2016.01.251
2016-01-01
Abstract:Summary Soilless culture is considered to be an alternative to soil-based cultivation.It has been developed quickly because of rapid growth on biomass and high quality of crops.Hydroponics and aeroponics are both soilless culture,but with different techniques.Aeroponics is a newly soilless culture technique,in which the roots are suspended mid-air inside a chamber and are intermittently sprayed with a nutrient solution to supply the plants with mineral and water.Unlike hydroponics using water as a growing medium and relying on essential mineral to sustain plant growth,aeroponics is conducted without a growing medium.Thus,there are significant differences of root zone between aeroponic and hydroponic cultivation systems.However,little effort has been found in the literature evaluating the effect of the two soilless techniques on yield and quality of growing vegetable. In this study,experiments were carried out to compare the biomass production and nutritional quality of lettuce between hydroponic and aeroponic cultivation systems under different nitrogen levels(2,8 and 20 mmol/L NO3 --N). Results showed that under the same nitrogen level,higher biomass,root growth,relative growth rate and photosynthetic rate were observed for lettuces grown in aeroponics than in hydroponics.Nitrate and glutathione contents were lower in aeroponics,while the ferric reducing/antioxidant power(FRAP)value and 1,1-diphenyl-2-picrydrazyl(DPPH)radical scavenging rate were comparable to those in hydroponics.There were no differences in contents of soluble protein,soluble sugar and ascorbic acid,but the accumulations of soluble protein,soluble sugar,ascorbic acid and glutathione in aeroponics were markedly higher than those in hydroponics.Furthermore, the contents of nitrate and soluble protein of lettuces increased both in hydroponics and aeroponics,while the concentrations of soluble sugar,ascorbic acid and glutathione,FRAP value and DPPH radical scavenging rate decreased with increasing nitrogen level.Highest biomass,root morphological index,photosynthetic index, accumulations of soluble protein,soluble sugar,ascorbic acid and glutathione were observed under the nitrogen level of 8 mmol/L. In sum,aeroponics is beneficial for higher biomass,antioxidant accumulation and antioxidative activity, especially under the nitrogen level of 8 mmol/L.