Abstract:Abstract The human visual ability to recognize objects and scenes is widely thought to rely on representations in category-selective regions of visual cortex. These representations could support object vision by specifically representing objects, or, more simply, by representing complex visual features regardless of the particular spatial arrangement needed to constitute real world objects. That is, by representing visual textures. To discriminate between these hypotheses, we leveraged an image synthesis approach that, unlike previous methods, provides independent control over the complexity and spatial arrangement of visual features. We found that human observers could easily detect a natural object among synthetic images with similar complex features that were spatially scrambled. However, observer models built from BOLD responses from category-selective regions, as well as a model of macaque inferotemporal cortex and Imagenet-trained deep convolutional neural networks, were all unable to identify the real object. This inability was not due to a lack of signal-to-noise, as all of these observer models could predict human performance in image categorization tasks. How then might these texture-like representations in category-selective regions support object perception? An image-specific readout from category-selective cortex yielded a representation that was more selective for natural feature arrangement, showing that the information necessary for object discrimination is available. Thus, our results suggest that the role of human category-selective visual cortex is not to explicitly encode objects but rather to provide a basis set of texture-like features that can be infinitely reconfigured to flexibly learn and identify new object categories. Significance Statement Virtually indistinguishable metamers of visual textures, such as wood grain, can be synthesized by matching complex features regardless of their spatial arrangement (1–3). However, humans are not fooled by such synthetic images of scrambled objects. Thus, category-selective regions of human visual cortex might be expected to exhibit representational geometry preferentially sensitive to natural objects. Contrarily, we demonstrate that observer models based on category-selective regions, models of macaque inferotemporal cortex and Imagenet-trained deep convolutional neural networks do not preferentially represent natural images, even while they are able to discriminate image categories. This suggests the need to reconceptualize the role of category-selective cortex as representing a basis set of complex texture-like features, useful for a myriad of visual behaviors.

Representation of Multiple Objects in Macaque Category-Selective Areas

An object-topic map in primate inferotemporal cortex

A Map of Object Space in Primate Inferotemporal Cortex

The Responses of Single Neurons in the Temporal Visual Cortical Areas of the Macaque when More Than One Stimulus is Present in the Receptive Field.

Tracing the representation of colored objects in the primate brain

The Representation of Colored Objects in Macaque Color Patches

Multiple objects evoke fluctuating responses in several regions of the visual pathway

Neural mechanisms for stimulus selection in cortical areas of the macaque subserving object vision

Color statistics of objects, and color tuning of object cortex in macaque monkey

Building of Object View Invariance in a Newly-Discovered Network in Inferior Temporal Cortex

Unitized Representation of Paired Objects in Area 35 of the Macaque Perirhinal Cortex

The functional organization of high-level visual cortex determines the representation of complex visual stimuli

Complex Pattern Selectivity in Macaque Primary Visual Cortex Revealed by Large-Scale Two-Photon Imaging.

Local organization of spatial and shape information in the primate prefrontal cortex

An inferotemporal coding strategy robust to partial object occlusion

Object-centered Encoding by Face-Selective Neurons in the Cortex in the Superior Temporal Sulcus of the Monkey.

Texture-like representation of objects in human visual cortex

Representation of Contextually Related Multiple Objects in the Human Ventral Visual Pathway.

Category-Selective Representation of Relationships in the Visual Cortex

The role of binocular disparity and attention in the neural representation of multiple moving stimuli in the visual cortex