Abstract:A stimulus that predicts the delivery of a specific food outcome can bias performance towards instrumental actions that earn that same outcome in a phenomenon known as specific Pavlovian-instrumental transfer (PIT). The precise mechanism by which the specific instrumental action is selected under these circumstances has remained elusive. The present set of experiments explored whether treatments that undermine the response-outcome (R-O) association also affect the expression of specific PIT. Consistent with previous work, in Experiment 1 we showed that specific PIT remains intact after an instrumental degradation treatment that attempted to undermine R-O associations. However, we additionally demonstrated that outcome-devaluation sensitivity also persisted after degradation, suggesting that R-O associations were impervious to the degradation treatment, and precluding any conclusions about the necessity of R-O associations for specific PIT expression. Nevertheless, given the two-lever two-outcome design of this experiment it is possible that R-O associations were indeed undermined by degradation and that the devaluation effect was driven by distinct, incidental Pavlovian lever-outcome associations. To nullify the obscuring effects of these incidental Pavlovian associations, we used a bidirectional lever for instrumental conditioning that could be pushed to the left or the right for distinct outcomes. In Experiment 2 we demonstrated that specific PIT could be observed on this bidirectional manipulandum whether the subjects were hungry or sated, consistent with the literature. The critical third Experiment used an identical design to Experiment 1 except that the two instrumental responses were made on the single bidirectional manipulanda. Here, specific PIT was intact after instrumental degradation and, crucially, we saw no evidence of outcome devaluation sensitivity in these same subjects, suggesting that the R-O associations were weakened or undermined by this treatment. We conclude that the expression of specific PIT is resistant to treatments that undermine R-O associations and disrupt value based choice, and discuss how these findings contribute to our understanding of the associative framework supporting behavioral control.

Triggering Avoidance: Dissociable Influences of Aversive Pavlovian Conditioned Stimuli on Human Instrumental Behavior.

Pavlovian-to-instrumental transfer in intertemporal choice

Response-independent outcome presentations dissociate stimulus and value based choice

Stimulus–outcome associations are required for the expression of specific Pavlovian-instrumental transfer.

Effects of Lesions of the Nucleus Accumbens Core and Shell on Response-Specific Pavlovian- Instrumental Transfer

Compulsive avoidance in youths and adults with OCD: an aversive pavlovian-to-instrumental transfer study

Obsessive-compulsive disorder is characterized by decreased Pavlovian influence on instrumental behavior

Pavlovian-to-instrumental transfer and outcome-devaluation effects in individuals with gaming experience

Pavlovian-to-instrumental transfer in individuals with chronic pain

Devaluation of response-produced safety signals reveals circuits for goal-directed versus habitual avoidance in dorsal striatum

Manipulations of the context-response relationship reduce the expression of response habits

Transfer from goal-directed behavior to stimulus-response habits and its modulation by acute stress in individuals with risky gaming behavior

The effects of acute stress exposure on striatal activity during Pavlovian conditioning with monetary gains and losses

Effect of context on the instrumental reinforcer devaluation effect produced by taste-aversion learning.

Instrumental behavior in humans is sensitive to the correlation between response rate and reward rate

High stakes slow responding, but do not help overcome Pavlovian biases in humans

Adolescents exhibit reduced Pavlovian biases on instrumental learning

Affective learning: Awareness and aversion

Noradrenergic Regulation of Central Amygdala in Aversive Pavlovian-to-Instrumental Transfer

Acute stress facilitates habitual behavior in female rats

The ventral striato-pallidal pathway mediates the effect of predictive learning on choice between goal-directed actions