Abstract:AbstractJudicial ideology is a latent trait that cannot be directly observed; its measurement must rely upon inferences drawn from observable traits or properties. In this paper, we assume that judicial ideologies of Supreme Court Justices may be inferred from the contents or themes of their authorial opinion texts, which embody their jurisprudential interpretation and reasoning on particular disputes of hard cases. The contents or themes of six opinion texts of “Bush v. Gore 2000” are analyzed both qualitatively and quantitatively, with the latter as the focus. An indicator is borrowed from quantitative linguistics (QL) to quantify individual thematic words which contribute to the contents or themes of the text, that is, “thematic concentration” (TC). Our research yields the following results: First, both the highest and lowest TC value are found in the dissenting opinions, which may indicate the dynamism of thematic concentration of this type of opinion; Second, the common “thematic words” distilled from six opinions help to lexically profile the key “content domain” of this case; Third, the only thematic word “state” which appears in almost all opinion texts can be regarded as representing the most fundamental characteristic of the genre of appellate court opinions; Fourth, there exists a significant difference of TC in texts between the majority opinion and the dissenting opinion but not within the majority opinion, indicating that TC can reflect in a correct direction of the ideological stances of Supreme Court Justices; Fifth, TC in texts of three opinions get together, and qualitative analysis of these three opinions also shows that they concentrate on similar themes. The application of TC still have some challenges, but at least it offers an alternative path to measure ideologies of Supreme Court Justices, which contributes to the progress and development of forensic linguistics.

Thematic Concentration As a Discriminating Feature of Text Types

Contrastive Study of the Syntactic-Semantic Structures Between English-Chinese Middles

Comparison study of using semantic and syntactic network characteristics to do text clustering

Entropy in Different Text Types.

Application of Quantitative Characteristics of Chinese Genres in Text Clustering

Ideologies of Supreme Court Justices: Quantitative Thematic Analysis of Multiple Opinions of “bush V. Gore 2000”

Marked Themes in Spoken Chinese: a Discourse Semantics Perspective

A Comprehensive Analysis of Text Value and Linguistic Characteristics of Chinese Language Literature Based on Text Mining Technology

Comparing the Performance Characteristics and Commonalities of Chinese Modern and Contemporary Literature in Different Cultural Contexts by Combining Text Mining Techniques

A Thematic Analysis of English and American Literature Works Based on Text Mining and Sentiment Analysis

A Paper-Text Perspective

An Investigation of Salient Information in Textual Summarization

Similarities and differences between Chinese two-character words and their constituent characters in norm-feature correlations

Comparative Computational Analysis of Global Structure in Canonical, Non-Canonical and Non-Literary Texts

High-level construal mindset promotes categorizing information based on thematic associate relations

Text tendency analysis based on multi-granularity emotional chunks and integrated learning

Study on influences of different Chinese word segmentation methods to text automatic classification based on LDA model

Understanding Reader Takeaways in Thematic Maps Under Varying Text, Detail, and Spatial Autocorrelation

Analyses of Multi-collection Corpora via Compound Topic Modeling

Topic Prominence in Typological Interlanguage Development of Chinese Students' English

An Evaluation on Feature Selection for Text Clustering