Abstract:Extensive literature probes labor market discrimination through correspondence studies in which researchers send pairs of resumes to employers, which are closely matched except for social signals such as gender or ethnicity. Upon perceiving these signals, individuals quickly activate associated stereotypes. The Stereotype Content Model (SCM; Fiske 2002) categorizes these stereotypes into two dimensions: warmth and competence. Our research integrates findings from correspondence studies with theories of social psychology, asking: Can discrimination between social groups, measured through employer callback disparities, be predicted by warmth and competence perceptions of social signals? We collect callback rates from 21 published correspondence studies, varying for 592 social signals. On those social signals, we collected warmth and competence perceptions from an independent group of online raters. We found that social perception predicts callback disparities for studies varying race and gender, which are indirectly signaled by names on these resumes. Yet, for studies adjusting other categories like sexuality and disability, the influence of social perception on callbacks is inconsistent. For instance, a more favorable perception of signals like parenthood does not consistently lead to increased callbacks, underscoring the necessity for further research. Our research offers pivotal strategies to address labor market discrimination in practice. Leveraging the warmth and competence framework allows for the predictive identification of bias against specific groups without extensive correspondence studies. By distilling hiring discrimination into these two dimensions, we not only facilitate the development of decision support systems for hiring managers but also equip computer scientists with a foundational framework for debiasing Large Language Models and other methods that are increasingly employed in hiring processes.

Social Capital and Homophily Both Matter for Labor Market Outcomes - Evidence from Replication and Extension

Social Capital and Job Search in Urban China: The Strength-of-Strong-Ties Hypothesis Revisited

Does local social capital deter labour migration? Evidence from rural China

Diversity of Social Network and Labor Market Outcome:A study on how social contacts affect the wage of migrant workers

The Causal Effect of Social Capital in the Labor Market Identification Challenges and Strategies

Using Contacts is Hardly Beneficial: the Treatment Effects of Using Social Capital

The Causal Effect of Social Capital in the Labor Market

Occupational Interactions and Income Level: a Social Capital Study Using the First-Order Difference Method

What does homophily do? a review of the consequences of homophily

Measuring the Labor Market Effects of Social Capital:A literature review and research strategy of dealing with the endogeneity problem

Social Capital and Internal Migrant Entrepreneurship: Evidence from Urban China

Heterogeneous Social Network and Rural Migrant Worker’s Wage: Evidence from China

Homophily and Individual Performance

Like Attract Like? A Structural Comparison of Homogamy across Same-Sex and Different-Sex Households

Workers’ Mobility Across Occupations: Complementary Insights from the Human Capital, Migration, and Social Stratification Literature

Homophily Within and Across Groups

Market Transition and Network-Based Job Matching in China: The Referrer Perspective

Perceived warmth and competence predict callback rates in meta-analyzed North American labor market experiments

Birds of a Feather: Homophily in Social Networks

Embedding social networks: How guanxi ties reinforce Chinese employees’ retention

Opportunity and choice in social networks