Abstract:As water scarcity becomes more acute in many parts of the world, crop modeling tools that effectively simulating crop response to deficit irrigation strategies to help investigate management improvement are needed. Identifying the strengths and weaknesses of the crop models with different growth-engines are therefore of great importance. The objective of this study was to investigate the capability and improvements of the new version of a solar energy-driven crop model (DSSAT-CERES-Maize, v4.7.5.0) in simulating water consumption and yield of hybrid seed maize under different soil water conditions, and its comparison with a water-driven crop model (AquaCrop, v4.0). Data obtained from a 4-year (2012–2015) field trial on maize grown under different irrigation treatments at Wuwei, Northwest China, was used for this assessment. These models were calibrated and validated using measured daily evapotranspiration (ET), leaf area index (LAI), aboveground biomass, yield (Y), harvest index (HI) and soil water content (SWC). Daily ET was measured using a combination of an eddy covariance (EC) system, sap flow sensors, and micro-lysimeter cylinders. The ability of DSSAT-CERES-Maize using the two different ET options, i.e., Priestley-Taylor/Ritchie (PT) and FAO-56 Penman-Monteith (PM) was analyzed. The results showed that DSSAT-CERES-Maize with the PT approach had fair agreement with measured daily ET of maize under non-water stress condition (R2=0.85; NRMSE=26.7%), but poor agreement with ET under water stress conditions (R2=0.51; NRMSE=43.8%). DSSAT-CERES-Maize with the PM approach systematically underestimated ET by up to 13% under non-water stress condition, which was mainly attributed to that the maximum static CERES-Maize crop coefficient (EORATIO) was currently hard coded to 1.0. Using the PT or FAO-56 PM approach as ET input in DSSAT-CERES-Maize showed no different effect on final biomass (B) and Y simulation for full irrigation. But for water stress conditions, DSSAT-CERES-Maize with the FAO-56 PM approach simulated B and Y with higher overestimation to the measured data than those simulated using the PT approach. The simulated LAI, biomass and SWC by DSSAT-CERES-Maize using the PT approach generally well followed the trend of the measured values for most irrigation treatments. The model with the PT approach showed acceptable prediction for B and Y of different irrigation treatments across years, with NRMSE of 15.5% and 26.2%, respectively, but the accuracy decreased with an aggravation of water stress. Furthermore, the strengths and weaknesses of DSSAT-CERES-Maize and AquaCrop, and their different cores of growth-engines, i.e. RUE and normalized water productivity (WP*) were carefully discussed. It was concluded that DSSAT-CERES-Maize was a superior estimate of maize yield than was AquaCrop, especially when the climate varied dramatically between years. But DSSAT-CERES-Maize, for the simulation of maize water consumption in an arid region where drought often occurs, was inferior to AquaCrop. These results contribute to recommend the appropriate crop model for specific modeling goals.

Modeling and assessing field irrigation water use in a canal system of Hetao, upper Yellow River basin: Application to maize, sunflower and watermelon

An Easily Implemented Agro-Hydrological Procedure with Dynamic Root Simulation for Water Transfer in the Crop–soil System: Validation and Application

Simulation of Water Balance in a Maize Field under Film-Mulching Drip Irrigation

Study on water and salt transportation of different irrigation modes by the simulation of HYDRUS model

Modeling agro-hydrological processes and analyzing water use in a super-large irrigation district (Hetao) of arid upper Yellow River basin

Assessment of irrigation and groundwater management strategies in cold arid areas with shallow groundwater tables using a coupled year-round agro-hydrological model

Evaluating the Effects of Irrigation Water Salinity on Water Movement, Crop Yield and Water Use Efficiency by Means of a Coupled Hydrologic/crop Growth Model

Simulation Model of Corn Restricted by Waterlogging and Its Verification

Simulation of Water Cycling in Wheat-maize Field in North China

Integrated Assessment of Crop Planting Suitability: A Case Study in the Hetao Irrigation District of China Using HJ-1A/1B Satellite Data

Assessing water productivity in the Hetao Irrigation District in Inner Mongolia by an agro-hydrological model

Modeling Regional Soil Water Balance in Farmland of the Middle Reaches of Heihe River Basin

Capability of a solar energy-driven crop model for simulating water consumption and yield of maize and its comparison with a water-driven crop model

Evaluating the impacts of saline water irrigation on soil water-salt and summer maize yield in subsurface drainage condition using coupled HYDRUS and EPIC model

A Clinicopathological Study of the Vogt-Koyanagi-Harada Syndrome

Field Assessment of Basin Irrigation Performance in Hetao, Inner Mongolia

Irrigation Schedule Optimization for Wheat and Sunflower Intercropping under Water Supply Restrictions in Inner Mongolia, China

HYDRUS-1D Simulation of Soil Water Dynamics for Sweet Corn under Tropical Rainfed Condition

Assessing crop yield and crop water productivity and optimizing irrigation scheduling of winter wheat in the Haihe plain using hydrological model

Evaluating the Sustainable Use of Saline Water Irrigation on Soil Water-Salt Content and Grain Yield under Subsurface Drainage Condition

Optimizing irrigation and drainage by considering agricultural hydrological process in arid farmland with shallow groundwater