Abstract:In dynamical systems, the full stability of fixed point solutions is determined by their basin of attraction. Characterizing the structure of these basins is, in general, a complicated task, especially in high dimensionality. Recent works have advocated to quantify the non-linear stability of fixed points of dynamical systems through the relative volumes of the associated basins of attraction [D. A. Wiley {\it et al.} Chaos {\bf 16}, 015103 (2006), P. J. Menck {\it et al.} Nat. Phys. {\bf 9}, 89 (2013)]. Here we revisit this issue and propose an efficient numerical method to estimate these volumes. The algorithm first identifies stable fixed points. Second, a set of initial conditions is considered that are randomly distributed at the surface of hypercubes centered on each fixed point. These initial conditions are dynamically evolved. The linear size of each basin of attraction is finally determined by the proportion of initial conditions which converge back to the fixed point. Armed with this algorithm, we revisit the problem considered by Wiley et al. in a seminal paper [D. A. Wiley {\it et al.} Chaos {\bf 16}, 015103 (2006)] that inspired the title of the present manuscript, and consider the equal-frequency Kuramoto model on a cycle. Fixed points of this model are characterized by an integer winding number $q$ and the number $n$ of oscillators. We find that the basin volumes scale as $(1-4q/n)^n$, contrasting with the Gaussian behavior postulated in Wiley et al.'s paper. Finally, we show the applicability of our method to complex models of coupled oscillators with different natural frequencies and on meshed networks.

Basin Stability of the Kuramoto-like Model in Small Networks

Basin Stability in Complex Oscillator Networks

Stochastic Basin Stability in Complex Networks

Critical Points, Stability, and Basins of Attraction of Three Kuramoto Oscillators with Isosceles Triangle Network

Optimizing synchronization stability of the Kuramoto model in complex networks and power grids

Basin sizes depend on stable eigenvalues in the Kuramoto model

Stability and Synchronization of Kuramoto Oscillators

The Size of the Sync Basin Revisited

Harmonic Solution of Higher-Dimensional Second Order Kuramoto Oscillator Network

Onset and suffusing transitions towards synchronization in complex networks

Stability and bifurcation of mixing in the Kuramoto model with inertia

Stability of anti-bunched buses and local unidirectional Kuramoto oscillators

Bifurcation and stability of complicated model of power system

The stability of fixed points for a Kuramoto model with Hebbian interactions

Deeper but smaller: Higher-order interactions increase linear stability but shrink basins

Low-dimensional Behavior of Kuramoto Model with Inertia in Complex Networks.

Building blocks of the basin stability of power grids

On the synchronization of the Kuramoto-type model of oscillators with lossy couplings

Qualitative Stability and Synchronicity Analysis of Power Network Models in Port-Hamiltonian Form

Dynamical Behavior and Singularities of a Single-machine Infinite-bus Power System