1941 RANDOMIZED STUDY TO COMPARE THE OUTCOME IN TREATING UPPER URETERAL IMPACTED STONES USING MPCNL WITH THE AID OF A PATENTED STONE-BREAKING AND CLEARANCE SYSTEM OR TRANSURETHRAL URETEROSCOPIC LITHOTRIPSY
Leming Song,Donghua Xie,Zhongsheng Yang,Min Hu,Tairong Liu,Chuance Du,Zuofeng Peng,Jiuqing Zhong,Wen Qin,Shulin Guo,Lunfeng Zhu,Lei Yao,Jianrong Huang,Difu Fan,Zhangqun Ye
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.juro.2012.02.2099
2012-01-01
Abstract:You have accessJournal of UrologyStone Disease: New Technology/SWL, Ureteroscopic or Percutaneous Stone Removal IV1 Apr 20121941 RANDOMIZED STUDY TO COMPARE THE OUTCOME IN TREATING UPPER URETERAL IMPACTED STONES USING MPCNL WITH THE AID OF A PATENTED STONE-BREAKING AND CLEARANCE SYSTEM OR TRANSURETHRAL URETEROSCOPIC LITHOTRIPSY Leming Song, Donghua Xie, Zhongsheng Yang, Min Hu, Tairong Liu, Chuance Du, Zuofeng Peng, Jiuqing Zhong, Wen Qin, Shulin Guo, Lunfeng Zhu, Lei Yao, Jianrong Huang, Difu Fan, and Zhangqun Ye Leming SongLeming Song Ganzhou, China, People's Republic of More articles by this author , Donghua XieDonghua Xie Chicago, IL More articles by this author , Zhongsheng YangZhongsheng Yang Ganzhou, China, People's Republic of More articles by this author , Min HuMin Hu Ganzhou, China, People's Republic of More articles by this author , Tairong LiuTairong Liu Ganzhou, China, People's Republic of More articles by this author , Chuance DuChuance Du Ganzhou, China, People's Republic of More articles by this author , Zuofeng PengZuofeng Peng Ganzhou, China, People's Republic of More articles by this author , Jiuqing ZhongJiuqing Zhong Ganzhou, China, People's Republic of More articles by this author , Wen QinWen Qin Ganzhou, China, People's Republic of More articles by this author , Shulin GuoShulin Guo Ganzhou, China, People's Republic of More articles by this author , Lunfeng ZhuLunfeng Zhu Ganzhou, China, People's Republic of More articles by this author , Lei YaoLei Yao Ganzhou, China, People's Republic of More articles by this author , Jianrong HuangJianrong Huang Ganzhou, China, People's Republic of More articles by this author , Difu FanDifu Fan Ganzhou, China, People's Republic of More articles by this author , and Zhangqun YeZhangqun Ye Wuhan, China, People's Republic of More articles by this author View All Author Informationhttps://doi.org/10.1016/j.juro.2012.02.2099AboutPDF ToolsAdd to favoritesDownload CitationsTrack CitationsPermissionsReprints ShareFacebookTwitterLinked InEmail INTRODUCTION AND OBJECTIVES The aim of this study is to find the efficient method in treating upper ureteral impacted stone by comparing the outcome of minimally invasive percutaneous nephrolithotomy (MPCNL) with the aid of a self-innovated patented stone-breaking and clearance system and transurethral uretersocopic lithotripsy. METHODS One hundred eighty two patients with complicated impacted upper ureteral stones above the level of L4 were randomly divided into 2 groups. Group 1 comprised 91 cases that were treated with transurethral ureteroscopic lithotripsy (URL). Group 2 comprised 91 cases that were treated with MPCNL with the aid of a patented stone-breaking and clearance system (PMPCNL). The patients received postsurgical shock wave lithotripsy (SWL) when necessary. The operative time, rate of stone clearance, operative complication markers, including amount of intraoperative bleeding, rate of postoperative fever, and cost of treatment, were compared. RESULTS There was a significantly shorter operative time, a higher rate of stone clearance, less need of postoperative SWL therapy, and a lower rate of postoperative fever in Group 2 compared to Group 1. However, there was a significantly higher cost of treatment and a higher amount of intraoperative bleeding in Group 2. CONCLUSIONS We think MPCNL with the aid of the patented stone-breaking and clearance system could be the first choice in treating complicated impacted upper ureteral stones above the level of L4. Group Average operative time (min) Average amount of operative bleeding (ml) Rate of postoperative fever (%) Number of cases needing secondary SWL therapy Cost of treatment (RMB) Stone clearance rate (3 days postoperatively) Stone clearance rate (1 month postoperatively) URL 45.2±3.1 15.6±1.8 15.4(14/91) 23 7037.2±514.3 71.4(65/91) 89.0(81/91) PMPCNL 27.4±2.3 40.2±5.3 5.5(5/91) 0 10115.1±1057.3 97.8(89/91) 100(91/91) p <0.001 <0.001 0.029 <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 0.001 © 2012 by American Urological Association Education and Research, Inc.FiguresReferencesRelatedDetails Volume 187Issue 4SApril 2012Page: e783 Peer Review Report Advertisement Copyright & Permissions© 2012 by American Urological Association Education and Research, Inc.MetricsAuthor Information Leming Song Ganzhou, China, People's Republic of More articles by this author Donghua Xie Chicago, IL More articles by this author Zhongsheng Yang Ganzhou, China, People's Republic of More articles by this author Min Hu Ganzhou, China, People's Republic of More articles by this author Tairong Liu Ganzhou, China, People's Republic of More articles by this author Chuance Du Ganzhou, China, People's Republic of More articles by this author Zuofeng Peng Ganzhou, China, People's Republic of More articles by this author Jiuqing Zhong Ganzhou, China, People's Republic of More articles by this author Wen Qin Ganzhou, China, People's Republic of More articles by this author Shulin Guo Ganzhou, China, People's Republic of More articles by this author Lunfeng Zhu Ganzhou, China, People's Republic of More articles by this author Lei Yao Ganzhou, China, People's Republic of More articles by this author Jianrong Huang Ganzhou, China, People's Republic of More articles by this author Difu Fan Ganzhou, China, People's Republic of More articles by this author Zhangqun Ye Wuhan, China, People's Republic of More articles by this author Expand All Advertisement Advertisement PDF downloadLoading ...