Abstract:Detecting and mapping individual trees accurately and automatically from remote sensing images is of great significance for precision forest management. Many algorithms, including classical methods and deep learning techniques, have been developed and applied for tree crown detection from remote sensing images. However, few studies have evaluated the accuracy of different individual tree detection (ITD) algorithms and their data and processing requirements. This study explored the accuracy of ITD using local maxima (LM) algorithm, marker-controlled watershed segmentation (MCWS), and Mask Region-based Convolutional Neural Networks (Mask R-CNN) in a young plantation forest with different test images. Manually delineated tree crowns from UAV imagery were used for accuracy assessment of the three methods, followed by an evaluation of the data processing and application requirements for three methods to detect individual trees. Overall, Mask R-CNN can best use the information in multi-band input images for detecting individual trees. The results showed that the Mask R-CNN model with the multi-band combination produced higher accuracy than the model with a single-band image, and the RGB band combination achieved the highest accuracy for ITD (F1 score = 94.68%). Moreover, the Mask R-CNN models with multi-band images are capable of providing higher accuracies for ITD than the LM and MCWS algorithms. The LM algorithm and MCWS algorithm also achieved promising accuracies for ITD when the canopy height model (CHM) was used as the test image (F1 score = 87.86% for LM algorithm, F1 score = 85.92% for MCWS algorithm). The LM and MCWS algorithms are easy to use and lower computer computational requirements, but they are unable to identify tree species and are limited by algorithm parameters, which need to be adjusted for each classification. It is highlighted that the application of deep learning with its end-to-end-learning approach is very efficient and capable of deriving the information from multi-layer images, but an additional training set is needed for model training, robust computer resources are required, and a large number of accurate training samples are necessary. This study provides valuable information for forestry practitioners to select an optimal approach for detecting individual trees.

Use of UAV oblique imaging for the detection of individual trees in residential environments

Fast Detection and Recognition Method of UAV in Sky Background

Urban forest monitoring based on multiple features at the single tree scale by UAV

Identifying Tree Species in a Warm-Temperate Deciduous Forest by Combining Multi-Rotor and Fixed-Wing Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Tree Recognition on the Plantation Using UAV Images with Ultrahigh Spatial Resolution in a Complex Environment

Hierarchical Instance Recognition of Individual Roadside Trees in Environmentally Complex Urban Areas from UAV Laser Scanning Point Clouds

Research on a Single-Tree Point Cloud Segmentation Method Based on UAV Tilt Photography and Deep Learning Algorithm

Papaya Tree Detection with UAV Images Using a GPU-Accelerated Scale-Space Filtering Method

Urban Treetop Detection and Tree-Height Estimation from Unmanned-Aerial-Vehicle Images.

Urban Tree Classification Based on Object-Oriented Approach and Random Forest Algorithm Using Unmanned Aerial Vehicle (UAV) Multispectral Imagery

Comparison of ALS- and UAV(SfM)-derived high-density point clouds for individual tree detection in Eucalyptus plantations

Individual Deciduous Tree Recognition in Leaf-Off Aerial Ultrahigh Spatial Resolution Remotely Sensed Imagery

Classification of Street Tree Species Using UAV Tilt Photogrammetry

Comparison of Classical Methods and Mask R-CNN for Automatic Tree Detection and Mapping Using UAV Imagery

Extraction of Information about Individual Trees from High-Spatial-Resolution UAV-Acquired Images of an Orchard

Individual Tree Species Identification and Crown Parameters Extraction Based on Mask R-CNN: Assessing the Applicability of Unmanned Aerial Vehicle Optical Images

A Tree Species Mapping Method from UAV Images over Urban Area Using Similarity in Tree-Crown Object Histograms

Individual-Tree Segmentation from UAV–LiDAR Data Using a Region-Growing Segmentation and Supervoxel-Weighted Fuzzy Clustering Approach

A Hierarchic Method of Individual Tree Canopy Segmentation Combing UAV Image and LiDAR

An All-Time Detection Algorithm for UAV Images in Urban Low Altitude

Individual Tree Parameters Estimation for Plantation Forests Based on UAV Oblique Photography