The Conceptual Origins of Maxwell’s Equations and Gauge Theory

Chen Ning Yang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1063/pt.3.2585

IF: 3.5

2014-01-01

Physics Today

Abstract:Already in Faraday’s electrotonic state and Maxwell’s vector potential, gauge freedom was an unavoidable presence. Converting that presence to the symmetry principle that underpins our successful standard model is a story worth telling.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Unification of Force and Substance

Frank Wilczek

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1098/rsta.2015.0257

2016-01-01

Abstract:Maxwell’s mature presentation of his equations emphasized the unity of electromagnetism and mechanics, subsuming both as ‘dynamical systems’. That intuition of unity has proved both fruitful, as a source of pregnant concepts, and broadly inspiring. A deep aspect of Maxwell’s work is its use of redundant potentials, and the associated requirement of gauge symmetry. Those concepts have become central to our present understanding of fundamental physics, but they can appear to be rather formal and esoteric. Here I discuss two things: the physical significance of gauge invariance, in broad terms; and some tantalizing prospects for further unification, building on that concept, that are visible on the horizon today. If those prospects are realized, Maxwell’s vision of the unity of field and substance will be brought to a new level. This article is part of the themed issue ‘Unifying physics and technology in light of Maxwell's equations’.
The Noether Current in Maxwell's Equations and Radiation under Symmetry Breaking.

Dhiraj Sinha,Gehan Amaratunga

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1098/rsta.2017.0452

2018-01-01

Abstract:Symmetries in physical systems are defined in terms of conserved Noether Currents of the associated Lagrangian. In electrodynamic systems, global symmetry is defined through conservation of charges, which is reflected in gauge symmetry; however, loss of charges from a radiating system can be interpreted as localized loss of the Noether current which implies that electrodynamic symmetry has been locally broken. Thus, we propose that global symmetries and localized symmetry breaking are interwoven into the framework of Maxwell's equations which appear as globally conserved and locally non-conserved charges in an electrodynamic system and define the geometric topology of the electromagnetic field. We apply the ideas in the context of explaining radiation from dielectric materials with low physical dimensions. We also briefly look at the nature of reversibility in electromagnetic wave generation which was initially proposed by Planck, but opposed by Einstein and in recent years by Zoh.This article is part of the theme issue 'Celebrating 125 years of Oliver Heaviside's 'Electromagnetic Theory''.
Historical roots of gauge invariance

J. D. Jackson,L. B. Okun

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/RevModPhys.73.663

2001-03-14

Abstract:Gauge invariance is the basis of the modern theory of electroweak and strong interactions (the so called Standard Model). The roots of gauge invariance go back to the year 1820 when electromagnetism was discovered and the first electrodynamic theory was proposed. Subsequent developments led to the discovery that different forms of the vector potential result in the same observable forces. The partial arbitrariness of the vector potential A brought forth various restrictions on it. div A = 0 was proposed by J. C. Maxwell; 4-div A = 0 was proposed L. V. Lorenz in the middle of 1860's . In most of the modern texts the latter condition is attributed to H. A. Lorentz, who half a century later was one of the key figures in the final formulation of classical electrodynamics. In 1926 a relativistic quantum-mechanical equation for charged spinless particles was formulated by E. Schrodinger, O. Klein, and V. Fock. The latter discovered that this equation is invariant with respect to multiplication of the wave function by a phase factor exp(ieX/hc) with the accompanying additions to the scalar potential of -dX/cdt and to the vector potential of grad X. In 1929 H. Weyl proclaimed this invariance as a general principle and called it Eichinvarianz in German and gauge invariance in English. The present era of non-abelian gauge theories started in 1954 with the paper by C. N. Yang and R. L. Mills.

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology,Physics Education,History and Philosophy of Physics
Critical Behavior at the Chiral Phase Transition

C. Bernard,T. Blum,C.E. DeTar,U.M. Heller,S. Gottlieb,J.E. Hetrick,Beat Jegerlehner,K. Rummukainen,R.L. Sugar,D. Toussaint,M. Wingate

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0920-5632%2897%2900782-2

1997-10-10

Abstract:Quantum chromodynamics with two zero mass flavors is expected to exhibit a phase transition with O(4) critical behavior. Fixing the universality class is important for phenomenology and for facilitating the extrapolation of simulation data to physical quark mass values. At Lattice '96 the Tsukuba and Bielefeld groups reported results from new simulations with dynamical staggered quarks at $N_t = 4$, which suggested a departure from the expected critical behavior. We report observations of similar deviations and discuss efforts in progress to understand this phenomenon.

High Energy Physics - Lattice
Nonperturbative properties of Yang-Mills theories

Markus Q. Huber

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1808.05227

2020-04-22

Abstract:Yang-Mills theories are an important building block of the standard model and in particular of quantum chromodynamics. Its correlation functions describe the behavior of its elementary particles, the gauge bosons. In quantum chromodynamics, the correlation functions of the gluons are basic ingredients for calculations of hadrons from bound state equations or properties of its phase diagram with functional methods. Correlation functions of gluons are defined only in a gauge fixed setting. The focus of many studies is the Landau gauge which has some features that alleviate calculations. I discuss recent results of correlation functions in this gauge obtained from their equations of motions. Besides the four-dimensional case also two and three dimensions are treated, since the effects of truncations, viz., the procedure to render the infinitely large system of equations finite, can be studied more directly in these cases. In four dimensions, the anomalous running of dressing functions plays a special role and it is explained how resummation is realized in the case of Dyson-Schwinger equations. Beyond the Landau gauge other gauges can provide additional insights or can alleviate the development of new methods. Some aspects or ideas are more easily accessible in alternative gauges and the results presented here for linear covariant gauges, the Coulomb gauge and the maximally Abelian gauge help to refine our understanding of Yang-Mills theories.

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology
The Classical Equations of Motion of Quantized Gauge Theories, Part 2: Electromagnetism

David E. Kaplan,Tom Melia,Surjeet Rajendran

2023-07-19

Abstract:In this and companion papers, we show that quantum field theories with gauge symmetries permit a broader class of classical dynamics than typically assumed. In this article, we show that the quantization of electromagnetism permits the existence of classical electric field states that do not obey Gauss's law. These states are gauge invariant and their time evolution can be consistently described using the Schrödinger equation. The time evolution of these states is such that at the classical level, the full set of Maxwell's equations would appear to hold, with the physical effects of these states being attributable to an auxiliary, static ``shadow'' charge density with no internal degrees of freedom. This density could affect the dynamics of charged particles in our universe and it may thus be of observational interest.

High Energy Physics - Theory,High Energy Physics - Phenomenology
From quantum electrodynamics to a geometric gauge theory of classical electromagnetism

Adam Marsh

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1142/S0219887824400012

2023-09-15

Abstract:A relativistic version of the correspondence principle, a limit in which classical electrodynamics may be derived from QED, has never been clear, especially when including gravitational mass. Here we introduce a novel classical field theory formulation of electromagnetism, and then show that it approximates QED in the limit of a quantum state which corresponds to a classical charged continua. Our formulation of electromagnetism features a Lagrangian which is gauge invariant, includes a classical complex field from which a divergenceless four-current may be derived, and reproduces all aspects of the classical theory of charged massive continua without any quantum effects. Taking a geometric approach, we identify the four-current as being in the direction of extremal phase velocity of the classical field; the field equations of motion determine this phase velocity as being equal to the mass, which makes the rest density proportional to the squared modulus of the field.

General Physics,High Energy Physics - Theory
Gauge Symmetries, Symmetry Breaking, and Gauge-Invariant Approaches

Philipp Berghofer,Jordan François,Simon Friederich,Henrique Gomes,Guy Hetzroni,Axel Maas,René Sondenheimer

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/9781009197236

2021-10-02

Abstract:Gauge symmetries play a central role, both in the mathematical foundations as well as the conceptual construction of modern (particle) physics theories. However, it is yet unclear whether they form a necessary component of theories, or whether they can be eliminated. It is also unclear whether they are merely an auxiliary tool to simplify (and possibly localize) calculations or whether they contain independent information. Therefore their status, both in physics and philosophy of physics, remains to be fully clarified. In this overview we review the current state of affairs on both the philosophy and the physics side. In particular, we focus on the circumstances in which the restriction of gauge theories to gauge invariant information on an observable level is warranted, using the Brout-Englert-Higgs theory as an example of particular current importance. Finally, we determine a set of yet to be answered questions to clarify the status of gauge symmetries.

History and Philosophy of Physics,High Energy Physics - Lattice,High Energy Physics - Phenomenology,High Energy Physics - Theory
Magnetic Monopoles, Fiber Bundles, and Gauge Fields

CN Yang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1749-6632.1977.tb26477.x

1996-01-01

Abstract:The reports in this monograph have shown great enthusiasm and exuberance for the unification of various interactions through the concept of gauge fields. I would like to emphasize a point that has not yet been explicitly stated by any of the other authors: gauge fields are deeply related to some profoundly beautiful ideas of contemporary mathematics, ideas that are the driving forces of part of the mathematics of the last 40 years. Recalling the relationship between physics and mathematics in earlier periods, general relativity and Riemannian geometry, quantum mechanics and Hilbert space, it is all too obvious that physicists may again be zeroing in on a fundamental new secret of nature.
On the foundations and necessity of classical gauge invariance

Miguel Sánchez

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.0803.1290

2008-03-10

Abstract:We argue that, ideally, the ways to measure magnitudes in non-quantum theories of physics (spacetime, field theory), limit drastically their possible mathematical models. In particular, gauge invariance in the Yang-Mills framework, is a necessity of our way of measuring rather than an a priori imposition on symmetry. A general postulational basis for the geometric aspects of classical field theories is introduced, and the permitted models are studied. Some of them (for example, compatible with signature-changing metrics or variations of the speed of interactions) are new, and require a generalization of the concept of principal fiber bundle, which may be of interest both, physically and mathematically.

Mathematical Physics,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology
Gauge Symmetry and Gravito-Electromagnetism

Simon J. Clark,Robin W. Tucker

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/0264-9381/17/19/311

2000-09-22

Abstract:A tensor description of perturbative Einsteinian gravity about an arbitrary background spacetime is developed. By analogy with the covariant laws of electromagnetism in spacetime, gravito-electromagnetic potentials and fields are defined to emulate electromagnetic gauge transformations under substitutions belonging to the gauge symmetry group of perturbative gravitation. These definitions have the advantage that on a flat background, with the aid of a covariantly constant timelike vector field, a subset of the linearised gravitational field equations can be written in a form that is fully analogous to Maxwell's equations (without awkward factors of 4 and extraneous tensor fields). It is shown how the remaining equations in the perturbed gravitational system restrict the time dependence of solutions to these equations and thereby prohibit the existence of propagating vector fields. The induced gravito-electromagnetic Lorentz force on a test particle is evaluated in terms of these fields together with the torque on a small gyroscope. It is concluded that the analogy of perturbative gravity to Maxwell's description of electromagnetism can be valuable for (quasi-)stationary gravitational phenomena but that the analogy has its limitations.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,Astrophysics
Gauge Symmetry from Integral Viewpoint

Chen Ying,He Bing,Lin He,Wu Ji-Min

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arxiv.hep-th/9912189

1999-01-01

Abstract:The purpose of this paper is to investigate the gauge symmetry of classicalfield theories in integral formalism. A gauge invariant theory is defined interms of the invariance of the physical observables under the coordinatetransformations in principal bundle space. Through the detailed study on theproperty of non-Abelian parallel transportor under gauge transformations, weshow that it is not generally a two-point spinor, i.e. an operator to beaffected only by the gauge group elements at the two end points of the paralleltransport path, except for the pure gauge situation, and therefore the localgauge symmetry for non-Abelian models is found to be broken in non-perturbativedomain. However, an Abelian gauge theory is proved to be strictly invariantunder local gauge transformation, as it is illustrated by the invariance of theinterference pattern of electrons in Aharonov-Bohm effect. The related issuesof the phenomenon are discussed.
Some beautiful equations of mathematical physics

Daniel Z. Freedman

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.hep-th/9408175

1994-09-01

Abstract:The basic ideas and the important role of gauge principles in modern elementary particle physics are outlined. There are three theoretically consistent gauge principles in quantum field theory: the spin-1 gauge principle of electromagnetism and the standard model, the spin-2 gauge principle of general relativity, and the spin-3/2 gauge principle of supergravity. (Dirac Prize lecture, November 1993. Two figures are unavailable, but should not be essential.)

High Energy Physics - Theory,Mathematical Physics
Defining geometric gauge theory to accommodate particles, continua, and fields

Adam Marsh

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1063/5.0230212

2024-09-25

Abstract:Gauge theory underpins the quantum field theories of the standard model, and in a previous paper was shown via a geometric approach to describe classical electromagnetism in a form which approximates QED. Here we formalize and generalize the notion of a geometric gauge theory, then apply this framework to classical physical models, including an improved Lagrangian for matter field electromagnetism. We find a remarkably consistent series of actions, with straightforward limits under which each previous one may be obtained. Ancillary benefits include a gauge-independent Galilean Lagrangian, a geometric interpretation for the unusual metric dependence of four-momentum, a modern treatment of the effects of worldline variation on the four-current, a gauge theory of gravity which includes a matter field, and consistent units for matter field electromagnetism.

General Physics
FAR AND NEAR ORIGINS OF THE STANDARD MODEL IN PHYSICS OF FUNDAMENTAL INTERACTIONS (TO THE 150TH ANNIVERSARY OF F. KLEIN'S ERLANGEN PROGRAM AND TO THE 100TH ANNIVERSARY OF THE BIRTH OF C. YANG)

V. P. Vizgin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.22363/2224-7580-2022-4-149-169

2022-12-15

Metaphysics

Abstract:In connection with the 150th anniversary of F. Klein’s Erlangen program in geometry and the 100th anniversary of the birth of C. Yang, the main creator, non-Abelian gauge fields are discovered, the far and near sources of the standard in the physics of fundamental models of interactions are concluded. A distant source is the Erlangen program and its subsequent introduction of reaction to relative and classical physics. This material discusses the phenomenon of “inconceivable effectiveness of mathematics in special sciences” (J. Wigner), which becomes clearer on the basis of the “relay model” of the interaction between mathematics and physics proposed by D. Hilbert. The approximation of the Erlangen observation, which is applied to Noether's observations on the connection between meetings and meetings, is considered, as well as the application of the Erlangen observation to the history of physics. It is shown how the extension of this domain to local gauge domains is carried out by C. Yang and R. Millsakoch theories of non-Abelian field gauges (1954), which became a near source on the way to the standard and completed model in 1973-1974.
Derivation of Maxwell's equations via the covariance requirements of the special theory of relativity, starting with Newton's laws

Allan D. Pierce

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.0807.2557

2008-07-16

Classical Physics

Abstract:A connection between Maxwell's equations, Newton's laws, and the special theory of relativity is established with a derivation that begins with Newton's verbal enunciation of his first two laws. Derived equations are required to be covariant, and a simplicity criterion requires that the four-vector force on a charged particle be linearly related to the four-vector velocity. The connecting tensor has derivable symmetry properties and contains the electric and magnetic field vectors. The Lorentz force law emerges, and Maxwell's equations for free space emerge with the assumption that the tensor and its dual must both satisfy first order partial differential equations. The inhomogeneous extension yields a charge density and a current density as being the source of the field, and yields the law of conservation of charge. Newton's third law is reinterpreted as a reciprocity statement, which requires that the charge in the source term can be taken as the same physical entity as that of the test particle and that both can be assigned the same units. Requiring covariance under either spatial inversions or time reversals precludes magnetic charge being a source of electromagnetic fields that exert forces on electric charges.
Price Variations in a Stock Market With Many Agents

P. Bak,M. Paczuski,M. Shubik

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0378-4371%2897%2900401-9

1996-09-17

Abstract:Large variations in stock prices happen with sufficient frequency to raise doubts about existing models, which all fail to account for non-Gaussian statistics. We construct simple models of a stock market, and argue that the large variations may be due to a crowd effect, where agents imitate each other's behavior. The variations over different time scales can be related to each other in a systematic way, similar to the Levy stable distribution proposed by Mandelbrot to describe real market indices. In the simplest, least realistic case, exact results for the statistics of the variations are derived by mapping onto a model of diffusing and annihilating particles, which has been solved by quantum field theory methods. When the agents imitate each other and respond to recent market volatility, different scaling behavior is obtained. In this case the statistics of price variations is consistent with empirical observations. The interplay between ``rational'' traders whose behavior is derived from fundamental analysis of the stock, including dividends, and ``noise traders'', whose behavior is governed solely by studying the market dynamics, is investigated. When the relative number of rational traders is small, ``bubbles'' often occur, where the market price moves outside the range justified by fundamental market analysis. When the number of rational traders is larger, the market price is generally locked within the price range they define.

Condensed Matter
High-gradient theories as new essential ingredient for the beyond-Standard-Model Des(s)ert cuisine: Getting rid of divergences in Feynman graphs, unified ``all-in-one'' states and origin of generations

Konstantin G. Zloshchastiev

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.hep-th/0006002

2000-06-06

Abstract:Inspiring ourselves by the assumption that the notion of symmetry itself is insufficient to construct the consistent physics of the Desert (the so-called region of energies beyond the Standard Model) and some additional insights are needed, we suggests that high-energy theories must take into account the higher-order variations of fields. With this in mind we propose the generalization of the concepts of kinetic energy and free particle. It is shown that the theory founded on such principles reveals major features of the genuinely high-energy one, first of all, it appears to be free from ultra-violet divergences, even the self-energy loop terms become finite. Also we discuss other arising interesting phenomena such as the high-gradient currents and charges, unified ``all-in-one'' multi-mass states, VR symmetry, regularization-without-renormalization of SM, etc.

High Energy Physics - Theory,High Energy Physics - Phenomenology
A gauge theoretical view of the charge concept in Einstein gravity

Marc Toussaint

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A%3A1001985024409

2000-03-17

Abstract:We will discuss some analogies between internal gauge theories and gravity in order to better understand the charge concept in gravity. A dimensional analysis of gauge theories in general and a strict definition of elementary, monopole, and topological charges are applied to electromagnetism and to teleparallelism, a gauge theoretical formulation of Einstein gravity. As a result we inevitably find that the gravitational coupling constant has dimension $\hbar/l^2$, the mass parameter of a particle dimension $\hbar/l$, and the Schwarzschild mass parameter dimension l (where l means length). These dimensions confirm the meaning of mass as elementary and as monopole charge of the translation group, respectively. In detail, we find that the Schwarzschild mass parameter is a quasi-electric monopole charge of the time translation whereas the NUT parameter is a quasi-magnetic monopole charge of the time translation as well as a topological charge. The Kerr parameter and the electric and magnetic charges are interpreted similarly. We conclude that each elementary charge of a Casimir operator of the gauge group is the source of a (quasi-electric) monopole charge of the respective Killing vector.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,High Energy Physics - Theory
From colored gravity to electromagnetism

Robert Monjo,Álvaro Rodríguez-Abella,Rutwig Campoamor-Stursberg

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10714-024-03307-8

IF: 2.84

2024-10-12

General Relativity and Gravitation

Abstract:The gauge formalism in telepalallel gravity provides an interesting viewpoint to describe interactions according to an anholonomic observer's tetrad basis. Without going into assessing the complete viability of quantization in an early stage, this paper explores classical gravity within the framework of a classical-to-quantum bridge between the SU(1, 3) Yang–Mills gauge formalism and the gauge-like treatment of teleparallel gravity. Specifically, the perturbed spacetime algebra with Weitzenböck connection can be assimilated to a local complexification based on the SU(1, 3) Yang–Mills theory, what we call hypercolor or, simply, color. The formulation of the hypercolor dynamics is build by a translational gauge, as in the teleparallel gravities. In particular, this work analyses small perturbations of a metric decomposition related to the Wilson line and the Kaluza–Klein metric, but obtaining electrodynamics in four dimensions. The spacetime coordinates are now matrices that represent elements of the algebra. To make compatible the formulation of a colored gravity with the Lorentz force and the Maxwell equations, it is enough to define every energy potential origin as 0 in the event horizon instead of the classic zero potential at infinity. Under the colored gravity framework, standard electromagnetism can be obtained as a particular abelian case.

astronomy & astrophysics,physics, multidisciplinary, particles & fields

The Conceptual Origins of Maxwell’s Equations and Gauge Theory

Unification of Force and Substance

The Noether Current in Maxwell's Equations and Radiation under Symmetry Breaking.

Historical roots of gauge invariance

Critical Behavior at the Chiral Phase Transition

Nonperturbative properties of Yang-Mills theories

The Classical Equations of Motion of Quantized Gauge Theories, Part 2: Electromagnetism

From quantum electrodynamics to a geometric gauge theory of classical electromagnetism

Gauge Symmetries, Symmetry Breaking, and Gauge-Invariant Approaches

Magnetic Monopoles, Fiber Bundles, and Gauge Fields

On the foundations and necessity of classical gauge invariance

Gauge Symmetry and Gravito-Electromagnetism

Gauge Symmetry from Integral Viewpoint

Some beautiful equations of mathematical physics

Defining geometric gauge theory to accommodate particles, continua, and fields

FAR AND NEAR ORIGINS OF THE STANDARD MODEL IN PHYSICS OF FUNDAMENTAL INTERACTIONS (TO THE 150TH ANNIVERSARY OF F. KLEIN'S ERLANGEN PROGRAM AND TO THE 100TH ANNIVERSARY OF THE BIRTH OF C. YANG)

Derivation of Maxwell's equations via the covariance requirements of the special theory of relativity, starting with Newton's laws

Price Variations in a Stock Market With Many Agents

High-gradient theories as new essential ingredient for the beyond-Standard-Model Des(s)ert cuisine: Getting rid of divergences in Feynman graphs, unified ``all-in-one'' states and origin of generations

A gauge theoretical view of the charge concept in Einstein gravity

From colored gravity to electromagnetism