Cone Ratio Models with Shared Resources and Unobservable Allocative Parameters in Network DEA

Jingjing Ding,Chenpeng Feng
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2368665
2012-01-01
Abstract:In the literature, many researchers study the performance of a production system with shared resources based on Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA). The extant models are based on the multiplier type models and resource allocation variables (RAVs) in some simple but instructive network settings such as multi-component and two-stage structures. Two issues associated with RAVs are relevant to both the theory and the practice. Firstly, the extant models with RAVs are nonlinear in general. Secondly, a potential conflict of interest between a central evaluator and the managers of decision-making units (DMUs) due to the unknown allocative parameters has not been addressed. This work contributes by presenting conflict free models (CFMs). First, the proposed models can be transformed to linear programs. Second, the proposed models are conflict free, which means that the manager of a DMU cannot argue against the evaluation result by claiming unfavorable information regarding the split of shared resources has been used, as no priorities over the split are included. Furthermore, we investigate the relations between CFMs and the existing models, which enrich the interpretations of the existent models. Last but not the least, the proposed models incorporate partial ordering preferences expressed as cone ratio constraints, and are suitable for a wide range of real life applications. A dataset extracted from the literature is used to illustrate the main idea.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?