Reply to Comment on "State-independent experimental test of quantum contextuality in an indivisible system"

c zu,y x wang,d l deng,x y chang,k liu,p y hou,h x yang,l m duan

2013-01-01

Abstract: This is a reply to the comment from E. Amselem et al. on our paper (Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 150401 (2012), arXiv:1207.0059).

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Comment on the Comment on Deformation of Quantum-Mechanics

YQ LI,ZM SHENG

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/0253-6102/24/3/384

1995-01-01

Communications in Theoretical Physics

Abstract:This is a reply to the comment by Chung and Chung [J. Phys. A27 (1994) 5037]. We point out that the discussion there is imperfect.
State-independent Experimental Test of Quantum Contextuality in an Indivisible System

C. Zu,Y. -X. Wang,D. -L. Deng,X. -Y. Chang,K. Liu,P. -Y. Hou,H. -X. Yang,L. -M. Duan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.109.150401

2012-01-01

Abstract:We report the first state-independent experimental test of quantum contextuality on a single photonic qutrit (three-dimensional system), based on a recent theoretical proposal [Yu and Oh, Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 030402 (2012)]. Our experiment spotlights quantum contextuality in its most basic form, in a way that is independent of either the state or the tensor product structure of the system.
Qin Et Al. Reply

Nan Qin,Emmanuelle Le Chatelier,Jing Guo,Edi Prifti,Lanjuan Li,S. Dusko Ehrlich

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/nature14852

IF: 64.8

2015-01-01

Nature

Abstract:A Reply to the Comment by J. H. Chen and H. Y. Fan.Received 22 May 2013DOI:https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.110.269502© 2013 American Physical Society
Experimental Test of State-Independent Quantum Contextuality of an Indivisible Quantum System

Yun-Feng Huang,Meng Li,Dong-Yang Cao,Chao Zhang,Yong-Sheng Zhang,Bi-Heng Liu,Chuan-Feng Li,Guang-Can Guo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physreva.87.052133

IF: 2.971

2013-01-01

Physical Review A

Abstract:We report a state-independent experimental test of quantum contextuality of a single-photon qutrit. The experimental results demonstrate violations of an inequality originally formulated by Yu and Oh [Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 030402 (2012)] and further optimized by Cabello et al. [Phys. Rev. A 85, 032108 (2012)]; this inequality is satisfied by all noncontextual hidden variable models and is violated by all qutrit states. Our experiment shows quantum contextuality of this nature in a most fundamental way: A way that is independent of state and unrelated to entanglement.
Reply to the Comment "Past of a quantum particle and weak measurement"

Lev Vaidman

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1310.1319

2013-10-04

Abstract:Misinterpretation in the preceding Comment of my recent analysis of the past of a photon is corrected. There is nothing in this analysis which is "contrary to the usual quantum expectations" but, nevertheless, it does provide "further understanding and interpretation of the system considered". In particular, it teaches us that the naive common sense argument frequently used in the literature including the Comment has to be abandoned.

Quantum Physics
Reply to comment in <a class="link-https" data-arxiv-id="1802.01382" href="https://arxiv.org/abs/1802.01382">arXiv:1802.01382</a>

T. P. Xiong,L. L. Yan,F. Zhou,K. Rehan,D. F. Liang,L. Chen,W. L. Yang,Z. H. Ma,M. Feng,V. Vedral

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1802.02392

2018-08-05

Abstract:Here we respond to a comment [<a class="link-https" data-arxiv-id="1802.01382" href="https://arxiv.org/abs/1802.01382">arXiv:1802.01382</a>] submitted recently on 'Experimental Verification of a Jarzynski-Related Information-Theoretic Equality by a Single Trapped Ion' PRL 120 010601 (2018). We consider that the argument is the thermalization in a quantum system, which is different from the counterpart in conventional thermodynamics.

Quantum Physics
Reply to Comment on "Multitime Quantum Communication: Interesting But Not Counterfactual" by L. Vaidman

Robert B. Griffiths

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.108.056202

2024-02-02

Abstract:This is a Reply to the Comment by Vaidman in <a class="link-https" data-arxiv-id="2306.16756" href="https://arxiv.org/abs/2306.16756">arXiv:2306.16756</a> on the paper: R. B. Griffiths, Phys. Rev. A 107, 062219 (2023)

Quantum Physics
State-independent Experimental Tests of Quantum Contextuality in a Three Dimensional System

Xiang Zhang,Mark Um,Junhua Zhang,Shuoming An,Ye Wang,Dong-ling Deng,Chao Shen,Luming Duan,Kihwan Kim

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.110.070401

2012-01-01

Abstract:We experimentally observed state-independent violations of Kochen-Specker inequalities for the simplest indivisible quantum system manifesting quantum contextuality, a three-level (qutrit) system. We performed the experiment with a single trapped ^171Yb^+ ion, by mapping three ground states of the ^171Yb^+ ion to a qutrit system and carrying out quantum operatations by applying microwaves resonant to the qutrit transition frequencies. Our results are free from the detection loophole and cannot be explained by the non-contextual hidden variable models.
An experimental test of the non-classicality of quantum mechanics using an unmovable and indivisible system

xi kong,mingjun shi,fazhan shi,pengfei wang,pu huang,qi zhang,chenyong ju,changkui duan,sixia yu,jiangfeng du

2012-01-01

Abstract: Quantum mechanics provides a statistical description about nature, and thus would be incomplete if its statistical predictions could not be accounted for by some realistic models with hidden variables. There are, however, two powerful theorems against the hidden-variable theories showing that certain quantum features cannot be reproduced based on two rationale premises of locality, Bell's theorem, and noncontextuality, due to Bell, Kochen and Specker (BKS). Noncontextuality is independent of nonlocality, and the contextuality manifests itself even in a single object. Here we report an experimental verification of quantum contextuality by a single spin-1 electron system at room temperature. Such a three-level system is indivisible and then we close the compatibility loophole which exists in the experiments performed on bipartite systems. Our results confirm the quantum contextuality to be the intrinsic property of single particles.
Experimental observation of quantum state-independent contextuality under no-signaling conditions

Ya Xiao,Zhen-Peng Xu,Qiang Li,Jin-Shi Xu,Kai Sun,Jin-Ming Cui,Zong-Quan Zhou,Hong-Yi Su,Adán Cabello,Jing-Ling Chen,Chuan-Feng Li,Guang-Can Guo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1364/OE.26.000032

2018-01-08

Abstract:Contextuality, the impossibility of assigning context-independent measurement outcomes, is a critical resource for quantum computation and communication. No-signaling between successive measurements is an essential requirement that should be accomplished in any test of quantum contextuality and that is difficult to achieve in practice. Here, we introduce an optimal quantum state-independent contextuality inequality in which the deviation from the classical bound is maximal. We then experimentally test it using single photons generated from a defect in a bulk silicon carbide, while satisfying the requirement of no-signaling within the experimental error. Our results shed new light on the study of quantum contextuality under no-signaling conditions.
Reply to "Comment on `Extending the laws of thermodynamics for arbitrary autonomous quantum systems'"

Cyril Elouard,Camille Lombard Latune

2023-09-15

Abstract:In his Comment [1], Philip Strasberg (PS) argues from the analysis of different examples that the framework we have presented in [2] does not recover known results of macroscopic textbook thermodynamics. Here, we show that such apparent contradictions disappear when the necessary assumptions the aforementioned known results pre-suppose are applied. Those assumptions concern the control ability of the observer, the nature of the described degree of freedom, or the scale of the systems. The ability to relax those assumptions is precisely a motivation of our framework, which can explore the capacity of quantum systems to exchange work and heat even at scales not captured by textbook thermodynamics. We take the opportunity of this reply to further expand on the use of our framework and its connections with traditional thermodynamics.

Quantum Physics
Reply to Comment on "Quantum Force in a Superconductor"

A.V.Nikulov

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.cond-mat/0304313

2003-04-14

Abstract:A reply is made to Comment by <a class="link-external link-http" href="http://D.P.Sheehan" rel="external noopener nofollow">this http URL</a> in which he takes notice that the quantum force introduced in my earlier paper <a class="link-external link-http" href="http://A.V.Nikulov" rel="external noopener nofollow">this http URL</a>, Phys. Rev. B 64, 012505 (2001) challenges to the absolute status of the second law of thermodynamics. It is shown that the introduction of the quantum force explains only an experimental challenge to the second law. The observation of the persistent current at non-zero resistance R > 0 is experimental evidence of violation of the postulate saving the second law in the beginning of the 20 century. According to this postulate any Brownian motion is absolutely random whereas the persistent current at R > 0 is a regulated Brownian motion.

Superconductivity,Statistical Mechanics
Reply to the Comment on ‘Two-State Vector Formalism and Quantum Interference’

Faheel Hashmi,Fu Li,Shi-Yao Zhu,M. Suhail Zubairy

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1751-8121/aa8d23

2018-01-01

Abstract:In the preceding comment it is claimed that we are mistaken in the analysis of the theory of the 'past of a quantum particle' proposed by the author of the comment. We show that the claim is unfounded. Moreover we show that the arguments presented in the comment are not consistent with the already proposed theory.
Reply to "Comment on `Weak values and the past of a quantum particle' ''

Jonte R Hance,John Rarity,James Ladyman

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevResearch.5.048002

2023-11-09

Abstract:We here reply to a recent comment by Vaidman [\href{<a class="link-external link-https" href="https://journals.aps.org/prresearch/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevResearch.5.048001" rel="external noopener nofollow">this https URL</a>}{Phys. Rev. Res. 5, 048001 (2023)}] on our paper [\href{<a class="link-external link-https" href="https://journals.aps.org/prresearch/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevResearch.5.023048" rel="external noopener nofollow">this https URL</a>}{Phys. Rev. Res. 5, 023048 (2023)}]. In his Comment, Vaidman first admits that he is just defining (assuming) the weak trace gives the presence of a particle -- however, in this case, he should use a term other than presence, as this already has a separate, intuitive meaning other than ``where a weak trace is''. Despite this admission, Vaidman then goes on to argue for this definition by appeal to ideas around an objectively-existing idea of presence. We show these appeals rely on their own conclusion -- that there is always a matter of fact about the location of a quantum particle.

Quantum Physics,History and Philosophy of Physics
Experimental Test of Quantum Nonlocality from Contextuality

Jianqi Sheng,Dongkai Zhang,Lixiang Chen

2024-02-29

Abstract:There are two powerful arguments against the possibility of extending quantum mechanics, the violation of Bell inequalities and the Kochen-Specker theorem, but the connection between the two remains confused. Following the distinctive strategy proposed by Cabello [Phys. Rev. Lett. 127, 070401 (2021)], Bell inequalities can be violated by state-independent contextuality sets. However, the experimental realization of such ideas is challenging as it requires high-dimensional entanglement. Orbital angular momentum provides an unlimited state space and the number of effective dimensions can be readily tailored as required. We performed an experimental test of non-locality based on Bell inequalities from contextuality, using orbital angular momentum entanglement in a bipartite photonic system. Our experiment not only shows a new way to produce non-locality but also connects contextuality and non-locality, two fundamental quantum resources that are critical for quantum computation and secure communication tasks.

Quantum Physics
Wexleret Al.reply:

Carlos Wexler,D. J. Thouless,Ping Ao,Qian Niu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.81.4277

IF: 8.6

1998-01-01

Physical Review Letters

Abstract:A Reply to the Comment by E. B. Sonin.Received 9 September 1998DOI:https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.81.4277©1998 American Physical Society
Experimental Test of Contextuality Based on State Discrimination with a Single Qubit

Qiuxin Zhang,Chenhao Zhu,Yuxin Wang,Liangyu Ding,Tingting Shi,Xiang Zhang,Shuaining Zhang,Wei Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/0256-307x/39/8/080301

2022-01-01

Chinese Physics Letters

Abstract:Exploring quantum phenomena beyond predictions of any classical model has fundamental importance to understand the boundary of classical and quantum descriptions of nature. As a typical property that a quantum system behaves distinctively from a classical counterpart, contextuality has been studied extensively and verified experimentally in systems composed of at least three levels（qutrit）. Here we extend the scope of experimental test of contextuality to a minimal quantum system of only two states（qubit） by implementing the minimum error state discrimination on a single171Yb+ion. We observe a substantial violation of a no-go inequality derived by assuming non-contextuality, and firmly conclude that the measured results of state discrimination cannot be reconciled with any non-contextual description. We also quantify the contextual advantage of state discrimination and the tolerance against quantum noises.
Reply to the comment on "High-Power Collective Charging of a Solid-State Quantum Battery" by Haowei Xu and Ju Li

D. Ferraro,M. Campisi,G. M. Andolina,V. Pellegrini,M. Polini

2024-11-16

Abstract:In this short communication we reply to the comment by Xu and Li (<a class="link-https" data-arxiv-id="2411.04132" href="https://arxiv.org/abs/2411.04132">arXiv:2411.04132</a>) on our first work on Dicke quantum batteries (Phys. Rev. Lett. 120, 117702 (2018)).

Quantum Physics
A computational test of quantum contextuality, and even simpler proofs of quantumness

Atul Singh Arora,Kishor Bharti,Alexandru Cojocaru,Andrea Coladangelo

2024-05-11

Abstract:Bell non-locality is a fundamental feature of quantum mechanics whereby measurements performed on "spatially separated" quantum systems can exhibit correlations that cannot be understood as revealing predetermined values. This is a special case of the more general phenomenon of "quantum contextuality", which says that such correlations can occur even when the measurements are not necessarily on separate quantum systems, but are merely "compatible" (i.e. commuting). Crucially, while any non-local game yields an experiment that demonstrates quantum advantage by leveraging the "spatial separation" of two or more devices (and in fact several such demonstrations have been conducted successfully in recent years), the same is not true for quantum contextuality: finding the contextuality analogue of such an experiment is arguably one of the central open questions in the foundations of quantum mechanics.

Quantum Physics,Cryptography and Security
Zu et al. reply:.

C Zu,Y-X Wang,D-L Deng,X-Y Chang,K Liu,P-Y Hou,H-X Yang,L-M Duan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.110.078902

IF: 8.6

2013-01-01

Physical Review Letters

Abstract:A Reply to the Comment by E. Amselem et al.Received 4 December 2012DOI:https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.110.078902© 2013 American Physical Society

Reply to Comment on "State-independent experimental test of quantum contextuality in an indivisible system"

Comment on the Comment on Deformation of Quantum-Mechanics

State-independent Experimental Test of Quantum Contextuality in an Indivisible System

Qin Et Al. Reply

Experimental Test of State-Independent Quantum Contextuality of an Indivisible Quantum System

Reply to the Comment "Past of a quantum particle and weak measurement"

Reply to comment in <a class="link-https" data-arxiv-id="1802.01382" href="https://arxiv.org/abs/1802.01382">arXiv:1802.01382</a>

Reply to Comment on "Multitime Quantum Communication: Interesting But Not Counterfactual" by L. Vaidman

State-independent Experimental Tests of Quantum Contextuality in a Three Dimensional System

An experimental test of the non-classicality of quantum mechanics using an unmovable and indivisible system

Experimental observation of quantum state-independent contextuality under no-signaling conditions

Reply to "Comment on `Extending the laws of thermodynamics for arbitrary autonomous quantum systems'"

Reply to Comment on "Quantum Force in a Superconductor"

Reply to the Comment on ‘Two-State Vector Formalism and Quantum Interference’

Reply to "Comment on `Weak values and the past of a quantum particle' ''

Experimental Test of Quantum Nonlocality from Contextuality

Wexleret Al.reply:

Experimental Test of Contextuality Based on State Discrimination with a Single Qubit

Reply to the comment on "High-Power Collective Charging of a Solid-State Quantum Battery" by Haowei Xu and Ju Li

A computational test of quantum contextuality, and even simpler proofs of quantumness

Zu et al. reply:.