Warning to Theoretical Structure Elucidation of Endohedral Metallofullerenes

Ruisheng Zhao,Yijun Guo,Pei Zhao,Masahiro Ehara,Shigeru Nagase,Xiang Zhao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.jpcc.5b09403

2015-01-01

The Journal of Physical Chemistry C

Abstract:Endohedral scandium fullerenes have attracted substantial interest since they were synthesized and isolated in 1992. The Sc2C74 series including both Sc-2@C-74 and Sc2C2@C-72 forms were thoroughly investigated with density functional theory (DFT) methods including B3LYP, CAM-B3LYP, M06-2X, wB97XD, and some other DFT methods combined with statistical mechanics in the present work. Among all the Sc2C74 isomers, Sc2C2@Cs(10528)-C-72 is the most thermodynamically stable one, and it is overwhelming at the temperature region of fullerene formation, which is very consistent with experiments. A deviation that the B3LYP method as well as other DFT methods without long-range corrections tends to overestimate energies of Sc2C2@C-72 series was exposed for the first time to our best knowledge, and this deviation may not only be restricted to the Sc2C2@C-72 series but also apply to other scandium carbide fullerenes Sc2C2@C-2n (2n not equal 72) and even other metal carbide fullerenes. Misleading conclusions will be drawn on the basis of inaccurate energies calculated with B3LYP method and other DFT methods without long-range corrections. As B3LYP, BP86, PBE, etc. are fairly widely used methods in theoretical studies of endohedral metallofullerenes, our work is an instructive warning to these studies.