Turning Good Soldiers into Bad Apples: Examining when and Why Citizenship Behavior Leads to Deviance

Kai Chi Yam,Anthony Klotz,Wei He,Scott J. Reynolds

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5465/ambpp.2014.26

2014-01-01

Academy of Management Proceedings

Abstract:Research suggests that when employees engage in organizational citizenship behavior (OCB), it generally produces a wide array of positive outcomes for employees and organizations. In this paper, we draw from moral licensing and self-determination theories to suggest a potential downside of OCB. Specifically, we argue that when employees feel compelled to engage in OCB, they subsequently feel entitled for having gone above and beyond the call of duty and these feelings of entitlement act as a moral license that psychologically frees employees to engage in deviance both inside and outside of the workplace. Data from an online experiment, a behavioral laboratory study, and two multi-source field studies provide support for these hypotheses. Results from Study 1 demonstrated that recalling OCB led to increased psychological entitlement among participants who had performed OCB as a result of controlled motivation. The findings of Study 2 indicated that this interactive effect in turn led participants to engage in increased interpersonal and organizational deviance. Studies 3 and 4 replicated these findings in two field settings. Finally, we demonstrated that OCB-generated feelings of entitlement also led to deviance outside of the organization. Theoretical implications and directions for future research are discussed.