Abstract:OBJECTIVES: The neural correlates of human cooperative behavior remain poorly understood. Previous work has suggested that increases in striatal activation while punishing unfair offers represents reward signaling. However, other regions are also implicated when punishing others, for example dorsomedial frontal cortex (dmFC), anterior insula cortex (AIC), and periaqueductal gray (PAG). Moreover, the response of other regions implicated in signaling reward, for example ventromedial prefrontal cortex (vmPFC) or posterior cingulate cortex (PCC), has not been systematically examined.EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN: Functional magnetic resonance imaging utilizing parametric modulation was conducted on 21 healthy adults participating in a social exchange paradigm.PRINCIPAL OBSERVATIONS: Participants showed significant positive modulation of activity as a function of delivered punishment in caudate, dmFC, AIC, and PAG; that is, higher punishments by participants of unsatisfactory offers were associated with increasing activity within these regions. However, participants showed significant negative modulation of activity as a function of delivered punishment in vmPFC and PCC; increases in punishment level by participants were associated with decreases in activity within these regions.CONCLUSIONS: The current data question whether caudate activity when punishing unfair offers should be considered to indicate the reward value of this punishment. Instead, this activity, in conjunction with activity within dmFC, AIC, and PAG, may represent the organization of an untypical, punishing response that represents a reactive aggressive response to provocation. Notably, an inverse, regulatory relationship between vmPFC and PAG activity has been previously implicated in the context of another stimulus for reactive aggression; looming threat (Mobbs et al. [2007]: Science 317:1079-1083).

Effects of Reward and Punishment on Conflict Processing: Same or Different?

Calculated Punishment

Reward Enhances Backward Inhibition in Task Switching

Reward Expectation Modulates Multiple Stages of Auditory Conflict Control.

Reward Interacts with Modality Shift to Reduce Cross-Modal Conflict.

Reward Modulates Unconsciously Triggered Adaptive Control Processes

Modulating Activity in the Dorsolateral Prefrontal Cortex Changes Punishment in the 3-Player Prisoner’s Dilemma: A Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation Study

Proactive reward in conflict tasks: Does it only enhance general performance or also modulate conflict effects?

cTBS to Right DLPFC Modulates Physiological Correlates of Conflict Processing: Evidence from a Stroop task

The influence of reward in the Simon task: Differences and similarities to the Stroop and Eriksen flanker tasks

Punishing unfairness: Rewarding or the organization of a reactively aggressive response?

Opposite Effect of Conflict Context Modulation on Neural Mechanisms of Cognitive and Affective Control.

Dissociable Early Attentional Control Mechanisms Underlying Cognitive and Affective Conflicts

Dissociable influences of reward and punishment on adaptive cognitive control

On Difference Between Direct-Response Method and Strategy Method in Decision-Making: Behavioural and Neural Evidence in a Reward-Punishment Game

Distinct mechanisms underlying cross-modal semantic conflict and response conflict processing

The Hot-Versus-cold Effect in a Punishment Game: a Multi-Round Experimental Study

Intention Modulates the Effect of Punishment Threat in Norm Enforcement via the Lateral Orbitofrontal Cortex.

Disrupting the Dorsolateral Prefrontal Cortex Attenuates the Difference in Decision-Making for Altruistic Punishment Between the Gain and Loss Contexts

The Important Role of the Right Dorsolateral Prefrontal Cortex in Conflict Adaptation: A Combined Voxel-Based Morphometry and Continuous Theta Burst Stimulation Study

Reward Facilitates Response Conflict Resolution Via Global Motor Inhibition: Electromyography Evidence