Striking A Balance Between Intellectual Property Protection of Traditional Chinese Medicine and Access to Knowledge

Lin Peng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2677628

2015-01-01

Abstract:Traditional Chinese medicine has played a vital role in the well being of Chinese people for thousands of years. It is a comprehensive system of herb medicine that has been repeatedly practiced and gradually summarized by Chinese people over a long period of time. The current practice related to traditional Chinese medicine has gone beyond the traditional practice. It at least includes mass production of traditional Chinese medicine pills, traditional Chinese medicine herb extract and therapeutic chemicals identified in traditional Chinese medicine materia medica. While traditional practice is in the public domain, the case is less clear for the expansive practice of traditional Chinese medicine, particularly because the public has not practiced such knowledge before. The current intellectual property law is designed to strike a delicate balance between incentives of creation and access to knowledge. It is often construed from a utilitarian perspective. This utilitarian consideration can justify some protection for the new practice. While the current intellectual property law often only recognizes limited defensive rights for traditional knowledge holders, once the rights of non-traditional practitioners are recognized, the rationale of intellectual property legal regime may justify a stronger package of rights, which would include more than defensive rights for traditional knowledge holders.