Reconsideration of scaling measure for liquid-column break problem

tomoaki kunugi,k hara,tsuyoshi nagatake,zensaku kawara
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1063/1.4816877
2013-01-01
AIP Conference Proceedings
Abstract:The liquid-column break problem is one of the well-known validation tests for the multiphase flow computations. However, a few experimental data are available until now regarding the liquid-column break problem. In the validation process, it is necessary to consider the differences of the boundary and initial conditions between both experiment and numerical simulation. In this study, we conducted the liquid-column break experiments and measured the position of the water-front and the gravity center of the water region by using a high-speed camera and an image analyzing software. These experimental results were compared with the numerical simulation results. The water front position is usually taken as a scaling measure to evaluate the accuracy of numerical method for multiphase flows. However, when the real sizes of the liquid column changed to double without changing the aspect ratio (height/width), the non-dimensional water front positions were changed. From this fact, it is considered that the position of the waterfront cannot be used as the scaling measure for this problem. On the other hand, the gravity-center positions of the water region obtained by the experiments for both cases showed in very good agreement with the numerical results for all cases. As the conclusion, the gravity-center position should be used as the scaling measure instead of the water-front position for the two-phase numerical simulation.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?