Current clinical practice in psychotherapy and counseling by professional personnel with different professional backgrounds
ZHANG Li-Li,YANG Peng,QIAN Ming-Yi,CHEN Hong,ZHONG Jie,YAO Ping,XU Kai-Wen,YI Chun-Li,ZHANG Zhi-Feng,WANG Yi-Ping
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1000-6729.2010.12.014
2010-01-01
Abstract:Objective:To explore current clinical practices in psychotherapy and counseling by professional personnel with different professional backgrounds.Methods:Totally 1201 professional personnel from 28 provinces were investigated by a stratified convenience sampling in this study.Among the whole subjects,there were 470 professional personnel with psychology background,314 with medicine background,190 with education background,194 with other background,and 33 subjects didn' t report this information.The study used a questionnaire of counseling and psychotherapy work to investigate the general features of professional work,types of clinical psychological services offered,usage of diagnostic criteria,methods of acquiring feedback on efficacy,and interaction with clients.Results:(1)Professional personnel with psychology background had the highest educational lever(master and above degree was 49.5%).Professional personnel with medicine background spent more time on clinical work(average 10.8 h per week).Professional personnel with medicine or psychology background spent more time in case discussion and supervision(average 2.3 h per week).But the group supervision hours and individual supervision hours in a week were all less than 1 h among all professional personnel.(2)Professional personnel with psychology background did more counseling work than other three backgrounds [(3.7±0.9)vs.(3.3±0.9),(3.4±0.9),(3.3±0.9);Ps<0.01].Professional personnel with medicine background did most psychotherapy(2.9±1.0)and medication treatment(2.9±1.1).Professional personnel with both psychology and medicine background used psychological assessment more often[(2.4±1.0),(2.5±1.1)vs.(2.1±0.9),(2.2±1.1);P< 0.01].(3)Professional personnel with medicine background used diagnostic tools more often and more strictly.(4)More professional personnel with psychology background finished their clinical work with clients under planning(3.1±0.8).Conclusion:As a whole,professional personnel with psychology and medicine background do more and better professional work than persons with other backgrounds.