Abstract:OBJECTIVE:To provide the scientific theoretical basis for clinical practice by comparing biomechanical characteristics of single compressed plate with intramedullary pin, locking intramedullary nail and simple arm external fixator with simple internal fixation devices. METHODS:Eighteen wet humeral bone specimens of adult cadaver were made complicated fracture models of humeral shaft and divided into 3 groups according to fixation methods. Fracture was fixed by single compressed plate with intramedullary pin in plate group, by locking intramedullary nail in intramedullary nail group and by external fixator with simple internal fixation devices in external fixator group. The intensity and rigidity of complicated fracture models of humeral shaft was measured in compress test and torsion test. RESULTS:In compress test, the maximum load in plate group (6,162.09 +/- 521.06) N and in intramedullary nail group (6,738.32 +/- 525.89) N was significantly larger than that in external fixator group (2,753.57 +/- 185.59) N (P < 0.05); but there was no significant difference between plate group and intramedullary nail group (P > 0.05). Under 600 N physiological compress load, the rigidity was (171.69 +/- 6.49) N/mm in plate group, (333.04 +/- 36.85) N/mm in intramedullary nail group and (132.59 +/- 2.93) N/mm in external fixator group; showing no significant difference between plate group and external fixator group (P > 0.05), and showing significant difference between intramedullary nail group and plate, external fixator groups (P < 0.05). In torsion test, the maximum torque in plate group (38.24 +/- 7.08) Nm was significantly larger than those in intramedullary nail group (17.12 +/- 5.73) Nm and external fixator group (20.26 +/- 6.42) Nm (P < 0.05), but there was no significant difference between intramedullary nail group and external fixator group (P > 0.05). Under 0.80 Nm physiological torque, the rigidity was (16.36 +/- 2.07) Ncm/degree in plate group and (18.79 +/- 2.62) Ncm/degree in external fixator group, which was significantly larger than that in intramedullary nail group (11.45 +/- 0.22) Ncm/degree (P < 0.05); but there was no significant difference between plate group and external fixator group (P > 0.05). CONCLUSION:Those fracture models fixed by single compressed plate with intramedullary pin have better compress and torsion intensity, they also have better torsion rigidity but less compress rigidity. Those fracture models fixed by locking intramedullary nail have better compress intensity but less torsion intensity, they also have better compress rigidity but less torsion rigidity. Those fracture models fixed by external fixator with simple internal fixation device have less compress and torsion intensity, they also have less compress rigidity but better torsion rigidity.

Comparison of three fixations for tibial plateau fractures by biomechanical study and radiographic observation.

Biomechanical analysis of tibial fracture fixed by three fixation devices

Biomechanical Comparison and Clinical Analysis of Three Different Fixation Methods for Medial Surface and Paries Posterior of Tibial Plateau Fracture

Biomechanical Evaluation of Various Fixation Methods for Proximal Extra-Articular Tibial Fractures

[Effectiveness and Biomechanical Analysis of Three Fixation Methods in Treatment of Posterior Pilon Fractures].

Finite Element Analysis of Three Internal Fixations for the Posteromedial Split Fracture Fragment in Tibial Plateau Fractures

A Systematic Comparative Study of Intramedullary Nail and Plate Fixation in Treatment of Extra-Articular Distal Tibial Fractures

Biomechanical comparison of three fixation methods in the repair of posterolateral tibial plateau fracture

Three Fixation Instruments for Schatzker VI Tibial Plateau Fractures: a Biomechanical Comparison

Biomechanical study of different internal fixations in the treatment of supracondylar femoral fractures

Biomechanical comparison of intramedullary nail and plate osteosynthesis for extra-articular proximal tibial fractures with segmental bone defect

Biomechanical analysis of four different fixations for the posterolateral shearing tibial plateau fracture.

Biomechanical comparison of two screw fixations in treatment of tibial plateau fractures ZHANG

Biomechanical Analysis of Various Fixations for the Posterolateral Shearing Tibial Plateau Fracture

Computational analysis of the biomechanical stability of internal fixation of the lateral tibial plateau fracture: A mechanical stability study

Biomechanical analysis of posteromedial tibial plateau split fracture fixation.

A Comparisive Study Between Intramedullary Interlocking Nail and Plate-Screw Fixation in the Treatment of Tibial Shaft Fractures

The Biomechanical and Clinical Study of Proximal Fracture of Tibia Treated with Intramedullary Interlocking Nail

Finite element analysis of a novel anatomical plate in posterolateral plateau fractures

[A Biomechanical Study on Internal and External Fixation Devices for Treatment of Humeral Shaft Fracture].

Comprehensive biomechanical analysis of three clinically used fixation constructs for posterior malleolar fractures using cadaveric and finite element analysis