Biomechanical analysis of tibial fracture fixed by three fixation devices

Qiao Zhang,Ming Gao,Peng Li,Hong-shun Ma

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1673-8225.2009.35.012

2009-01-01

Abstract:BACKGROUND: It is necessary to understand the axial compression, bending, torque changes after fixation by intramedullary nailing of tibial fracture, plate fixation and external fixation. OBJECTIVE: To explore the biomechanical properties of three internal and external fixation devices (intramedullary nails, steel and the external fixator) for tibial fractures. DESIGN, TIME AND SETTING: Observation. The study was performed at the Mechanical Laboratory Center of Jilin University in August 2007. MATERIALS: A total of 9 samples of fresh tibia were provided by Norman Bethune University of Medical Science; fixture was provided by the Mechanical Laboratory Center of Jilin University; tibial axial intramedullary nail was purchased from Shanghai Puwei Medical Instrument; steel plate from Changzhou Waston Company; external fixator was purchased from Changzhou Kanghui Medical Instrument Company. METHODS: The fresh samples were randomly divided into intramedullary nails, steel plate and external fixator groups (n=3). The middle tibia was saw to make model of type A1 fracture according to DAT classification and fixed respectively by intramedullary nails, steel plate and external fixator. Three sets of specimens were subjected to compressed axial compression test and bending experiments in the electronic universal testing machine, and to torsion experiment in the torsion test machine. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Displacement of samples under axial compression and bending loading as well as torsion angle under torsional moment. RESULTS: The intramedullary nail group exhibited less displacement of under axial compression and bending loading than the other groups, but the difference was not significant (P > 0.05); while torsion angle of intramedullary nail group was significantly less than the plate and external fixator groups (P < 0.05). CONCLUSION: The intramedullary nail fixation for tibial fracture displayed bending, torsion, axial compression resistance abilities and good mechanical properties. Plate fixation and external fixation also have strong anti-bending ability and axial compression resistance. Although their anti-torsion effect is inferior to intramedullary nail, they have good mechanical properties.