Arthroscopic button plate fixation therapy for instable distal clavicular fracture
Jianhai Chen,Yu Dang,Zhongguo Fu,Baoguo Jiang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3877/cma.j.issn.2095-5790.2015.03.002
2015-01-01
Abstract:Background The cases of distal clavicular fracture account for 12%-1 5% of all clavicular fracture cases.Distal clavicular fracture combined with coracoclavicular ligament rupture frequently behave as unstable fracture,with the opportunity for fracture non-union in conservative therapy being as high as 21%.Although partial patients with fracture nonunion show mild clinical symptoms,the symptomatic nonunion may affect the functions of shoulder joint.Therefore,most of physicians suggest operative treatment for unstable distal clavicular fracture.The operative treatment can achieve fracture union rate up to 98%.The distal clavicular fracture is characterized by fracture combined with ligament injury, and there are also diversified clinical therapies. The frequently reported internal fixation methods include kirschner wire,tension band,coraco-clavicular screw, anchor,clavicular hook plate,anatomical locking plate as well as suture fixation,etc.After fracture union,the metallic internal implants are frequently required to be taken out through operation. Different therapies have both their advantages and disadvantages.At present,there has been no unified therapy for unstable distal clavicular fracture.Arthroscopic button plate fixation therapy for unstable distal clavicular fracture is a relatively new minimally invasive treatment method,and its technology is originated from arthroscopic button plate fixation for the treatment of dislocation of acromioclavicular joint.We made retrospective analysis on the clinical effects of arthroscopic button plate fixation on distal clavicular fracture and discussed the potential advantages and disadvantages of this therapy.Method Ⅰ.General materials:Twenty-one patients with unstable distal clavicular fracture who received operative treatment in our department during the period from September 2010 to December 2012 are collected,seventeen cases of these meet inclusion criteria,namely 10 male cases and 7 female cases,with an average age of 42.6 years;according to Robinson clavicular fracture classification,all fracture cases are of type 3B fracture.Inclusion criteria:(1)Diagnosed as unstable distal clavicular fracture; (2 ) Received arthroscopic button plate fixation treatment. Exclusion criteria:(1)Diagnosed as unstable distal clavicular fracture,but has not received arthroscopic button plate fixation treatment,including open reduction Clavicle hook plate fixation,anatomic locking plate fixation and open button plate fixation;(2 )Old distal clavicular fracture.Ⅱ.Operative method:operation was performed under general anesthesia.Allow the patient to take sand beach chair posture, with head leaning to the other side.Draw shoulder joint anatomic marks under shoulder arthroscopy, and perform conventional disinfection on affected shoulder and upper limbs.The arthroscope enters the joint cavity from posterior portal;Under direct vision,establish the anterior working portal located in rotator interval. perform intra-articular routine inspection, pay particular attention to inspect whether there is structural damage to glenoid labrum and rotator cuff.If intra-articular injury is discovered during operation,immerely treat it.Under direct vision,establish the anterolateral second observation portal under arthroscope through anterior supraspinatus tendon,and transfer the arthroscope to the second observation portal through exchange rod.Along the upper edge of musculus subscapularis,inward expose the lower surface of coracoid,and use a feller to determine the madial and lateral edges of coracoid.Perform C-arm X-ray machine fluoroscopy to demine the vertical projection position of coracoid on clavicular surface,namely the conical ligament attachment position;open skin by 2 cm,and expose the clavicular upper surface.Place the anterior cruciate ligament guider on the central location of coracoid lower surface,drive guide pin into coracoid through clavicle;perform fluoroscopy to validate that the position of guide pin is corret;through guide pin,use a 4.5 mm hollow drill for drilling,introduce the shuttle wire,and take out guider.Take two 4-hole button plates,remove loop spinalium,and use two No.5 Ethicon suture to perform plate connection as shown in Figure 9.By means of shuttle wire,introduce the button plates to pass through clavicle and coracoid,place one plate under coracoid,place another plate on the surface of clavicle.Perform reduction of fracture.If there are soft tissues entrapped at the fracture end,use probe for release. Maintain fracture reduction,tighten the suture for knotting and fixation,perform fluoroscopy again to validate fracture reduction;perform arthroscopy to validate that the plate under coracoid is completely attached on the lower surface of coracoid.Conventionally close incision.Ⅲ.Postoperative treatment:Use shoulder joint protector to suspend the injured shoulder for 4 weeks.In 4 weeks post operation, allow the shoulder joint to perform passive uplifting and external rotation activities;In the 2nd month after operation,perform intensive joint traction exercise,active assisted shoulder joint uplifting as well as internal and external rotation activities;2 months post operation,when preliminary fracture healing is realized and there is no local pressing pain,start active motion of shoulder joint,gradually recover daily activities as well as muscle strength and endurance training on rotator cuff and shoulder girdle.Ⅳ.Post-operative follow-up:After operation,perform re-examination once per month,take X-ray film,examine the fracture union situation until bony union of fracture.In the final follow-up,make evaluation on patient through shoulder joint constant scoring,simple shoulder joint test (SST),VAS pain scoring and examination on the range of shoulder joint motion.Results All 1 7 cases obtained follow-up,with average follow-up time of 50 months (42-66 months).1 6 cases achieved fracture union,with average union time of 3.2 months;there is 1 case of nonunion.During the operation 2 cases of combined intra-articular injury,1 case of SLAP injury and 1 case of Bankart injury are discovered and respectively repaired.Average postoperative constant score of the patients is 93.1 points (72-100 points),with health side score of 98.3 points (90-100 points).SST affected side score is 10.7 points on average (8-12 points),with health side score of 1 1.6 points (9-12 points).VAS average score is 1.9 points (0-4 points),with health side score of 1.7 points (0-5 points).1 case of fracture nonunion,male,aged 50 at the time of initial operation,right shoulder is injured by falling from electric bicycle in drunk driving,fracture typing is 3B distal clavicle fracture;this patient has pervious history of diabetes,with unsatisfactory blood glucose control.After hospital admission, perform arthroscopic internal fixation with button plate,and postoperative conventional bracing and rehabilitation training;According to postoperative re-examination,internal fixation failure and fracture displacement are discovered;make observation until 4 months after operation;fracture nonunion, local pressing pain and obviously limited shoulder joint functions are discovered.After readmission of the patients,take out the internal implants,take ilium for bone grafting,perform internal fixation with clavicular hook-plate;In 3 months after the operation for the second time,fracture union is realized;12 months later,take out clavicular hook-plate;the shoulder joint functions of the patients are basically recovered to normal level,with Constant score of 91 points,SST score of 1 1 points and VAS score of 1 point.Conclusion Most of unstable distal clavicular fracture cases need operative treatment,but there has been no unified therapy at present.Arthroscope-assisted button plate fixation is a new operation method which has been gradually developing in recent years,which is minimally invasive,being able to treat combined intra-articular injury at the same time,realize elastic fixation of coracoclavicular,without need for reoperation.This new operation method can realize good clinical effects,but has high technical requirements.It can be an option for treatment of distal clavicular fracture.