Evaluation of lateral straight incision approach in the treatment of scapula fractures and investigation of operational details
ZhangChuan,Lei Wang,ZhangZuojun,ZhaoMing,LiXingxing,Hongmin Cai
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3877/cma.j.issn.2095-5790.2016.01.009
2016-01-01
Abstract:Background The approach of choice for open reduction internal fixation of displaced scapular fractures involving the scapula neck or body is from posterior including modified Judet approach,the lateral straight incision approach and so on.The chosen surgical approach depends on fracture location,complexity,and chronicity.Less invasive approaches are preferred when feasible, but are technically more demanding.There is an unstudied belief that patients rehabilitate faster and have less pain with less invasive dissection.In this study,lateral straight incision approach was evaluated as the treatment of some subgroup of scapular fractures.Methods 278 cases of scapular fractures were treated operatively in our hospital from 2005 to 2015,most of the cases were operated through Judet or modified Judet approach.Eighty-seven cases underwent lateral straight incision approach,46 cases (47 scapulas)of them were followed up for more than 6 months from May 2010 to February 2015.The age of the 34 males and 12 females ranged from 22 to 65 years old with an average age of 44.9.The causes of injury included fell from height in 12 cases,automobile accident in 13 cases,crashed injury in 5 cases,fell from standing height in 14 cases,torsional injury of arm in 1 case,beated by other guy in 1 case.There were 8 solo scapular fractures,1 bilateral scapular fracture with associate injuries of pneumohemothorax and multiple rib fractures,all the other 35 patients had associate inj uries,including 8 cases of craniocerebral inj ury,1 6 cases of multiple rib fracture and 2 solo rib fracture,1 1 cases of contusion of lung and pleural effusion,1 2 cases of pneumohemothorax,3 cases of spine fractures with no spinal cord inj ury,8 cases of craniocerebral inj ury,8 cases of ipsilateral clavicular fracture,1 case respectively with the inj ury of posterior fracture-dislocation of proximal humerus,cervical cord injury,ipsilateral ulnar fracture,disassociation of acromioclavicular joint caused by acromion fracture, ipsilateral shoulder dislocation, anterior trans-olecranon fracture dislocation,malleolus fracture, open fracture of tibia and fibula. There were 3 1 scapular body fractures,8 scapular surgical neck fractures,2 scapular anatomic neck fractures,5 glenoid fossa fractures,1 scapular neck combined with body fracture according to Hardegger scapular fracture classification.The time interval between injury and operation was 4-22 days,averaged in 7.9 days. Operation method:The patients were placed on lateral decubitus position under general anesthesia, entire forequarter was carefully prepped and draped in the usual sterile fashion with the arm free, associated inj ured site was also prepped if it need to be addressed.Lateral straight incision approach was performed,the incision started from the soft point of 1 cm medial inferior to the posterolateral corner of acromion in the dorsal side of scapula,extending toward the inferior angle of scapula,it could be extended superiorly or inferiorly along with the need for exposure.The fascia around deltoid and adjacent muscles were released to improve the movement between each other,the location and tension of posterior bundle of deltoid could also be changed with the ad-abduction or flexion and extension to facilitate exposure by retractors.Interval between infraspinatus and teres minor was opened to expose the lateral rim,scapula neck and dorsal glenoid.Circumflex scapular artery was routinely ligated for the expansion of exposure and placement of implants.The fracture was reduced with reduction clamps and provisionally fixed with K-wires,plates were contoured as the dorsal facet of lateral scapular rim and dorsal glenoid,the screws were inserted parallel or even deviated to the glenoid surface and this should be confirmed by fluoroscopy to avoid joint penetration.The wound was closed in layers after hemostasis and irrigation. Postoperative treatments:Painless pendulum movement and assisted movement in lying position was proceeded in the first 4 weeks,then the movement was started in standing position,active movement was started after 6 weeks and the patients recuperated 1 2 weeks later.Patients were asked to return to the hospital for follow-up and instructions for functional rehabilitation.Hardegger scoring system and Constant-Murley score were used for functional evaluation.Results Most of the patients could not regularly return to hospital for follow-up,only 46 patients were followed for more than 6 months,the mean time is 8.3 ± 7.1 (6-17.5)months.Complications such as infection occurred in 3 patients and heterotopic ossification occurred in 1 patient.No nonunion,nerve injury occurred.According to Hardegger shoulder score, the results were excellent in 40 cases,good in 6 cases,moderate in 1 case.According to Constant-Murley score,the mean score was 90.6±6.9(71-100)points,there were 37 cases in the range 90 to 100 points,8 cases in the range 80 to 89 points and 2 cases in the range 70 to 79 points.Conclusion The lateral straight incision approach is indicated for lateral rim,scapular neck and posterior glenoid fractures with the advantages of less soft tissue dissection and early good recovery,anatomic reduction and rigid fixation,especially favorable exposure can be achieved with this approach.