Air Pollution of China and Its International Comparison——Analysis Based on Sulfur Dioxide
ZHANG Zhao-li,ZHOU Ya-hong
2012-01-01
Abstract:China gained rapid economic growth in the past thirty years,but the pollution was also serious and attracted criticism from international community.The criticism was unfair because it ignored China's current stage of economic development.Since China's pollution of sulfur dioxide is very serious and the emission is No.1 in the world,we analyze sulfur dioxide only by using the Environmental Kuznets Curve theory and considering more reasonable explanatory variables such as whether the sample is coastal or not,central city or not,the percentage of industry to GDP of the provinces,the population density and rainfall of the city.All above explanatory variables are almost ignored by other research,and this is one of this paper's main innovations.We found that the relationship of China's GDP and pollution appears an inverted N shape,that is,the density of sulfur dioxide in the atmosphere decrease with GDP first,then rise,and decrease finally.Since Beijing,Tianjin,and Shanghai are different in various aspects with other six provinces,such as economic structure,the political status,population density,these cities can accept only high-end industries while leave the high energy consumption or high pollution industry to other provinces,therefore we suspect that the final declining stage of the curve is pulling by the three municipalities.After discarding them and re-do the regression,we found that the relationship between pollution and income are completely changed.Eastern provinces' sulfur dioxide concentration decline with the GDP growth,and then rise,which shows that the environmental Kuznets curve is U shaped.Therefore the degree of China's sulfur dioxide pollution dropped at 10,350 international dollars per capita is driven by the three municipalities,and this does not indicate China's overall economy-pollution path.After removing Beijing,Tianjin and Shanghai,the other six provinces are more representative of China in a way,and reflect better China's economy-pollution path.The three municipalities are just special case of China.The Curve reaches the lowest point at GDP of 7100 per capita and then rises again,indicating that China has not really reached the win-win stage of economic growth and environmental improvement.Then this paper compares China's pollution with that of developed countries,we found that the two curves has one intersection.When per capita GDP is less than 4000 international dollars,eastern China's sulfur dioxide pollution is much higher than that of other countries,but with the increase of per capita income,the historical pollution level is lower than that of other countries.After discarding the three municipalities,the two fitting curves have two points of intersection,4,000 and 10,900 international dollars respectively.When China's per capita GDP exceed 10,900 international dollars,domestic sulfur dioxide pollution will be serious than other countries.In other words,after removing Beijing,Tianjin and Shanghai,which have special economic structure and political status,the rest provinces' sulfur dioxide pollution is serious than that of other countries.Domestic data shows that the GDP in 2007 has an average of 10,480 international dollars,which means in the future,if China's development mode does not change,its sulfur dioxide pollution will exceed other countries' historical level.This is a pessimistic conclusion.Since 2003,China's economic structure became "heavier".From 2003 to 2008,the mean value of the secondary industry to GDP rose to 52.54%,as the result,energy consumption increased from 1.594 billion tons to 2.914 billion tons,counted by standard coal.The most fundamental reason for this phenomenon is in China's economic system.The government in China controls a lot of resources such as capital,land,etc.,and local government leaders are often keen on investing industrial projects,which led to rapid increase of energy consumption and pollution emissions.If there were not this wave of heavy industrialization,China's pollution may be lower than other countries' historical levels.The conclusion of this article also proved once again that transformation of economic growth mode and adjusting the economic structure are very urgent.