Abstract:ABSTRACT Monitoring the levels of opportunistic pathogens in drinking water is important to plan interventions and understand the ecological niches that allow them to proliferate. Quantitative PCR is an established alternative to culture methods that can provide a faster, higher-throughput, and more precise enumeration of the bacteria in water samples. However, PCR-based methods are still not routinely applied for Legionella monitoring, and techniques, such as DNA extraction, differ notably between laboratories. Here, we quantify the impact that DNA extraction methods had on downstream PCR quantification and community sequencing. Through a community science campaign, we collected 50 water samples and corresponding shower hoses, and compared two commonly used DNA extraction methodologies to the same biofilm and water phase samples. The two methods showed clearly different extraction efficacies, which were reflected in both the quantity of DNA extracted and the concentrations of Legionella enumerated in both the matrices. Notably, one method resulted in higher enumeration in nearly all samples by about one order of magnitude and detected Legionella in 21 samples that remained undetected by the other method. 16S rRNA amplicon sequencing revealed that the relative abundance of individual taxa, including sequence variants of Legionella , significantly varied depending on the extraction method employed. Given the implications of these findings, we advocate for improvement in documentation of the performance of DNA extraction methods used in drinking water to detect and quantify Legionella , and characterize the associated microbial community. IMPORTANCE Monitoring for the presence of the waterborne opportunistic pathogen Legionella is important to assess the risk of infection and plan remediation actions. While monitoring is traditionally carried on through cultivation, there is an ever-increasing demand for rapid and high-throughput molecular-based approaches for Legionella detection. This paper provides valuable insights on how DNA extraction affects downstream molecular analysis such as the quantification of Legionella through droplet digital PCR and the characterization of natural microbial communities through sequencing analysis. We analyze the results from a risk-assessment, legislative, and ecological perspective, showing how initial DNA processing is an important step to take into account when shifting to molecular-based routine monitoring and discuss the central role of consistent and detailed reporting of the methods used.

[Three Quantitative Methods to Continuously Monitor Legionella in Spring Water].

Research on detection of Legionella pneumophila by real-time fluorescence PCR

[Establishment of loop-mediated isothermal amplification method for detection of Legionella pneumophila].

Application of EMA-qPCR As a Complementary Tool for the Detection and Monitoring of Legionella in Different Water Systems

High Prevalence, Genetic Diversity And Intracellular Growth Ability Of Legionella In Hot Spring Environments

Detection of Legionella Pneumophila by Using Fluorescence Quantitative PCR

Investigation of Legionella Contamination in Soil

Performance evaluation of a low-throughput qPCR-based Legionella assay for utility as an onsite industrial water system monitoring method

Total and viable Legionella pneumophila cells in hot and natural waters as measured by immunofluorescence-based assays and solid-phase cytometry

Comparison of Updated Methods for Legionella Detection in Environmental Water Samples

LAMP-based Method for a Rapid Identification of Legionella Spp. and Legionella Pneumophila

PCR Methods for the Rapid Detection and Identification of Four Pathogenic Legionella Spp. and Two Legionella Pneumophila Subspecies Based on the Gene Amplification of Gyrb

Surveillance and analysis on Legionella spp.in water systems of public buildings in Xiamen

OCCURRENCE AND DISTRIBUTION OF LEGIONELLA IN MAN-MADE WATER SYSTEMS OF GUANGZHOU

Investigation of Legionella contamination in hospital water supply system

The impact of DNA extraction on the quantification of Legionella , with implications for ecological studies

Detection and quantification of viable but non-culturable Legionella pneumophila from water samples using flow cytometry-cell sorting and quantitative PCR

Detection of Legionella pneumophila in Water From Cooling Tower of Centralized Air Conditioning System

Detection of Legionella pneumophila in cooling tower water of central air conditioning system in Shenzhen City

Standard addition method for rapid, cultivation-independent quantification of Legionella pneumophila cells by qPCR in biotrickling filters

High Prevalence and Genetic Polymorphisms of Legionella in Natural and Man-Made Aquatic Environments in Wenzhou, China