Abstract:This study reports the performance of 7 types of consumer grade passive Electronic Radon Integrating Monitors, ERIM (AlphaE, AER Plus, Canary, Corentium Pro, Radon Scout Home, Ramon and Wave) and passive etched track radon detectors. All monitors and passive radon detectors were exposed side by side for 2 periods of 3 months under controlled conditions in the UKHSA radon chamber and in a stainless steel container to an average radon concentration of 4781 Bq m-3 and 166 Bq m-3, respectively. The performance of each individual monitor was compared with Atmos 12DPX and AlphaGUARD P30 reference instruments. The performance of the monitors was evaluated by estimating the biased, precision and measurement errors of each type. It was found that UKHSA passive radon detectors showed excellent performance (measurement error < 10%) at both higher and lower exposures. The AlphaE, Canary and Ramon showed excellent performance, with measurement error < 10%, when they were exposed to radon concentrations between 4000 Bq m-3 and 6000 Bq m-3 in the UKHSA radon chamber. However, when the monitors were exposed to radon levels below the UK radon Action Level of 200 Bq m-3, the only ERIM which had a measurement error <10% was the Radon Scout Home. All other monitors showed a significant decrease in their performance with measurement errors ranging between 20% and 50%. The calibration factor, which is the ratio between the measured value (background is subtracted) and the reference value, was also studied. It was found that the calibration factors of individual monitors changed significantly. Calibration measurements in 2019 and in 2023 found that the percentage change varied between -46% and +63%. This shows the importance of initial and regular calibration, and maintenance of the monitors.

Instrument Performance of A Radon Measuring System with the Alpha-Track Detection Technique

Long-term comparison and performance study of consumer grade electronic radon integrating monitors

Intercomparison of equipment measuring radon activity concentration in the air—an example from a hydrotechnical structure in Dobromierz (SW Poland)

Measurement Performance of Electronic Radon Monitors

New-designed Measurement Device for Radon and Thoron Activity Concentration Based on Gas Direct Detection.

Characterization of Commercially Available Active-Type Radon–Thoron Monitors at Different Sampling Flow Rates

Up-to-date Radon-Thoron Discriminative Detector for a Large Scale Survey

Comparison of Morphological Characteristics for Alpha Tracks in CR-39 Using Different Radon Monitors

A Simple Passive Monitor for Integrating Measurements of Indoor Thoron Concentrations

Nonlinear Calibration and Temperature Sensitivity of Makrofol Solid-State Nuclear Track Detectors for Radon Measurement

Development of new radon monitoring systems in the Kamioka mine

Effects of Atmospheric Parameters on Radon Measurements Using Alpha-Track Detectors.

Upgrade of a Highly Sensitive Monitor for Atmospheric Radon Measurement

Preliminary results from an indoor radon thoron survey in Hungary

Effects of Storage Time and Pre-Etching Treatment of CR-39 Detectors on Their Response to Alpha Radiation Exposure

An Improved Electrostatic Integrating Radon Monitor with the CR-39 As Alpha-Particle Detector.

Long-Term Measurements of Radon and Thoron Exhalation Rates from the Ground Using the Vertical Distributions of Their Activity Concentrations

An Instrument for Measuring the Unattached Fraction of Radon Progeny with Etched Track Detectors

Radon Concentration Measurement with a High-Sensitivity Radon Detector at the Yemilab

The Radon Monitoring System in Daya Bay Reactor Neutrino Experiment

Radon removal trap design and coefficient testing for the development of an effective radioxenon sampling, separation and measurement system